Jerusalem – Yesterday morning, an unusual coalition of conservative and liberal factions, which usually war with each other, formed in the Israeli Knesset.

A broad-based coalition of Israeli legislators called a packed press conference at the Israeli parliament to demand the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestinian Refugees (UNRWA), be replaced by the United Nations High Commission for Refugees (UNHCR).

Kadima Knesset member Amira Dotan gave the best explanation.

“This is a message to the U.N., which in 1949 formed UNRWA with one purpose to maintain the status of Palestinian Arab refugees as refugees for generations to come,” Ms. Dotan said. “This contrasts with UNHCR, founded by the U.N. in 1950 for all refugees around the world with one purpose in mind: to help rehabilitate refugees and to relieve them of their status as refugees.”

The UNHCR helps refugees to find solutions, so they can get on with their lives.

UNRWA, however, operates under the premise that Palestinian refugees, and even their descendants, are also refugees. The U.N. body considers them refugees even if they acquire a new citizenship, as many have in Jordan – until they return to their ancestral homes and villages in Israel. Many of those villages, fled from during Israel’s 1948 War of Independence, no longer exist.

U.N. General Assembly Resolution 302, which established UNRWA in 1949, included Resolution 194’s reference to the “right of return.” UNRWA officials use that clause in a broader context where resettlement enters the picture.

The General Assembly had intended in 1949 to see refugees from the 1948 war “return to their homes and live at peace with their neighbors” at was then the earliest possible time. That was almost 60 years ago.

Subsequent U.N. resolutions over the years have added the phrase “unalienable” to describe the “right of return,” and UNRWA functions today on the basis of that presumed “right.”

Consequently, UNRWA accuses Israel of blocking the Palestinian refugees’ “legitimate rights” under the premise they must stay in limbo status until their “return” can be realized. Attempts to resettle them elsewhere have been blocked by UNRWA and by the U.N. as a whole.

A 1985 incident serves as case-in-point. At that time Israel, with the help of the Catholic Relief Agency, attempted to move refugees into 1,300 permanent houses built for them near Nablus on the West Bank. The U.N. then passed a resolution calling on Israel to desist, claiming the living improvements would violate the refugees’ “inalienable right of return.”

In 1993, at the outset of the Oslo process, then-Israeli Deputy Foreign Minister Yossi Beilin said, in a taped interview, the newly formed Palestinian Authority had committed itself to removing U.N. refugee camps and absorbing refugees. However, the new Palestinian Authority decided the UNRWA refugee camps would remain until the Palestinian refugees from the 1948 war, and their descendants, were repatriated.

Today, with Gaza completely under Palestinian control, 80 percent of of Gaza’s residents wallow in UNRWA refugee camps. And UNRWA continues to encourage repatriation under what it sees as their “right of return” to their ancestral villages inside Israel.

The UNRWA-promoted idea of the “right of return” is far from a nostalgic exercise. A Web site developed in the UNRWA camps, known as www.PalestineRemembered.com, accuses Israel of “ethnic clensing” during the 1948 war and prepares a new generation to reclaim their ancestral homes.

Refugee-camp residents, some of whom now spearhead attacks against Israeli towns in the western Negev, have been educated to believe they are the villages’ rightful owners.

The question remains whether U.N. refugee camps will continue to advocate the “right of return” by all means possible, or whether it will act in a humanitarian rather than a political context.

“It is long past the time for the care of Palestinian refugees to be given to the UNHCR so their lives can be improved rather than maintain their delusions about the ‘right of return,'” Rabbi Benyamin Alon, the National Union Member who instigated the statement against the UNRWA, said.

The UNRWA could not be reached for comment.

David Bedein can be reached at dbedein@israelbehindthenews.com. His Web site is www.IsraelBehindTheNews.com

©The Bulletin 2008

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Previous articleIsraeli Legislators Confront The UN: REPLACE UNRWA WITH UNHCR
Next articleOlmert Says He Will Resign
David Bedein is an MSW community organizer and an investigative journalist.   In 1987, Bedein established the Israel Resource News Agency at Beit Agron to accompany foreign journalists in their coverage of Israel, to balance the media lobbies established by the PLO and their allies.   Mr. Bedein has reported for news outlets such as CNN Radio, Makor Rishon, Philadelphia Inquirer, Los Angeles Times, BBC and The Jerusalem Post, For four years, Mr. Bedein acted as the Middle East correspondent for The Philadelphia Bulletin, writing 1,062 articles until the newspaper ceased operation in 2010. Bedein has covered breaking Middle East negotiations in Oslo, Ottawa, Shepherdstown, The Wye Plantation, Annapolis, Geneva, Nicosia, Washington, D.C., London, Bonn, and Vienna. Bedein has overseen investigative studies of the Palestinian Authority, the Expulsion Process from Gush Katif and Samaria, The Peres Center for Peace, Peace Now, The International Center for Economic Cooperation of Yossi Beilin, the ISM, Adalah, and the New Israel Fund.   Since 2005, Bedein has also served as Director of the Center for Near East Policy Research.   A focus of the center's investigations is The United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA). In that context, Bedein authored Roadblock to Peace: How the UN Perpetuates the Arab-Israeli Conflict - UNRWA Policies Reconsidered, which caps Bedein's 28 years of investigations of UNRWA. The Center for Near East Policy Research has been instrumental in reaching elected officials, decision makers and journalists, commissioning studies, reports, news stories and films. In 2009, the center began decided to produce short movies, in addition to monographs, to film every aspect of UNRWA education in a clear and cogent fashion.   The center has so far produced seven short documentary pieces n UNRWA which have received international acclaim and recognition, showing how which UNRWA promotes anti-Semitism and incitement to violence in their education'   In sum, Bedein has pioneered The UNRWA Reform Initiative, a strategy which calls for donor nations to insist on reasonable reforms of UNRWA. Bedein and his team of experts provide timely briefings to members to legislative bodies world wide, bringing the results of his investigations to donor nations, while demanding reforms based on transparency, refugee resettlement and the demand that terrorists be removed from the UNRWA schools and UNRWA payroll.   Bedein's work can be found at: www.IsraelBehindTheNews.com and www.cfnepr.com. A new site,unrwa-monitor.com, will be launched very soon.