UNRWA gives free services to 775,000 who aren’t refugees even by its own definition!

We’ve discussed many times how the UNRWA definition of “refugee” is completely at odds with the official UN definition of refugee, drastically inflating the number of real refugees they raise funds for. They include descendants of refugees that UNHCR would never consider refugees, they include two million Jordanian citizens, they include well over two million Palestinians who are citizens of the Palestinian Authority.
We’ve seen how their “registered refugee” metric includes hundreds of thousands of people who no longer live in their areas of operation but whom UNRWA still counts as receiving services.
We’ve seen how hundreds of thousands of today’s UNRWA “registered refugees”  were not even refugees under their own definition when it started, but UNRWA registered them anyway and today hundreds of thousands of UNRWA’s “Palestine refugees” didn’t even descend from real refugees in 1948.
But this chart shows even more duplicity.
According to UNRWA, they provide services to over 770,000 people who aren’t refugees even according to its own bizarre and counterfactual definition.
Doing some digging, I found the definition of “non-refugee” spouses and children.

 

UNRWA definition of “other eligible population” includes: (i) “Non-Refugee Wives” – women who are (or were) married to registered Palestine refugees, and as such are eligible to register to receive UNRWA services; (ii) “Non-Refugee Husbands” and “Non-Refugee Descendants” (including legally adopted children) – husbands and descendants of women who are Registered Refugees and are (or were) married to a non-refugee. They are also eligible to register to receive UNRWA services. Once they are registered with UNRWA, persons in this category are referred to as Married to Non-Refugee (MNR) Family Members.

So being married to a “refugee” makes one eligible to access free UNRWA health and housing. Which would have made Palestinian “refugees” very attractive marriage partners! According to this, some 450,000 non-refugees have married UNRWA aid recipients – an astonishing number.
Moreover, even if the spouses get divorced, he or she can keep getting those benefits forever – and so can their descendants! Not a bad deal!

UNRWA’s Commissioner-General (then Director) stated in his annual report to the General Assembly in 1961: “The Agency’s definition of a refugee eligible for assistance is narrowly drawn and stipulates the loss of both home and means of livelihood as a result of the 1948 hostilities. Substantial numbers of Palestine Arabs do not qualify for Agency relief on the technical grounds that they did not lose both home and means of livelihood, i.e. they may have lost their source of income and may be wholly destitute, but did not lose their home. This category has become known as ‘economic refugees’ and includes frontier villagers in Jordan, some destitute inhabitants of Jerusalem and the Gaza Strip, and certain Bedouin expelled after 1948. The General Assembly has more than once confirmed that, despite the undoubted need of these unfortunate people, the Agency’s mandate does not extend to them.

That was 1961. Since then, “The present Agency position is that, while registered for the purposes of receiving UNRWA services, these persons are not counted as part of the official registered Palestine refugee population. Except for descendants through the male line, UNRWA does not accept new applications from persons wishing to be registered in these categories.
So if a person was considered a “frontier villager” or “Jerusalem poor” in 1950, even though they weren’t refugees and the UN consistently said they are not to receive UNRWA services during the 1950s, today their descendants can continue to receive UNRWA benefits as a poverty stricken Palestinian – even if they live in a mansion in Ramallah.
Do the UNRWA donors even know that UNRWA spends 11% of its budget on people who aren’t “refugees” even under its own definitions?
The problem is, as we’ve mentioned before, that, unlike UNHCR, UNRWA has no means to remove anyone’s “refugee” status. The vast majority of UNRWA’s “Palestine refugees” are not refugees in any sense. And now we see that even non-refugees continue to receive UNRWA services forever.
There are more non-refugees under UNRWA’s own definition receiving services today than there were real refugees in 1948. That shows, in a nutshell, why UNRWA must be abolished.

Behind The Scene With David Bedein

UNRWA Faces Funding Crisis, Announces Major Service Cuts

US Funds Withheld and Incitement Concerns Lead to Severe Reduction in UNRWA Services

The United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) held a donors conference on June 2 at the UN headquarters in New York. The conference aimed to raise funds for the agency, which operates 59 temporary refugee camps for Arabs displaced after the 1948 Arab-Israeli war. With 67 nations and 33 nonprofit organizations providing health, education, and welfare services to the 6.7 million UNRWA refugee population, including descendants of the original 700,000 refugees, the event was crucial for securing support.

Despite seeking to raise $1.6 billion to cover the full UNRWA budget, Commissioner Phillipe Lazzarini announced that only 30% of the budget was raised, leading to a significant reduction in UNRWA services. The majority of the budget, 58%, is allocated to education.

However, the ongoing US policy of freezing funds to UNRWA remains a significant obstacle. The US has withheld its funds until UNRWA demonstrates its commitment to the US-UNRWA Accord, which prohibits funding as long as incitement to violence persists in UNRWA schools.

Due to this policy, UNRWA cannot access the $211 million allocated by the US this year. Recent revelations, such as UNRWA conducting summer camps in honor of terrorists involved in acts of murder, further complicate the situation. The UNRWA commissioner is unlikely to witness the resumption of US cash flow to the agency under these circumstances.

Additionally, the use of a fourth-grade textbook glorifying an Arab woman terrorist who led a lethal attack in 1978, resulting in the deaths of over 30 Jews, including 13 children, adds to the concerns surrounding UNRWA’s activities.

Maps of Israel No Longer Provided in Jerusalem Hotels

Israel Ministry of Tourism Alters Distribution Policy, Citing Smartphone Usage

Hotels in Jerusalem have recently ceased providing maps of Israel to their guests. When contacted, the spokesperson for the Israel Ministry of Tourism, Haim Katz, confirmed that this change in practice is intentional. The ministry now expects guests to rely on their smartphones for accessing maps of Israel. The spokesperson clarified that privately produced maps are available upon request, but the ministry will no longer distribute maps to hotels as before.

However, a hotel administrator in Jerusalem shared an incident where they called Tourism Minister Katz directly to request a map of Israel, only to be instructed to collect one personally from the ministry’s Jerusalem office.

Maps are crucial for visitors who may be unaware of the proximity of proposed Palestinian territories to Jewish communities in Israel. While the ministry cites smartphone usage as a reason for the change, the decision has sparked questions about the accessibility and convenience of maps for tourists who may not have reliable internet access or prefer traditional printed maps.

Get thej.ca a Pro Israel Voice by Email. Never miss a top story that effects you, your family & your community

Concerns Arise Over Abbas’ Health Amidst China Visit

Fatah Sources Report Deteriorating Health, Contradicting Public Image

Reports from Fatah sources in Beirut indicate that Mahmoud Abbas, the 88-year-old head of Fatah and the Palestine National Authority, is facing deteriorating health. However, Abbas’s recent visit to China seems to contradict these reports, as he appeared in apparent good health during his arrival in Beijing, captured by TV cameras.

This unexpected development raises questions about Abbas’s health and the purpose of his trip. It is unusual for a leader coping with health issues to embark on international visits unless medically advised.

Some have expressed skepticism, wondering if the visit to China serves as a distraction from his health concerns.

It’s not a laughing matter

Quite often, one is faced with a situation so absurd that laughter seems to be the only suitable response.

On closer examination, however, it invariably turns out that the subject concerned is far more serious and warrants a much more robust reaction.

Some people react by dismissing the topic altogether and hoping that by ignoring it, the inconvenient topic or statement will disappear on its own accord. This method of dealing with absurdities is beloved by establishment figures and politicians who do not want to face hard truths. Silence may be golden, but it is suspect because muteness in the face of blatant lies and incitement is merely another form of acquiescence and a refusal to tackle reality.

This past week has been another vintage occasion where the absurd and the fake have taken centre stage and where the responses have been utterly inadequate. In fact, there has been a total non-response to some of the occurrences.

The cold peace with the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan is a classic example of how avoiding inconvenient facts and pretending that nothing is amiss leads to disgusting hypocrisy. This has resulted in the absurd acceptance of Jordanian guardianship of religious freedom for everyone except Jews.

This situation was starkly highlighted once again when members of an Israeli delegation tried visiting the Kingdom. It has been known for quite some time that religious Jews wanting to visit Jordan must divest themselves of any identifiable Jewish apparel, prayer books and items such as a tallit (prayer shawl) and tefillin (phylacteries). Predictably, this massive affront has been conveniently swept under the carpet in order not to upset the authorities in Amman.

According to a report in Israel’s largest circulation newspaper (Israel Hayom), a delegation of Israeli Municipal leaders experienced a humiliating encounter. Trying to enter Jordan via the border crossing in Eilat, the Jordanian border guards ordered them to lift up their shirts so that they could see whether the men were wearing any Jewish garments underneath (tzitzit). Those who were found to be doing so and who were also wearing kippot were refused entry. One member of the delegation described how a border guard took off his kippah and threw it into the trash.

The secular participants who presumably were untainted by any association with Judaism were permitted to enter the country while their religious colleagues were denied and were forced to return to Israel.

There are several aspects of this disgusting event that need to be emphasised and questioned.

 

  • Why has the Jordanian ambassador not been summoned to the Israel Foreign Ministry and read the riot act?
  • Why has this blatant example of religious and ethnic discrimination not been the subject of a Knesset investigation and debate?
  • Why has the general media, domestic and foreign, buried this scandal?
  • Why are all the usual self-loathers, post and anti-Zionists masquerading as human rights champions remaining silent?
  • Why has the UN failed to convene in emergency session to denounce Jordanian violation of religious freedom?
  • Why did the secular members of the Israeli municipal delegation proceed with their visit in the face of their religious colleagues being refused entry?
  • Why are Israeli Jews still putting up with this hypocritical double standard and continuing to visit Jordan?
  • Why does the Israeli Government perpetuate the myth that Jordan is the guarantor of religious freedom on the Temple Mount when it is blatantly obvious that this claim is an outright lie?

Can you imagine the worldwide uproar if Israel were to confiscate Korans, prayer beads and head coverings from Muslim tourists?

The lack of either domestic or international outrage at Jordan’s actions confirms that when it comes to discrimination against Jews, anything goes. Imagine what would happen if ever the PLO, Hamas and friends had sovereignty in Jerusalem or anywhere else for that matter. That is why most sane Israelis will have nothing to do with giving them the opportunity to do so.

In a recent report in the UK Jewish Chronicle the Palestinian National Council President stated that Palestinians, Arabs and Muslims have inhabited Jerusalem for over one and half MILLION years while Jews have only been in the region for six thousand years. According to his logic it followed that Palestine in its entirety belongs to the Palestinians and to nobody else which means that it cannot be shared with anyone.

If ever there was a pronouncement worthy of uncontrolled laughter, this assertion would be a prime candidate for derision.

The problem, however, is that even statements as ludicrous and historically fake as this one become the accepted gospel. Truth and facts do not matter because in this age of social media, the big lies gain traction and authenticity is irrelevant.

Knowledgeable and informed people may very well dismiss these fables and myths as the ranting of fanatical lunatics but the sad fact is that the uninformed and anti-Israel masses will lap it up. In the blink of an eye or more likely as quick as it takes to turn on a smartphone or, these moronic claims will circle the globe.

Amazingly but not surprisingly, it is not just the misinformed masses who fall for this sort of poisonous garbage.

One would logically think that given the almost daily outpouring of incitement and historical fantasies against Israel and its Jewish connection that at least foreign Governments might be prepared to take a stand.

No such luck, however, as the US State Department once again proves.

The US Assistant Deputy Secretary of State declared that “we want to rebuild relationships with the Palestinians.” The Biden Administration has provided nearly one billion dollars in aid to the PA. All this and more in the pipeline, despite the PA rewarding murderers of Israelis and promoting revisionist rubbish.

As if all this was not enough to make one convulse in anger rather than laughter, this following item should take first prize.

It seems that Israel’s Security Minister has decided to put an end to security prisoners (a polite term for incarcerated terrorists) receiving free dental treatment. When I first read this, it seemed unreal. Ordinary hard-working Israelis have to pay out large sums of money in order to receive dental care while jailed terrorists are entitled to have their teeth fixed for free!!

I am now waiting for the expected eruption of outrage from the usual suspects at the horrendous prospect of this benefit being terminated.

One doesn’t know whether to laugh or cry.

Amnesty’s new Israel report goes to war with reality

The nongovernmental human rights organization Amnesty International does some valuable work around the world. This includes bringing attention to human rights abuses such as China’s genocide against its Uyghur Muslim population, for example. Unfortunately, when it comes to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, Amnesty’s work often fails the truth test.

A new report released on Monday emphasized as much. Focused on Israel’s recent mid-May conflict with the Palestinian Islamic Jihad, or the PIJ, Amnesty’s report misreads both the laws of war and the nature of the battles.

Click  here to read full article. 

Imam Mohammad Tawhidi on Peace Between Jews and Muslims: Permissible and Achievable

Imam Mohammad Tawhidi is an Islamic scholar, educator, and vice president of the Global Imams Council (GIC), a global council of fourteen hundred Islamic scholars and faith leaders, both Sunni and Shia, from a wide array of Islamic sects and schools of thought. Tawhidi spoke to a June 9th Middle East Forum Webinar (video) about the prospects for peace between Muslims and Jews. The following is a summary of the imam’s comments:

click here to read full article. 

Gaza kids camp

How unsurprising

“Life is full of surprises. Not all these surprises are pleasant, so you need to be ready for what life brings you.”

This anonymous quote encapsulates the situation prevailing today where many are still caught unaware by developments that with a little foresight, could have been anticipated.

Even when past events clearly pointed to disastrous and calamitous outcomes, an unerring ability to tread down the same path years later seems to prevail. For some inexplicable reason, Jewish people seem to be afflicted with this defective genetic attribute more than other groups.

Our history, ancient and modern, is full of examples of this phenomenon.

Just read the “tzoris” that Moshe had to put up with during the forty-year odyssey in the wilderness. After entry to the Promised Land, the same backstabbing and relapses reoccurred with monotonous and disastrous results.

Today, in addition to the eternal efforts of our enemies to target Israel and Jews in general, we continue to face undermining on the part of self-loathers who have this uncanny ability to join hands with external haters.

It is amazing how many times our decision-makers and non-elected Diaspora machers are surprised whenever the recycled slanders and machinations surface. One would think that by now they might have learnt the lessons of the past.

The latest crop of “surprises” should have been anticipated because, as King Solomon said a long time ago “there is nothing new under the sun.”

Hard on the heels of the Nakba Day fiasco at the United Nations General Assembly, where President for Life, Abbas, spewed a litany of lies and received a standing ovation for his efforts, the PA and others commemorated Naksa Day. You can be forgiven if you do not know what this particular piece of revisionist history is all about because so far it has received far less media exposure.

The first week in June is the anniversary of the 1967 Six-Day War when miraculously, Israel managed to avert a planned genocidal massacre of Jewish Israelis. Anyone born before 1967 can still remember the events leading up to that fatal period. Nasser of Egypt, together with the leaders of Syria, Jordan and Iraq, were poised to attack Israel and hurl any remaining Jews into the sea. Their intentions were no secret and the mob hysteria among the masses is recorded for posterity. Israel stood alone in the face of this impending doom. Abandoned by the USA, which reneged on its promised support and by the UN and international community, which issued pious pontifications but preferred to look the other way, the days preceding the outbreak of war were filled with dread. Teenagers helped to dig mass graves in parks in anticipation of horrendous casualties.

Unfortunately, these moments leading up to the Six-Day War tend to be forgotten by those born since 1967. The revisionists have had a field day, completely erasing the genocidal threats and focusing instead on what followed. The complete and utter defeat of the Arab forces arraigned against Israel resulted in the liberation of Judea, Samaria, the Golan and Jerusalem. Following the failure to annihilate the Jews, the myth of a fake Arab Palestine with Jerusalem as its make-believe capital was born. Anointed as the “patron saint” of religious freedom, the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan successfully whitewashed its own shameful ethnic cleansing of Jews from the Old City.

This is how Naksa Day was created. Like the commemoration of the catastrophic creation of Israel in 1948, it mourns the defeat of the plan to destroy Israel in 1967. Needless to say, the same individuals and groups, with the help of the usual media who have elevated Nakba Day to sacred status, join together on Naksa Day observing yet another lost opportunity to wipe out the Jewish State.

All that is missing is the “hechsher” of the UN. No doubt and unsurprisingly to all but those mesmerised by the progressive left, this will follow in short order.

The UN, of course, never fails to prove how toxic and irrelevant it has become.

North Korea has been elected to the World Health Organization executive board. This pariah nation which breaks every record by its human rights abuses and bullying tactics against democratic neighbours and successfully thumbs its nose at the world community is elected to the WHO. One couldn’t make this up.

If you think that this piece of Orwellian doublespeak is some sort of aberration, you haven’t seen anything yet.

Iran, which clearly articulates its ambition to rid the world of the “Zionist colonialist apartheid entity”, has been rewarded by being appointed as a Vice President of the UN General Assembly. Concurrently this same regime has also been appointed rapporteur of the Disarmament and Non-Proliferation Committee of the UN General Assembly.

Here is a regime that thumbs its nose at the international community, develops nuclear missiles, exports terror and persecutes women, gays and Baha’is. Iran is now being rewarded by an organisation too corrupt and morally bereft to stand up for its long abandoned principles.

The fact that the few remaining democracies at the UN do not collectively refuse to go along with this farce should surprise nobody.

Like their predecessors in 1939 and 1967 they prefer to kick the can down the road and believe that appeasing the bullies with diplomatic goodies will avert the evil decree. Most Israelis know from bitter experience that this agenda leads to ultimate chaos and disaster.

When, sooner rather than later, the inevitable mess hits the fan the only ones who will be surprised are those who live in a parallel universe of make-believe fantasy.

Meanwhile, back in the good old USA, where mass shootings are an almost daily occurrence, the Secretary of State and Vice President had nothing better to do than once again lecture Israel.

Antony Blinken in an address to AIPAC, uttered these “memorable” words of admonition: “settlement expansion clearly presents an obstacle to the horizon of hope we seek.”

Presumably, it is only the sight of Jews returning to their historical heartland which creates obstacles. One needs to ask what sort of horizon of hope is being sought. In the absence of any condemnation of PA incitement, sponsorship of terror and payments for the murder of Israelis one has to assume that, as usual, it is only the Jews who are the villains impeding the dawn of the age of brotherly and sisterly love.

With Abbas being given a pass to continue spouting revisionist garbage without any adverse consequences, the Biden Administration unsurprisingly continues to promote a totally warped and futile policy.

Kamala Harris, not to be outdone, burbled total nonsense about judicial reform. As Israel’s Foreign Minister aptly responded, “She has obviously not read a word of the proposed reforms.” Of course, she hasn’t, but why should she when prattling inanities written by an uninformed speech writer is par for the course?

Don’t be surprised when in the very near future, the Americans will triumphantly announce a breathtaking agreement with Iran. It may not take place in Munich, but the end results will be similar.

Now is the time for all the ostriches at the UN to take their collective heads out of the sand. Unfortunately, based on past performances, it will all be too late.

Hopefully, Israel will be the least surprised and act accordingly.

Biden’s Ambassador to Israel Approved Grant Aimed at Delegitimizing Israel, Emails Show

The Biden administration’s outgoing ambassador to Israel personally signed off on a controversial $1 million grant to a program critics said was meant to delegitimize Israel, according to internal State Department communications obtained by the Washington Free Beacon.

U.S. ambassador to Israel Thomas Nides approved the funding project in a January 2022 internal “action memo,” according to a trove of internal emails obtained by the America First Legal Foundation through a Freedom of Information Act request for information about the grant. The emails detail how Nides personally cleared the State Department to offer $987,654 for groups to investigate alleged human rights abuses in Israel, the West Bank, and the Gaza Strip.

Those applying for the grant were instructed to probe the Israeli government for “documentation of legal or security sector violations and housing, land, and property rights.” The cash would essentially empower activist groups critical of Israel to pursue false claims that the Jewish state is systematically abusing Palestinians and stealing their land. With taxpayer cash at their disposal, these nonprofit groups could advance an agenda that pro-Israel advocates say fuels the delegitimization of Israel on the international stage by incentivizing a disproportionate focus on the supposed missteps and abuses of the Jewish State.

The taxpayer-funded initiative, which the Free Beacon first reported in March 2022, prompted a congressional investigation. Lawmakers accused the Biden administration of working to isolate Israel and bolster the anti-Semitic Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions movement (BDS), which wages economic warfare on the Jewish state. The United States government, critics said, should not be funding efforts to paint Israel as a pariah state.

The ambassador’s involvement in the funding effort is certain to attract congressional scrutiny as Israel’s defenders on Capitol Hill worry the Biden administration is alienating the Jewish State. President Joe Biden has been openly critical of Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu, and the State Department was found to be bankrolling far-left groups seeking to topple the prime minister’s governing coalition.

The emails show State Department officials working to get the grant approved so they could post it publicly on the department’s website. Subsequent emails show State Department employees discussing potential grant proposals submitted by various organizations looking to cash in. America First Legal, which began investigating the grant last year, says the emails indicate Nides, who is expected to vacate his post this summer, signed off before the grant was published.

“Best news to wake up to on a Monday!” one State Department employee wrote upon getting confirmation that the grant had been approved.

A State Department spokesman would not comment on Nides’s involvement in the program, saying, “as a general matter, we do not discuss internal government communications.”

While the State Department initially indicated to the Free Beacon that the grant had been canceled, it later clarified that statement to say that “no grant was awarded for this funding opportunity.” The spokesman, however, would not clarify what exactly that means, or provide the Free Beacon with updated information about the funding proposal.

“As the review of proposals is part of internal deliberations processes within the Department of State, we are unable to publicly share details regarding status or outcomes,” the spokesman said.

The ongoing opacity surrounding the program threatens to reignite a congressional battle with the State Department, which has been under pressure for more than a year to pull the taxpayer funding. Congressional sources who have been tracking the issue said it is unacceptable for the State Department to withhold information about a publicly available grant program.

Sen. Ted Cruz (R., Texas) and 11 other Republican lawmakers pressured the State Department last year to cancel the program, saying that it would embolden the global BDS movement.

“As a policy matter, it is wholly unacceptable for the State Department to fund NGOs to delegitimize and isolate Israel,” the lawmakers wrote in a letter, following the Free Beacon’s initial report on the grant. The State Department, the lawmakers said, is using taxpayer dollars to promote a “new anti-Semitism” that is “driven by a global network of anti-Israel nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) and human rights groups.”

Cruz, in separate comments to the Free Beacon last year, accused the Biden administration of using “American taxpayer money to subsidize the international NGO campaign to demonize and isolate Israel.”

The America First Legal Foundation, which discovered Nides’s involvement in the grant program through a FOIA request, also launched an investigation into the matter last year, the Free Beacon reported.

Lawmakers and pro-Israel advocacy groups view the funding as part of a larger effort to mainstream the BDS movement and undermine Netanyahu’s government at a time when Israel is facing a renewed wave of terrorism. The State Department in particular has come under scrutiny for hiring several people who worked in the anti-Israel community and promoted the BDS movement.

The State Department, in its comment to the Free Beacon, maintained that these “programs are intended to foster respect for human rights and the rule of law and support democracy globally.” The State Department “carefully reviews all eligible proposals per our well-established and rigorous review process.”

Silence is not an option

Not one government in the world – including Israel – is ready to demand that the PA must repeal its law that if you murder a Jew you get a salary for life.

Not one Member of the Knesset is ready to support the demand that the PA must repeal its law that if you murder a Jew you get a salary for life.

This is the time to speak up that the PA must repeal its law that if you murder a Jew you get a salary for life. 

Here is that law: 

https://israelbehindthenews.com/2017/01/11/incentivizing-terrorism-palestinian-authority-allocations-terrorists-families/

The message has to be made clear to the PA, which works under the aegis of the Palestine Liberation  Organization: 

Not one penny to the PA until it repeals that law.