Official Palestinian Radio News: The Voice of Palestine (V.O.P.) February 15-16th

Quote of the Day-February 15

The terrorism (by Israel) yesterday involved the use of gas bombs which we do not know how to treat this poison. We are against escalation and terror. We are in favor of a just and comprehensive peace not just for our sake but also for the sake of the Israelis and the region of the Middle East. There is a role for Turkey, an international, a role for Europe, a role for Russia and for the United States and a role for the Arab states. We call for an international effort, quickly, to put a stop to this military escalation against our people”.
Yasser Arafat from Ankara press conference Wednesday, broadcast Thursday morning 7:03 a.m.

Summary and Analysis, February 15/16

From Thursday afternoon and through Friday mid-day, the Voice of Palestine headlined what it said were reports from the “Hebrew press” (al-suhuf al’ibriyya: Hebrew newspapers) that Israel was on the verge of launching full military operations against the Palestinians.

Friday’s broadcast stressed on-going artillery attacks on Khan Yunis, Bethlehem and El-Bireh, according to V.O.P., that, according to V.O.P. had caused widespread power blackouts. Palestinian Radio also stressed the stern nature of the Israeli blockade placed on Palestinian towns and cities.

At the same time there was an important change in coverage in the last two days: Yasser Arafat has come full center stage in the news reports-something that had not been seen since the “independence intifada” began in late September. This could mean that Arafat feels he needs to buttress his image and/or it could mean that there is more internal criticism of and frustration with Arafat’s leadership than what has been previously believed.

During its broadcasts on Thursday, V.O.P. continued and enlarged the process (begun Wednesday February 14) of building a heroic profile of the bus driver who rammed his bus into a bus stop south of Tel Aviv yesterday.

The Voice of Palestine did not call Ala Khalil Abu Alba a hero, but its strongly sympathetic treatment of him [ordinary working man, father of five, no known political attachments] left an unmistakable tone with listeners that the driver was being victimized and that he might even be worthy of respect.

Yasser Arafat was quoted throughout the day as calling the incident “an ordinary accident which could have taken place anywhere.” There was no condemnation whatsoever.

The central theme of the day was not terror against Israel but by Israel which was, according to the PLO’s UN representative in Geneva-nabil Ramlawi, escalating its war crimes on all fronts and evading any international investigations.

Palestinian radio emphasized the theme that Israel was preparing for war against the Palestinian Authority, using any and all military means and political stratagems. During its 9PM evening news round-up, it cited widely disparate Israeli officers such as Binyamin Ben Eliezer, (General Oren Shahor (Labor Party, former coordinator of West Bank for Israel) and former General Rafael Eytan are advocating liquidating leading PA officials, according to the V.O.P. report.

Even as it stressed that Israel was heading to war, V.O.P. highlighted claims by Arafat and other PA leaders that Israel was using illegal and immoral weapons systems using poison gas or uranium. At the same time, Israel was stopping Muslims from completing their religious duty to visit Mecca as pilgrims.

Part of the Israel-is-going-to-war picture was furnished by the government coalition developments in Israel. In the evening, V.O.P. reported at 9 p.m. that “defeated prime minister Ehud Barak” was accepting the “army portfolio” from Ariel Sharon-a reference to Barak’s designation as defense minister in the presumed Sharon-led national unity government.

Thursday Morning Headlines. February 15, 7 a.m. / 8 a.m. / 9 a.m.

  • “His Excellency President Yasser Arafat called for an international presence on Palestinian territory as a base to stop the dangerous Israeli aggression against our people;
  • During a press conference with Turkish Foreign Minister Ismail Jinn, his excellency also stressed the dangers of poison gas used by Israel as well as other strange measures used in Khan Yunis.;
  • “His Excellency said the Palestinian people clung to a just and lasting peace, refusing escalation and terrorism.;
  • His Excellency said Palestinian-Turkish relations were strong.;
  • Occupation forces shelled neighborhoods in Al-Aroub camp and the town of Yatta near Hebron;
  • Masses of our people escorted the two exalted martyrs in two funerals in Tulkarm and Gaza, the martyred officer Mas’oud Ayyad and the martyr First mate Ayyid Abu-Harb. The national Authority said Israel would bear the blame for the escalation that would result from the assassinations and its aggression against our people;
  • Occupation forces imposed a land, sea and air blockade on all Palestinian territory in the (West) Bank and Gaza, imposing a siege on all towns and cities;
  • The military authorities extended the custody for 15 days of Ala Khalil Abu Alba from Sheikh Radwan in Gaza for investigation while he is being treated in one of the hospitals, after his being critically wounded. And Abu Alba was wounded yesterday when the bus he was driving struck several Israeli soldiers, killing eight and injuring 21;
  • Egyptian Foreign Minister Amr Moussa say that the assassination policy of Israel against the Palestinians is a source of escalating violence. And Mousa said such assassinations only open the door to more violence and that every action leads to a reaction;
  • Jordanian foreign minister Tailib al-Rifai says that the dangerous escalation of Israel in Palestinian territory is the source of great worry to Jordan and the region;
  • Russian foreign minister Ivan Ivanov says Russia desires that new prime minister Ariel Sharon will take steps to put an end to the conflict.;
  • The Arab states strongly condemned the steps Israel was taking against our people, especially the assassination of Masoud Ayyad of Force 17. and blamed Israel for the escalation in the violence.demanding international protection for our people and condemning the war crimes being committed against our people;
  • The defeated Israeli prime minister Ehud Barak expressed his confidence that an agreement would soon be reached to form a national unity government headed by the leader of the Israeli Right, prime minister-elect Ariel Sharon.but he was not sure he (Barak) would participate in it.”

Thursday Morning Round-up Headlines, February 15

  • “His Excellency President Yasser Arafat in Ankara renews his call for an international presence in Palestinian territory to stem the savage Israeli aggression against our people (Note: this item was repeated in roughly identical form through 18 consecutive newscasts throughout the day);
  • “His Excellency extolled the state of Palestinian-Turkish relations and Palestinian-Syrian relations;

Note: V.O.P. broke from usual format and used Arafat footage from yesterday’s trip to Turkey at the top of its show, even before the bulletin headlines. The reason for this change is not clear, but perhaps it was a way of showing Arafat in good form and in control. Arafat spoke well and without interruption or noticeable stutter.

Thursday Afternoon February 15 Mid-day Round-up and Panorama Magazine, 2 p.m.

  • “The slaughter and murder of our innocent citizens continues despite international condemnations;
  • Today the Israeli authorities cold-bloodedly murdered the youth Nasser Muhammad Hasanat, 20 years old, contending that he was trying to enter the settlement of Kfar Darom, south of Gaza, and opened fire on him;
  • The reinforced Israeli blockade continues in all prefects, turning the homeland into a prison, preventing the entry or exit from any city;
  • On the political front, his excellency the president returns from a diplomatic tour of several countries.demanding an investigation into the use of poison gas;
  • The UN’s investigation commission speaks to the Minister of Labor.”

Friday February 16 Morning News 8 a.m.

  • “Occupation forces shell residential neighborhoods in El-Bireh, Hebron and southern Gaza;
  • His Excellency the president holds discussion with the European representative to the peace process (Miguel Angel Moratinos) regional topics in the shadow of the Israeli military escalation;
  • Agreement on establishment a national unity government in Israel between Labor and Likud, and Binyamin Netanyahu courts Sharon from Washington;
  • The Home Rule Minister (Saeb Erikat) warns Israel about abandoning (literally: scratching off) the source authority of the peace process;
  • The Hebrew newspapers say the Occupation forces are about to launch painful military operations against Palestinian personalities, especially against leaders of the Fatah Movement.”

Official PA radio news – . P.B.C. V.O.P. (Voice of Palestine) Radio: February 14th – Official P.A. Reaction to Bus Killings

Quote of the Day

“And I believe that in a civilized world Sharon would be brought before an international tribunal for crimes against humanity. If he were Milosovic or Pinochet or even Heidar who was elected and chosen as a deputy minister, as a partner in a government and not as the prime minister in Austria, but only as a partner. Sharon’s history is a death sentence for respect for human rights especially for Palestinians and Arabs.”
PA Minister Hanan Ashrawi in morning interview, 8:30 a.m. on V.O.P., approximately at time of bus massacre.

Evening Summary and Analysis

V.O.P. opened its evening news with Yasser Arafat’s call for an international presence to protect Palestinians against Israeli aggression and its “dangerous escalation.” Through the 8PM evening news, the Voice of Palestine was still treating the bus massacre as an accident.

“Referring to the event in Holon, south of Tel Aviv, President Arafat said it was ‘an ordinary event and not terrorism, and the driver was arrested and his crime will be investigated,'” V.O.P. quoted Arafat as saying (during a press conference in Turkey) in its 8PM round-up.

V.O.P. also quoted Arafat as saying the Palestinians clung to a full and comprehensive peace and the rejection of violence, based on the peace process linked to UN resolutions 242 and 338 and the principle of territory for peace.

There was no condemnation of the bus attack, but there was continuous condemnation of Israeli “state terror.” (Despite an Israel Television report of a PA official issuing a disapproval of the bus attack, nothing of this kind was broadcast on Voice of Palestine or PA state television.)

PA presidential secretary Taib Abdel-Rahim was quoted throughout the day during bulletins, warning Israel that its actions were going to lead “to an explosion.”

At Seven PM Wednesday evening, V.O.P. reported that in a split-session of the Palestinian Legislature (Ramallah/Gaza), legislators condemned Israel for its policy of “state terrorism.”

Bus Massacre and Escalation

First news on V.O.P. of the bus massacre at the Holon Junction came at 8:57 a.m. from senior V.O.P. commentator Youssef al-Kazaz, who was at the tail-end of his Mishwar al-Sabah (“Morning Dialogue”) show.

Al-Kazaz said seven Israeli soldiers were killed and ten others (not necessarily soldiers from the way it was phrased) when hit by a bus.

During the 9:00 a.m. news bulletin, the same basic details were repeated along with the fact that the man driving the bus was a Palestinian from Gaza who regularly drove buses for the Israeli Egged Bus Company. There was no intimation that the man had deliberately carried out an attack, and there was scant information about him as well, only that he was wounded, too. The bus incident was sandwiched between news of a new martyr (see below) and funeral arrangements for Mas’oud Ayyad, the Force 17/Hezbollah commander who was killed by Israeli missiles yesterday.

During the 10:00 news show, V.O.P. said the bus driver had been driving for the Egged Company for five years (a detail taken apparently from the Voice of Israel). The bus massacre was not treated as an “attack” or “operation” by the news writers at V.O.P., but with language suggestive of a bus accident.

(At both nine and ten, V.O.P. opened its news with the “assassination” of ‘Ayid Khalid Abu-Harb which was condemned at length by Yasser Abd-Rabbo and other PA officials. No one at V.O.P. drew any connections between the bus attack and Israeli “assassinations/liquidations” over the last week.)

At the time of the attack, PA minister Hanan Ashrawi was describing Israeli “war crimes” in an interview from Washington. During the interview (8:20-8:32 a.m.), Ashrawi mapped out the PA’s press strategy in the United States: to depict Israeli leaders in general as war criminals who need to be brought to justice, particularly Ariel Sharon whom Ashrawi likened to August Pinochet, Slobodan Milosevic and Jorg Heidar.

In its 12-noon news round-up V.O.P. led with the headline that the Palestinian Authority rejects any responsibility for the bus incident.

It reported that PA officials-particularly parliamentary affairs minister Nabil Amr — said Israel officials had only themselves to blame for the escalation of violence. Later in the day, this comment was echoed in an on-air interview by Yasser Arafat himself.

V.O.P. identified the bus driver as Ala Khalil Abu Alba, the father of five children. V.O.P. said this identification was based on Israeli police sources. V.O.P. said the driver was seriously wounded in an Israeli operation involving helicopters. V.O.P. said its Gaza correspondent said the driver “had no connection to any political organization,” and that he lives in the Sheikh Radwan neighborhood of Gaza.

Wednesday Morning February 14, Summary and Analysis

V.O.P. opened its morning news with the martyring of several citizens, and at 9:00 a.m. it led its news with the assassination of another citizen.

Throughout broadcasts today and yesterday, Israel is being depicted as a cold-blooded murderer-not only of Fatah commanders but also of innocent children. (Israel has denied involvement with several of the deaths, including the death of a 14-year-old boy)

Quotes from Interview with Hanan Ashrawi, February 14, 8:20-8:32 a.m.

“There is strong worry (about Sharon) and we have to study all the possibilities about what kinds of irresponsible plots Sharon could put forward, or maybe (Note: these next few words were said with a kind of snort as if to deprecate the possibility of their being at all true) whether he might have changed.

We, as Palestinians, we have made it clear that we cannot accept a person like Sharon as a partner for peace because we realize who Sharon is. We know his past history and his hands which are covered with blood and with a chain of massacres and crimes he committed…We as Palestinians cannot except that Sharon has undergone a change, that he has broken with the past, that he is a new person…And I believe that in a civilized world Sharon would be brought before an international tribunal for crimes against humanity. If he were Milosovic or Pinochet or (note: interviewer Khalid al-Qasem tried to cut Ashrawi off but she just kept going) or even Heidar who was elected and chosen as a deputy minister as a partner in a government and not as the prime minister in Austria, but only as a partner. Sharon’s history is a death sentence for respect for human rights especially for Palestinians and Arabs.”

Wednesday Morning Round-up Headlines

(note: announcer Khaled al-Qasem has begun, today and yesterday, to dedicate the headlines to “confronting Israel” as he leads into the morning headlines)

  • “The Occupation kills an officer in Presidential Security (force) and murders a child in cold blood;
  • The national Authority condemns the crime, and Fatah threatens reaction as Barak congratulates the army;
  • His Excellency President Yasser Arafat confers in Amman with the Jordanian monarch King Abdullah on the peace process and Israeli aggression against our people;
  • Palestinian and Arab diplomatic dynamism to confront the Israeli policy;
  • Reports and eye witnesses and doctors about the Israeli use of poison gas which is internationally prohibited;
  • The United Nations estimates that the Palestinian siege imposed by Israel at a cost of one billion dollars;
  • Occupation forces lock-down the airspace over Gaza in an escalation only one day before the departure of pilgrims on the Haj (pilgrimage to Mecca, that is one of five essential commandments or “pillars” of Islam);
  • The former Israeli government, its sun setting in the outward appearances of being caught between a policy of siege and assassination;
  • Palestinian refugees caught between bullets and poverty.”

Morning Headlines 7 a.m. / 8 a.m. / 9 a.m.

  • “Eight citizens suffer various injuries in confrontations at the northern approach to El-Bireh yesterday, and Occupation authorities arrest the child Taher Harubi, after his being wounded, and take him to an unknown location;
  • Medical sources in Nasser Hospital in Khan Yunis say Israeli occupation forces decided to use poison gas during their artillery shelling of Khan Yunis,… and Dr Riyad Za’anoun, the health minister has sent a letter (for assistance) to Egyptian and Jordanian authorities about the unknown poison gas used against citizens;
  • Occupation forces close Gaza International Airport… before the departure of pilgrims on the Haj…;
  • The National Authority condemns the crime of assasination of the officer Mas’oud Ayyad of the Presidential Force, Force 17, in Jabalya yesterday morning, President Yasser Arafat’s advisor Nabil Abu-Irdeineh blamed the Israeli government for the operation and for irresponsible conduct that poisons the atmosphere;
  • His Excellency President Yasser Arafat conducted talks in Amman with Jordanian monarch King Abdullah…;
  • The American State Department considers that the situation in Palestinian territory has deteriorated seriously following the assassination of the martyr Ayyad yesterday;
  • The European Union condemns the assassination policy of Israel against our Palestinian people…;
  • Representatives of the Likud Party and the Labor Party cite great progress in talks yesterday for forming a government….”

2 p.m. Afternoon Headlines

  • “The martyring of the youth Ayyid Khalid Abu Harb, First Mate in the Palestinian Navy in east Tulkarm;
  • The National Authority refuses attempts to place blame on it for running-over operation in Tel Aviv today in which nine soldiers were killed and nineteen others wounded
  • The identity of the bus driver, who worked for the Egged Bus Company for five years, is Ala Abu Alba, father of five children, from Gaza;
  • Masses of our people in Gaza escort the exalted martyr Masoud Ayyad who was killed by an Israeli warplane (note: yes, they said warplane this time, not helicopter) yesterday;
  • Israeli forces place an air blockade on Gaza International Airport;
  • His Excellency President Yasser Arafat, who held talks this morning with Jordanian monarch King Abdullah is now meeting Jordanian prime minister Ali Abu Ghaghib.”

Official Fatah Website Editorial: A Storm in a Broken Cup

Even during the most dangerous wars in 1967, in 1973 and during the Zionist invasion of Lebanon in 1982, nobody held his breath as the whole area is doing now while waiting for Sharon to come. This state of horror and fear is based on the idea that something wrong may happen to the peace process.

The Oslo Accord was a historical risk and it failed in different aspects. However, our steadfastness has increased due to our adherence to international legality and to what the intifada has already achieved. What also strengthens our steadfastness is the national unity that combines all the forces that comprise the Palestinian civil society in addition to the PNA executive, legislative and judicial authorities.

The Palestinian people, therefore, will not waste their time on wishful thinking. To us, it does not matter whether Sharon or Barak will win the elections. They are two faces for the same dirty coin. And we have to prepare ourselves for the worst.

Sharon’s election campaign reminds us of that of Netanyahu who not only refused the Oslo Accord but he also accused the Labor party of being traitors who transferred “the land of Israel” to those Palestinians who according to him have no national rights. The storm that engulfed his campaign then took him to power, and Shimon Peres sank in the blood of his victims in Lebanon.

Nowadays, we witness another storm that is highly likely to take Sharon to power after the atrocities that Barak has done. His follies were much more serious than those of Peres who bombarded Qana killing hundreds of civilians. He and the high-ranking officials in his army in addition to the gangs of settlers attack the Palestinian people as part of a state-organized terror campaign. Also, he destroyed the few signs of coexistence that remained between the Palestinians living in Israel and the Israelis, when his policemen killed thirteen Arab demonstrators. He also exerted all kinds of economic pressures and closed down all crossing points in and out of the occupied territories.

The tragic living conditions that we are living as a result of Barak’s policies make us believe that the intifada should remain regardless of the results of the Israeli elections. The consensus that formed the basis of the intifada will also remain since it embodies our legal rights: the liberation of al-Aqsa and Jerusalem, the establishment of our independent state, and the return of refugees.

If Barak turns out to be the winner, then nothing will change. His victory will help resume the vicious circle that started because of Barak’s intransigence in dealing with our national rights. As to Sharon, it is not necessary to mention the atrocities he committed against our people. One thing should be stressed here: regardless of who is the winner, any future Israeli government will not last for long due to the composition of the current Israeli Knesset.

In short, the upcoming Israeli elections make it necessary to prepare our selves for the worst prospects. A short-term plan has to be devised taking into account the following levels:

First: The Palestinian Level

Our adherence to the basic principles that are embodied in international resolutions is the first requirement that we need for our action plan. A clear and solid political position will enhance our trust in ourselves, the Muslim world and the international community. Our commitment to a comprehensive peace remains an important guarantee in our battle against the arrogant Zionists who continue to violate the international resolutions.

The clarity of the political position requires the strengthening of the organizational and administrative structure of all forces participating in the struggle. These forces consists of:

The PNA executive, legislative and judicial authorities.

The PNA shoulders the responsibility of maintaining a high degree of readiness while it is engaged in the negotiations with Israel. This will enhance the negotiating position and guarantee the continuation of the intifada.

In this regard, the role that the Ministry of Health has played during the intifada offers a good example to other ministries, with each ministry contributing in accordance with its capabilities and the nature of services it offers.

The ministry of Education has also played a wonderful role in organizing the educational and teaching process without any serious interruptions. The ministry helped maintain the level of stability that is essential for a civil society to carry out its activities.

Other ministries such as the Ministry of Information and the Ministry of Finance have also played a role. However, their future plans have to take into account the nature of tasks to be carried out as part of our continuous struggle.

Emphasis should be placed on the vital role of the security apparatus in maintaining a high level of security for the Palestinian society. The security apparatus has also played a role in the battle against collaborators who helped Israel in its military as well as psychological warfare against us.

As to the judicial authorities, they can help in the fight against corruption and any attempts that may be made to distort the Palestinian society.

National and Islamic Forces

These forces make up the hard core necessary for implementing the action plan to be devised. The unified statements expressing the political position that were issued by all forces participating in the intifada reflect the high degree of national unity we have. This will strengthen the position of the Palestinian negotiating team.

Enhancing national unity requires a higher level of co-ordination between the institutions of the PNA and the national and Islamic forces. Such coordination will help avoid any contradictions that may emerge as a result of political differences. Priority should be given to our national rights.

Public Organizations and Federations and NGOs

A third force in the confrontation against the Israeli occupation is the non -government organizations. These institutions comprise the Palestinian civil society whose participation in the intifada is essential. It is these institutions that give the intifada its public nature and guarantee its continuity.

These three basic forces that constitute our society need to have a high degree of coordination because of the complementary nature of the tasks they carry out as their contribution to the intifada. The unity they should experience in their work is the only guarantee for avoiding any risks that may destroy any achievements we have made since the Oslo Accord.

Secondly: The Arab and Islamic Level

The Arab and Islamic support for our national project is necessary for avoiding the dangers of the Oslo Accord. The intifada succeeded in unifying the Arab and Islamic front against the colonial Zionist danger. It made possible the holding of two important conferences: the Arab summit conference and the Islamic conference. However, Arab and Muslim countries have not yet played the role we expect of them. U.S. and Israeli threats in addition to the absence of a true Arab consensus as a result of the Gulf war, explain the failure of an active role by these countries.

The moral and material support that Iraq has offered for the Intifada represents a good example to other Arab countries.

Palestinian national and Islamic forces reaffirm their earlier position that Arab and Islamic countries should shoulder their responsibilities towards our cause. These countries should realize that the upcoming confrontation with the new Israeli government will be much more forceful.

Third: The International Level

The disappearance of Denis Ross and the Zionist administration of Clinton will hopefully put an end to the U.S. monopoly over the peace process. The latest statements by Mr. Kofi Anan and the interest he has shown in the Palestinian Israeli negotiations, indicate that the U.N. can play a much more effective role instead of the marginal one it has so far played.

The determination of such a role depends on us. We should continue to adhere to all international resolutions relevant to our issue: 181, 242, 338 and 194. As to international sponsorship, Russia, Europe, the Security Council countries and some Arab countries should be involved.

A more effective role by the U.N. and a wider international involvement in sponsoring the peace process will protect our rights and the peace process as well.

These expectations of what needs to be done requires a great deal of preparations without paying attention to Israeli propaganda that will eventually fade away.

Revolution Until Victory.
Special Thanks to “imra” at www.imra.org.il for calling our attention to this site.

Official PA Radio News, 13th Febuary, 2001

Assassination Aftermath Bulletin, 2 p.m.

Following the assassination this morning of Mas’oud Ayyad, an officer in the Palestinian elite unit known as Force 17, V.O.P. reacted with extensive live local coverage detailed condemnations from the Palestinian Authority. This included comments from PA spokesman Nabil Abu-Irdeineh that the PA would not be scared off by such actions and policies by Ariel Sharon and his advisor Meir Dagan (although neither Sharon nor Dagan are in office yet) and would respond to them, raising violence to a new level. PA Justice Minister Freih Abu-Medein said Israel was guilty of “state terrorism.”

The Fatah secretary in Gaza said “the Israeli enemy” would not succeed in dampening the Intifada with its policy of escalations.

V.O.P. said the death of Ayyad was the tenth assassination of a Fatah commander by Israel during the Intifada.

The V.O.P. coverage featured an unusual 11:02 a.m. live broadcast from Gaza with its local corespondent ‘Adil Za’anoun describing the four missiles fired by the helicopter-borne Israeli assassination team.

The “martyr” Ayyad, 55 years old, was described as a key Force 17 commander, and V.O.P. relayed part of the Israeli contentions that Ayyad had been working with Hezbollah (Lebanon) operatives to smuggle heavy weapons into Gaza and to train Palestinians in their use (but V.O.P. did not report Israeli contentions that this included at least two mortar attacks on Netzarim settlement in Gaza).

Summary and Analysis
Escalation: Verbal and Otherwise

For the last three or four days, the Voice Of Palestine has been opening its news shows with general headlines about Israeli escalations and heightened confrontations, even when there are no fatalities on the Palestinian side which could be headlined as “martyrings.” (Note: today and late yesterday, the deaths of two Palestinians allowed V.O.P. to begin its news shows with a martyr headline rather than a general escalation headline.) At the same time, as has been customary for V.O.P., there is scant attention being paid to Israeli fatalities or attacks on Israeli civilians that often touch off confrontations, which are then covered luridly.

V.O.P. described the Israeli use of tear gas in its news stories today and yesterday in almost-hysterical terms, today describing the gas as “poison gas” as well as “a type of nerve gas prohibited by international law.”

V.O.P. has been highlighting PA officials-as well as Egyptian Foreign Minister Amr Musa-contending that there can be no talks with Israel unless they begin from where they had left off in Taba, with the ideas of yesterday’s leaders: Clinton, Barak, Ben-Ami and Beilin. The tough talk is also laced with strong hints of threats (see interview below with Nabil Sha’ath, interviewed yesterday, translated today).

Days of Rage and Preparations For War?

It appears that the heightened V.O.P. rhetoric is meant to prepare (and perhaps even trigger) the Palestinian public for actual escalation as well as to make a case before human rights investigations and European governments for increased intervention on their part at a time when the Palestinian Authority has been more than disappointed by the statements by President George Bush, ex-President Bill Clinton and soon-to-be-ex-prime minister Ehud Barak.

In a very unusual morning commentary by senior V.O.P. commentator Youssef al-Kazaz, the Palestinian Authority virtually beseeched gunmen not to shoot from populated neighborhoods and inhabited buildings. This was not a call for non-violence or for restraint. Rather it was more like an operations manual to prevent an Israeli reprisal that would hurt civilians. The almost-plaintive commentary by Kazaz was nearly identitical-but much longer and repetitive-than a similiar call broadcast on V.O.P. from Marwan Barghouti on December 31. Then, too, the comment was not a call for non-violence but for more effective violence. The fact that this time the summons or plea came from the voice of V.O.P.’s top commentator can mean one or both of the following-and neither of them good.

Arafat is really preparing for war and preparing his public for war; and/or
Arafat still has a great deal of control but not enough to prevent wide-spread ‘freelance’ attacks by PA armed forces and tanzeem, unless he goes head-to-head with them, risking a serious loss of his intifada-won popularity rise.

7 a.m. Morning Round-up Headlines

  • “The latest Intifada news and (news of) the Israeli aggression against the sons of our people from our correspondents throughout the homeland;
  • Two martyrs in Ramallah and El-Bireh, and a farming ban in Khan Yunis camp;
  • Occupation forces burn tens of houses near the Tufah roadblock, as they use gas that induces hysteria;
  • His Excellency President Yasser Arafat begins an Arab round (of talks) to deal with developments after Sharon’s victory in the prime ministerial election in Israel;
  • Dr. Nabil Sha’ath visits Saudi Arabia to meet with Saudi Finance Minister;
  • The Fatah movement in Bethlehem calls for boycotting Israeli media because of their lack of reliability;
  • Likelihood of forming a national unity government in Israel between Labor and Likud.”

Morning Headlines, 7 a.m. / 8 a.m. / 9 a.m.

  • “Israeli aggression continues against the sons of our people leading to the martyring of two citizens and the wounding of ninety, six of them in dangerous condition;
  • Israeli shelling on several locations in the homeland… ;
  • Occupation forces continue to hold on to the body of the exalted martyr Atif Ahmad al-Nabulsi, 35 years old;
  • His excellency President Yasser Arafat meets Tunisian President Zein Abdeen Ben-Ali today in Tunis after meeting Egyptian president Husni Mubarak in Cairo yesterday;
  • The Palestinian Authority condemns Israeli aggression against our people, and the presidential secretary Ta’ib Abdel-Rahim says that the escalation carried out by the occupation army in Ramallah and Beit Jallah and Khan Yunis is unprecedented.” (fuller version of headlines to be sent later)

Quotes from Interview with Nabil Sha’ath on current inter-Arab dialogue (Monday February 12, 7:45 a.m.)

“The important problem for Palestinian public opinion is execution (of Arab commitments to donate to the Intifada support fund). They have heard us, but what we desire is execution. That’s not the matter. It’s not about an exchange of opinions but a difference of opinion about execution and framework and why this agreement has not led to a speedy execution. When the agreement is finished the Palestinian citizen has to feel it-not only in statements but on the ground.”

Question: “What message did the Arabs at the conference send Sharon in connection with the peace process?”

Answer: “The message was clear, and it was that we link any progress in the talks with the obligation of Israeli party to the source authority of Madrid, international resolutions 242, 194 and beside that the agreements and international memoranda and the exchange of territory for peace. If Sharon really wants success, then he has to abide by these rules.

And if not, then he will find an Arab nation and Arab governments in front of him ready to resist any attempt to attack us….And I think Minister Amr Musa made this point completely.”

Official PA radio news — 12th February, 2001

Summary and Analysis

V.O.P. justified the murder of the Israeli driver Tzahi Sasson last night near the Jerusalem-Bethlehem by-pass tunnel, when it announced at the opening of its 8 a.m. morning news that the dead man was “a settler from Rosh Tzurim which was built on land (taken) from Hebron.” The broadcast also used the term “met his fate” for the death of the man who took a road whose use is specifically protected by several of Palestinian-Israeli agreements commonly known as “the Oslo Accords.”

The Voice of Palestine and other state-run Palestinian media also did not condemn the murder or broadcast any calls for restraint-though this is also required by the Oslo Accords.

Similarly, neither V.O.P. nor the Palestinian Authority in any of its other manifestations found it necessary to report-let alone to condemn or to try to restrain-the actions of the gunmen who re-opened fire on the Israeli neighborhood of Giloh last night.

At the same time, Yasser Arafat’s spokesman Nabil Abu Irdeineh “condemned” (that was the term used in Arabic-“yudeenu”) the way Israeli politicians have been speaking about Mr. Arafat. Abu-Irdeineh condemned particularly the comment by Meir Dagan (a retired general and counter-terrorism expect who advises Sharon) that Arafat should be arrested by Israel if it obtained concrete proof of his direct involvement in attacks on Israelis.

Abu-Irdeineh and PA Minister of Information Yasser Abd-Rabbo reaffirmed that the PA would not negotiate with Israel except from the point at which talks left off with the defeated Prime Minister Ehud Barak.

Abd-Rabbo likened the American and Israeli statements that the Taba and Clinton ideas were not biding to “game-playing” by children. The minister accompanying Yasser Arafat to talks in Egypt basically called Ehud Barak and Ariel Sharon as well as George Bush and Bill Clinton “immature” or “un-serious” while extolling the virtues of the Palestinian Leadership which always sticks to its agreements and understandings (See interview below).

American Note

For the second day in a row, V.O.P. has been sprinkling its news programs with items of Iraqi casualties due to American and British actions. Yesterday, V.O.P. reported that two Iraqi children were killed when an old bomb left over from the 1991 Gulf War exploded.

Commentary

Several Israeli reports this morning and last night repeat the view that the escalating acts of violence-particularly the first fatal tunnel sniping and the Giloh shelling-are “rogue operations,” which Arafat opposes. But the escalating rhetoric at V.O.P.-including undisguised support for the Fatah Tanzeem gunmen and calls for judging Israel for “war crimes”-seems to dovetail with (if not actually to encourage) the escalating violence.

What is the reason for the violence and the rhetoric?

Some believe it is a way to “stir up the pot” and to insure increased pan-Arab and European involvement, but it may also be connected with the current visits of investigating commissions from the UN.–MW

Monday Morning Round-up Headlines

  • “Israeli forces continue their reinforced military and economic siege on Palestinian lands, extending their repressive actions against citizens;
  • In Bethlehem, shelling on residences and one person wounded after one Israeli meets his fate;
  • At this moment there is a shelling of the neighborhood in Ramallah that includes the Palestinian Broadcasting and radio;
  • The international commission on human rights investigate the Israeli violations and crimes against the rights of our Palestinian people, and members of the commission heard from Palestinian officials about the savage attacks, violations and crimes;
  • His Excellency President Yasser Arafat is in Cairo as part of the framework of the cooperative Arab effort to attain peace in the region based on the resolutions of international legitimacy and the realization (lit: making real) of Palestinian national rights including the establishment of an independent Palestinian state with full sovereignty and with Jerusalem as its capital;
  • The deliberations and dynamics of the Arab conference in Amman show their results, among them deep analysis and understandings on positions.;
  • Lifting of the closure of Palestinian airspace following meetings with the Israeli side yesterday, to be implemented (fully) tomorrow in connection with the Haj (the pilgrimage to Mecca);
  • Israel announces its opposition to a boycott of its products and its Finance Minister demands the National Authority lift warnings against trading with Israel, but the Authority (i.e. the Palestinian Authority) says the boycott is a decision of the masses;
  • In Israeli matters we will look at the new balance after the loss of Labor in the prime ministerial election, and at Sharon’s efforts to form a unity government with the Laborites.”

Usage Note

In the last three weeks, particularly in the last 10 days, official Palestinian media have begun to use the term “Kamil al-siyada” that means “completeness of sovereignty” or “fullness of sovereignty” when expressing Palestinian demands for statehood and control over Jerusalem. It appears that the usage is a direct attempt to respond to trial balloons floated by Ehud Barak and other Israeli officials for partial sovereignty or partial control or demilitarization.

Monday Morning 7 a.m. News Bulletin Headlines

  • “There are artillery shellings at this moment in the neighborhoods around the Palestinian Broadcasting and Television in El-Bireh;
  • Many of the residential neighborhoods in Bethlehem, El-Bireh, and Ramallah were subjected to fire last night, especially Bethlehem were 10 people were injured and one house was totally destroyed;
  • Israeli journalistic sources say the settler who was killed last night was from the settlement of Rosh Tzurim, one of the settlements of Gush Etzion built on land of citizens from the Hebron prefecture; (NOTE: the Gush Etzion settlements were built before the 1948 war on land that was purchased, and they were overrun during the war, with many of the settlers then slaughtered by local Arabs, while some settlers were taken prisoner and later traded back to Israel by the Arab Legion under Abdel-Qader al-Husseini)
  • His Excellency President Yasser Arafat is holding talks in Egypt with President Husni Mubarak;
  • The National Authority warns the Israeli army against pursuing additional racist attacks against the inhabitants of the Muasy neighborhood of Khan Yunis;
  • The International commission of Human Rights (of the United Nations) begins its investigation of Occupation violations of human rights.;
  • The opening of Gaza International Airport from tomorrow between eight in the morning until five in the evening as part of the transfer of pilgrims to the sacred shrine;
  • Sultan Qabus of Oman transfers a sum of millions of dollars to help workers of our people;
  • Seven Iraqi civilians injured and several buildings damaged in attacks by American and British planes on southern Iraq;
  • The regional development minister in the Barak Government, Shimon Peres, says that the chances of forming a national unity government are about 50 percent.”

Quote of the Day

“The member of the commission heard from Palestinian officials a detailed report on the attacks, crimes and violations. Dr. Ali Sha’ath, an official of the Ministry of International Development, announced that the economic losses since September 28 last year amounted to more three billion dollars.He said Israeli forces used various military means against the Palestinian people in an attempt to increase to kill the greatest number of innocent children and youths as possible as well as assassinating officials-a direct violation of the fourth Geneva Convention protecting civilians.”
From morning report read by Khalid Dabas, discussing Palestinian testimony to the international commission investigating human rights violations — 7:15 a.m.

Quotes from Interview with Yasser Abd-Rabbo, Minister of Information

“This is visit (to Egypt for talks with Mubarak) follows the Israeli election to review the results and to have consultations during this period. We and Egypt from the first day after the elections, we decided that we would not interfere in the choice made by the Israeli people although there are negative indications. Our position is clear. We are obligated to the agreements, ready to continue the peace process, but absolutely only from where the process reached, beginning at Camp David and ending at Taba, based on the source authority of the peace process-resolutions 242, 338 and resolution 194. We will not enter, and we do not accept and we never accepted partial or stop-gap agreements.We expect to carry out the (Taba) agreements, and we expect the same thing from the other side.

A final agreement requires a comprehensive agreement.that means first Jerusalem and the refugees and of course land and settlements which is the central matter. And all other things on which the final agreement is based.”

Question: “What do you say about what Barak said about Taba and the Clinton proposals?”

Answer: “Barak knows, Sharon knows and everyone knows that the process is not a game. When a government goes back on what it says, that is NOT SERIOUS

Important Note: “not serious” both in the common usage of Arabic and Hebrew in this context has a strongly pejorative connotation meaning “immature” or “inappropriate”.

We are returning to the point at which we arrived, and all this talk does not impress us or affect us.This is a campaign designed before the American Secretary of State Mr. Colin Powell is set to come to the region, at the gates of the forming of a new Israeli government. They all want – Mr. Barak and all of them-they want to form a national unity government with Sharon on the basis of Sharon’s program, and therefore they have to retreat from their past obligations and past positions. That’s their problem.

We believe that everything we discussed with Israeli governments is an important matter. It is something we have to work out together with responsibility. One cannot say something today and then return tomorrow and pull it back and retreat. That’s a shame.”

Official PA radio news – P.B.C. V.O.P. (Voice of Palestine) Radio, February 9-10

Summary and Analysis

Throughout its newscasts on Friday and Saturday, the Voice Of Palestine-unlike the Voice of Israel-made no mention whatsoever of any contacts between Yasser Arafat and Ariel Sharon. It certainly did not report any friendly conversations-as was reported on the Voice of Israel radio news between Israeli and Palestinian leaders

On the contrary, V.O.P. published calls from the “national and Islamic forces” to launch major demonstrations and parades in support of an unfettered right of return by refugees to their homes.

Friday Afternoon Round-up Headlines February 9-4 p.m.

  • Three citizens wounded seriously in Gaza by Occupation bullets;
  • Tens of citizens wounded in El-Bireh;
  • The (Palestinian) National Authority says that any ideas to move forward the peace process must be based on international legitimacy;
  • The Human Rights investigating commission begins its investigation into Israeli violations in Palestinian lands, tomorrow, Saturday;
  • Ariel Sharon says he wants to achieve a non-belligerency pact with the (Palestinian) National Authority;
  • Demonstrations in Iran calling for freedom lead to 20 casualties;
  • Demonstrations in Indonesia calling for resignation of Wahid.”

Saturday Morning February 10- 8 a.m. Headlines

  • “Presidential advisor Nabil Abu-Irdeineh says Israel must accept principle of land for peace in order to get security and in order for talks to proceed from point where they left off. Without this, he said, there would be no progress in the peace process;
  • The oversight commission of the Arab summit continues its deliberations in Amman today on the foreign minister level;
  • The United Nations commission of inquiry begins its investigation today-first in Ramallah, then in Jerusalem, Hebron, Ramallah and Beit Jallah;
  • Israeli Prime Minister-elect Ariel Sharon has invited the Labor Party to participate in a unity government. He met with defeated prime minister Ehud Barak and they reviewed political and security subjects.;
  • The Security Council is discussing continuation of sanctions against Libya in the wake of the Lockerbie verdict;
  • A spokesman for the American Navy admitted that it had sunk a Japanese ship yesterday near Honolulu, with 10 people missing.”

Toward the end of the news cycle on Friday afternoon’s news programs, V.O.P. began to make note of the American and Israeli announcements that the Clinton proposals were a dead letter.

From Friday mid-day through Saturday night, V.O.P. concentrated on what it called severe Israeli shelling in Khan Yunis and Hebron Thursday night (Note: exactly why it took more than 10 hours to report the overnight shelling is unclear). There was no V.O.P. mention of a PA artillery shell having been fired at an Israeli settlement in Gaza (Israeli reports said Netzarim), although there was a V.O.P. report of “a big explosion” in the settlement of Kfar Darom.

Official PA radio news – P.B.C. V.O.P. (Voice of Palestine) Radio, February 11th

Summary and Analysis

Voice of Palestine opened its Sunday noon news program with news that a special military court had sentenced a Palestinian to death by firing squad for working with Israel. An execution date was not announced, apparently because the condemned man, Muhammad Hassan Musalem, still has the right of appeal to President Yasser Arafat.

In addition, in one of its Sunday interviews, V.O.P. featured PLO Executive member Assad Abdul-Rahman who spoke of attaining refugee rights not only for Palestinians but also for Israeli Arabs displaced in 1948. This little-known feature of Palestinian ideology has not really intruded on the public debate, but the V.O.P. interview was a signal that the Palestinian Authority is not only not pulling back on its refugee demands, it is actually escalating them to include Israeli citizens, which IT (the PA) intends to represent in talks with Israel.

Instead of contacts between Arafat and Sharon (such as Yediot Aharonot and Kol Yisrael talking about Arafat’s greetings to Sharon’s new grandchildren), V.O.P. emphasized the contacts between Sharon and Ehud Barak to form a national unity government which Palestinian commentators said would not help Palestinian interests.

Rather than friendly contacts with Israel, V.O.P. is telling the Palestinian audience that the Palestinian leadership is doing everything it can to put pressure on Israel:

  • Making efforts to keep the Intifada going and even to escalate with the help of increased Arab aid;
  • Working hard to get the Mitchell Commission and the UN Human Rights Commission to condemn Israel and to cal for an international force to be placed in defense of Palestinians;
  • Pressing for a renewed Arab boycott of Israel.

Sunday Morning Round-up Headlines, February 11

  • The continuing confrontations and the attacks by the occupation forces go on, wounding a number of our citizens by the bullets of the occupation soldiers;
  • In Amman the meeting continues of the Oversight Committee (foreign ministers) of the Arab League summit in Cairo, discussing executing the decisions of the summit concerning the Intifada and the changes in the region and the changes in the American Administration as well as Sharon’s rise to power;
  • And in this news period we will take an in-depth look at the formation of the new government led by Ariel Sharon.”

Morning Headlines 7 a.m. / 8 a.m. / 9 a.m.

  • A large explosion in Kfar Darom, which was built on lands taken from Dir al-Balah, followed by a major exchange of fire and the occupation forces close the roads between north and south Gaza;
  • Occupation forces continue their aggression against our people in most of the prefectures;
  • His Excellency President Yasser Arafat received the United Nations investigating commission in his headquarters in Gaza last night asking it to proceed quickly to stop the continuing aggression against our people and our lands.
  • Occupation forces extended their aggression against our people as Occupation special forces arrested the two brothers Rami and Jihad Awad al-Dik from Hawara near Nablus after opening fire on them and wounding them;
  • A farmer was wounded when he entered his lands and was fired upon by an Israeli settler in Turmos Aya in the Ramallah prefecture, along with confrontations in Kufr Malik in the prefecture under live fire and the use of gas canisters designed to cause tears (i.e. tear gas grenades);
  • In Hebron, two citizens were wounded in the Qarantina area, and in Gaza three citizens were injured near the Mintar crossing point and were taken to Shefaa Hospital for treatment;
  • Israeli forces endangered people in 22 residences in Khan Yunis in preparation of their demolition today, and the occupation authorities threatened to demolish the homes.;
  • The residents of Al-Khader in the Bethlehem district were subjected to severe Israeli shelling last night resulting in injuries;
  • His Excellency President Yasser Arafat discusses with Terry Larsen, the special representative of the United Nations Secretary General, the latest political developments in the region and the difficult events enveloping our people;
  • His Excellency called on the UN’s investigating commission visiting Palestine to redouble its efforts into investigating the Israeli violations of the rights of our citizens. The head of the commission criticized Israel for lack of cooperation with the commission;
  • The Oversight Commission of the Arab League summit began its deliberations in Amman last night;
  • Farouk al-Qaddoumi, the head of the political department of the Palestinian Liberation Organization, said the commission would discuss ways for continuing support for the Intifada of our people;
  • Dr. Nabil Sha’ath, Minister of International Economic Development said the Palestinian Leadership would ask the summit meeting to develop an effective economic boycott of Sharon should he continue with his extreme policy against the Palestinian people;
  • The Jordanian monarch King Abdullah II called on the Israeli prime minister-elect Sharon to continue negotiations with the (Palestinian) National Authority from the point it left off with the Barak Government.
  • Syrian Foreign Minister Farouk al-Sharaa calls on the Arabs for solidarity and for boycotting Israel in response the stern (also hard-line or unrelenting or severe) position held by Israeli prime minister Sharon (Note: they left out ‘elect’) to the peace process;
  • The Israeli Labor Party says it will respond today to the Likud proposals for a unity government headed by Ariel Sharon, and sources in the Likud say Sharon aims to achieve a unity government in two weeks.

Quotes from Interview with Dr. Assad Abdul-Rahman, member of PLO Executive, participating in Human Rights forum in Rabat Morocco, 7:20 a.m.

“The Palestinian refugees got special attention (at the forum) inasmuch as they constitute 70-percent of the Palestinian people, and therefore we cannot discuss what may happen to the Palestinian people without addressing this broad political question… and the rights of the refugees cannot be discussed except through a position of principle and in the context of human rights, and this follows also from resolution 194 (the resolution referring to refugees’ rights to return home)… There is also discussion that resolution 194 is not enough. for example, we found that many of the groups (in the conference) did not know about situation of the displaced persons inside the ’48 areas (Note: “’48 areas” is a reference to Israel, referring to “internal refugees,” i.e. Arabs who were displaced from one Israeli-ruled area to another Israeli-ruled area) and that’s a third of a million or two hundred fifty thousand…

Official Palestinian Radio News: The Voice of Palestine (V.O.P.) February 8th

Thursday Midnight News Round-up, February 8/9

  • “His Excellency President Yasser Arafat receives two telephone calls-one from President George Bush and one from his Secretary of State Colin Powell dealing with the peace process;
  • Mr. Nabil Abu-Irdeineh, the president’s advisor, underscores the necessity of the Israeli side adhering to the source authority of the Peace process and implementing the resolutions of international legitimacy;
  • Israeli aggression continues against our people and their possessions and several are wounded in attacks by occupation forces;
  • Egypt calls on the Israeli prime minister-elect to embark upon a policy of negotiation based on what was reached with the previous government.”

Morning Headlines, 7 a.m. / 8 a.m. / 9 a.m.

  • “His Excellency President Yasser Arafat receives two telephone calls-one from President George Bush and one from his Secretary of State Colin Powell concentrating on the peace process;
  • The President’s advisor, Nabil Abu-Irdeineh said the two presidents-Arafat and Bush-exchanged ideas on the peace process especially after the change in the Israeli government, agreeing to keep up contacts between them (Arafat and Bush);
  • From their points of view, both Minister of Information and Culture Yasser Abd Rabbo and Home Rule Minister Dr. Saeb Erikat said both of them that negotiations with the Israeli side would not resume except from the point at which they left off in Taba;
  • Heavy Israeli shelling from the settlement of Psagot last night fell on residents of Jabal Tawil in El-Bireh, wounding two citizens.;
  • In Hebron and Qalqilya, seven citizens were wounded, two seriously, in confrontations with occupation forces using gas;
  • Occupation forces arrested five citizens in Jericho and the Ghor Valley last night;
  • Two residents of Khan Yunis were arrested according to military sources when they tried to enter the settlement of Jedid south of the city;
  • Israeli sources say that the explosion in west Jerusalem Thursday night led to the wounding of one person, and the White House Spokesman Ari Fleischer said the explosion was reminder of the need to reach permanent and just peace in the Middle East;
  • Both the new prime minister Ariel Sharon and the outgoing prime minister Ehud Barak rushed to place responsibility for the incident on the (Palestinian) National Authority;
  • The American State Department announced that Washington no longer sees the proposal of the former American president Bill Clinton as a source authority for the peace process between the Palestinian and Israeli sides, and the Clinton thoughts will not return to play a major role in American proposals;
  • Likud candidate Ariel Sharon wins with 62.3 percent over resigning prime minister Ehud Barak, and by a margin of 24.7 according to final results announced last night by the Israeli Central Election Commission;
  • Egypt calls on the Israeli prime minister-elect Ariel Sharon to embark upon a policy of negotiation based on what was reached with the previous government;
  • From his point of view, Egyptian Defense Minister Mushir Tantawi said the Egyptian army was able and ready to respond to any foreign aggression and to respond to anyone foolish enough to attack Egypt;
  • First meeting since the election today between Ariel Sharon and Ehud Barak;
  • Syrian President Bashar Assad said he believed it was possible to start a new political style in Syria, sharing power with the Ba’ath Party.”

Quote of the Day “Any negotiations with the Sharon Government have to proceed from the point left off at Taba..This is the way to security and stability in the region.” (Arafat advisor and spokesman, Nabil Abu Irdeineh in statement to Voice of Palestine-aired constantly on February 8 and February 9)

Official Palestinian Radio News: The Voice of Palestine (V.O.P.) February 9th

Summary and Analysis

The Voice of Palestine is hammering home the view that there will be no talks with Ariel Sharon unless he picks up where Ehud Barak left off in Taba.

“From their two points of view both Minister of Information and Culture Yasser Abd Rabbo and Home Rule Minister Dr. Saeb Erikat said both of them that negotiations with the Israeli side would not resume except from the point at which they left off in Taba,” declared the V.O.P. announcer in the midnight news round-up, 12:03 a.m. Friday, February 9.

V.O.P. reported in a very low-key way (Thursday/Friday Midnight round-up) that the Administration of President George Bush asserted that the Clinton proposals were source authority for the peace process. But the report did not mention that Clinton himself and Ehud Barak seconded this view. In addition, V.O.P. and the PA continue to assert that unsigned Taba “understandings” with Barak ARE BINDING on the as-yet-unconfirmed Sharon Government.

Regarding last night’s car bombing in Jerusalem, V.O.P. continued in its policy of not condemning the act, adding that no one had taken credit for it. V.O.P. noted that the White House Spokesman Ari Fleischer had said the act showed the need to renew the peace process, without mentioning any American condemnation of the bombing.

Assessment; The Attitiude of the Palestinian Authority Towards the Israeli elections

Over the past few days, V.O.P. has been adopting a two-tier information policy regarding the election of Ariel Sharon both before and after the election.

Before the Election

On the one hand, the PA took no official position on the contest between Sharon and Ehud Barak.

On the other hand, Senior PA officials such as Yasser Abd-Rabbo and Saeb Erikat focused on the dangers of Sharon’s potential election, and the Voice of Palestine ran detailed profiles calling Sharon a mass murderer whose intent was prosecuting endless war against the Arabs.

On the one hand, the PA took no stand against the planned boycott or organized blank-ballot led by the Israeli Islamic movement and various Israeli Arab political parties, respectively.

On the other hand, the PA and the Voice of Palestine missed few opportunities to suggest strongly that the election-especially of Sharon-would have a pivotal impact on the “peace process” and on the “struggle to achieve our national goals.”

Why did the PA adopt a two-tier policy before the election?

Perhaps for three reasons:

  • It did not want to be accused of interfering in Israeli affairs, especially when trying to help Barak would only have backfired anyway;
  • It did not try to make a frontal effort to overcome Israeli Arab boycott and blank ballot plans because it was likely to fail, and there is almost nothing Yasser Arafat hates more than to be shown to be suffering temporary political impotence among his own people;
  • The poll figures in Israel (which once again showed a pro-Left bias beyond the purported statistical error-the 18-point poll edge will become a 26 or 27-point official margin of victory after soldiers’ ballots are counted) made it unrealistic for Arafat to risk any more of his political capital by supporting a sure loser (Barak) and unnecessarily angering a sure winner (Sharon).

After the Election

On the one hand, PA President Yasser Arafat is taking a “we-respect the-choice-of-the-Israeli-people” tone.
On the other hand, Arafat’s top minister and advisors are saying that the Israeli election means nothing and that Sharon must implement even unsigned Barak-Arafat understandings.

On the one hand, Arafat and his advisor Nabil Abu-Irdeineh insist that they want peace.
On the other hand, Arafat’s top ministers and field officials-Saeb Erikat, Nabil Sha’ath, Yasser Abd-Rabbo and Marwan Barghouti-say the “Independence Intifada” will not only not stop but actually escalate until the Palestinians achieve total Israeli withdrawal to the 1967 frontiers, including first and foremost Jerusalem, dismantling of all settlements, and “the return of the refugees to their homes.”

On the one hand, Arafat says he wants comprehensive peace-“salaam kamil wa-shamil.”
On the other hand, Arafat and his top officials make it clear that they will not accept any interim settlements or staged withdrawals or phased agreements, and they will be ready to increase violence that will endanger regional stability. They hint broadly at effects on oil prices and a regional war.

On the one hand, they insist that they never accepted the Clinton proposals for an Israeli-Palestinian settlement.
On the other hand, they insist on the Clinton proposals as the starting point for further Israeli concessions. On the one hand, they call for an increased American role to push Israel into compliance.

On the other hand, they insist and invite the European community, Russia and the United Nations (especially Kofi Anan and Mary Robinson) to impose a settlement on Israel and to investigate, try, convict and punish (NOTE: Arafat and his Justice Minister Freih Abu-Medein are willing to skip straight to the punishment phase) Israeli war criminals.

Conclusions

Does this mean that war or even unending Palestinian-Israeli confrontations are inevitable?

Not necessarily.

Despite the fact that Arafat’s popularity actually rose with the rise in violence, the Palestinian-Israeli War of Attrition has caused severe internal crisis in the Palestinian camp.

There is a possibility that a new balance of power, a new balance of deterrence/aspirations may be struck between Arafat and Sharon, especially if Sharon is able to consolidate his government.

But this will require Sharon overcoming tremendous obstacles, and it will also require Arafat to lessen the expectations of his people, while re-educating them to the idea that “cooperation with Israel” is not something for which one will face a firing squad.

In preparation for his PhD at Bar Ilan University, Michael Widlanski has been following the official media of the nascent Palestinian Authority for the past five years.