UNRWA Mandate to Relocate Palestinians outside of Judea, Samaria and Gaza Under the “Right of Return”, as taught in Palestinian Authority Texts in the PA and in UNRWA school system.

By: David Bedein

Research: Dr. Arnon Groiss

The US State Department has  ​denounced a  proposal ​that Arabs dislocated from Gaza be settled elsewhere:

https://www.state.gov/rejection-of-irresponsible-statements-on-resettlement-of-palestinians-outside-of-gaza/

However, what the Palestinian Authority and UNRWA teach in their schools in Judea, Samaria, Gaza is that Arabs from UNRWA must be settled  elsewhere- under the “Right of Return”.

The Right of Return is considered a basic element in the Palestinian narrative and is expressed in the Palestinian Authority’s schoolbooks. Following are three examples taken from the latest edition of these books that are used today in all schools in the West Bank, the Gaza Strip and East Jerusalem, including those ones operated by UNRWA:

  1. The presentation of this issue to four-graders includes the Palestinian point of view regarding the creation of the refugee problem in 1948, which serves as the basis for the notion of the right of return with a view to annulling the results of that war and returning to the pre-1948 situation:

“I have learned:

 The Palestinians were forced to leave their cities and villages in Palestine in 1948 due to their harassment by the Zionist occupier and the killing of many of them, so they lived in refugee camps in the West Bank, the Gaza Strip and neighboring Arab states, such as Jordan, Lebanon and Syria, and are still there until now.

The Palestinians who were expelled from their country are called refugees and they still hold the keys to their houses and the ownership documents for their lands and homes, from which they were forced to emigrate. They have the right to return to them.”

(National and Social Upbringing, Grade 4, Part 1 (2020) p. 34)

  1. The return is not dependent on agreements or on Israel’s good will. Rather, it is an integral part of the fighting for the liberation of Palestine’s territory occupied by Israel in 1948. Following is a poem expressing that notion:

“I am the owner of the great right from which I will create the morrow

I shall retrieve it. I shall retrieve it as a precious and sovereign homeland

I shall shake the world tomorrow and shall march as a unitary army

I have an appointment in my homeland and it is impossible that I forget the appointment”

(Arabic Language, Grade 5, Part 1 (2020) p. 86)

  1. The notion of the right of return to liberated Palestine is emphasized again in the following piece taken from the same book, which ends a story of a 1948 refugee:

“We shall return; we shall return with the soaring eagles; we shall return with the raging wind; we shall return to the vine and the olive tree; we shall return to raise the flag of Palestine, alongside the anemone flower, over our green hills.”

(Arabic Language, Grade 5, Part 1 (2020) p. 84)

Response of the UNRWA spokesman 2024

https://www.cfnepr.com/205640/Movies

https://israelbehindthenews.com/?s=hamas+unrwa

This was the response of the UNRWA spokesperson:

 

 

  • Video clips have again been circulating on social media insinuating that UNRWA and its education system promote hatred and violence among Palestinian children as part of a “Palestinian terrorism education system”. This content has been shared before and appears to be being used again in the context of the war in Gaza.  

         The latest video, circulating on X (formerly Twitter), attempts to link UNRWA’s education system to violence, using clips of alleged ‘UNRWA’ students and teachers.  

         The videos do not portray the reality in UNRWA schools. UNRWA dismisses those accusations in the strongest possible terms. UNRWA firmly condemns the anti-Semitic and inflammatory statements made during some of the interviews filmed. We also have serious concerns around the potential harm caused to children through the making and publication of these videos.  

  

         UNRWA has zero tolerance for hate, discrimination or any action that could be viewed as taking sides in conflict. Our work to ensure adherence to humanitarian principles and UN values, including neutrality, represents a fundamental pillar of UNRWA’s strategy and operations. It provides UNRWA the space, access, and acceptance necessary to carry out its mandate of protection and assistance to Palestine refugees.  

         The Agency takes all allegations of breaching UN values and principles extremely seriously and launches investigations into any credible accusations, applying disciplinary measures where misconduct is found.  

         UNRWA prides itself on providing a quality education in line with UN principles to Palestine refugees. To ensure no controversial material is taught in schools, the Agency undertakes regular and meticulous review of all textbooks and learning materials used by UNRWA schools to ensure their compatibility with UN values and principles.  

         The dedication of UNRWA staff to providing services to refugees and those affected by conflict, including in Gaza at significant risk to their own safety, is a testament to their will and humanity.   

         Unfortunately, attacks such as these attempt to discredit the Agency despite the lifesaving work it carries out. 

 

Response of  UNRWA spokesman can be summarized as follows:

Denial that UNRWA promotes hatred or  violence among Palestinian children

Denial of anti-Semitic or inflammatory statements associated with UNRWA. 

Assertion that…

UNRWA ensures humanitarian principles, UN values, and  neutrality.

UNRWA investigates all credible accusations.

UNRWA activities are  compatible with UN values and principles.  

 

Red Flags

Red Chinese flags photographed in Beijing composited against snow-capped mountains in background

Warning flags on Australian and New Zealand beaches are intended to prevent individuals from endangering their lives.

Ignoring these signals often proves fatal.

Surveying the many bright red political flags currently flapping internationally and the large number of individuals and groups pretending that nothing is amiss, it is not difficult to surmise exactly in what disastrous direction the international community is heading.

Add in the phenomenon of those who revile victims or potential victims for trying to do something to avert calamitous chaos and you have a perfect recipe for impending fatal results.

Take, for example, the cries of distress every time someone points out that Abbas and his coterie of corrupt comrades are neither partners for peace nor even remotely interested in acknowledging Jewish legitimacy. One would think that given all the available evidence linking them to terror and incitement, the international community and our own delusional deniers might wake up to reality. One has only to read and listen to the daily outpouring of bile emanating from Ramallah to realise their true agenda.

If ever these “doves” were to achieve their proclaimed goal of “Palestine from the river to the sea” the elimination of Jewish sovereignty will have been well and truly fulfilled.

The PA had cancelled Christmas.

Now they have cancelled New Year.

A “day of rage” replaced these two holidays, according to a proclamation from Abbas. This is a meaningless gesture because for the PA, every day is one of rage, terror, murder and mayhem. 

Where are our political leaders amidst all these red flags?

Silent or muted, no doubt fearful of upsetting Biden & Blinken and provoking a Democratic Party already slowly but steadily drifting ever further into the murky realms of leftist progressive lunacy.

Last week, I pointed out that the so-called maritime coalition purportedly established to deal with Houthi/Iranian terror piracy was likely to turn out to be another desert mirage. So far this seems to be borne out as twelve out of the twenty nations touted to be part of this force have dropped out. From reports, it appears that the defectors’ excuses range from “not wanting to appear pro-Israel” and “being fearful of themselves becoming targets of Houthi attacks.”

This exhibition of collective moral collapse in the face of naked maritime piracy and aggression must be music to the ears of the Mullahs in Tehran. Shooting down a few drones and missiles will not deter the terrorists. A reluctance to tackle the real source of the terror will be noted and this in turn will embolden them to undertake further and more lethal action. This maritime armada may very well prove to be another US-led fiasco thanks to fickle allies and a hopelessly confused lack of will in Washington. Could it be a rerun of the 1967 scenario? We will soon find out.

Meanwhile, Saudi Arabia and the UAE, two countries one would think might be critical components of a pirate-busting fleet, have announced their “disinterest” in participating. This is yet another perfect example of Churchill’s observation that those who avoid confronting the crocodiles will end up being among the first to be eaten by them.

As the USA withdraws one of its warships from the Mediterranean, Iran sends one of its vessels into the Red Sea. Coincidence or is this a sign of things to come?

Once again, the red flags are clearly visible, but nobody wants to take any effective action.

It has been apparent for quite some time that certain nations that were assumed to be “friends” are, in actual fact, faking it.

Russia has reverted to its historical default position of supporting Islamic fanaticsThe end result is the same whether it is sanction busting by supplying Iran with the means to target Israel, championing the Iranians at the UN or ignoring gross human rights crimes. Pogroms in Russia may not yet have become official policy but the warning flags are out there. The old virus of hate is percolating away under the surface and will become full-blown again once Israel becomes officially demonised or economic problems prevail.

China, which never used to have a Jewish “problem” but nevertheless was the patron saint of Arab delegitimisation of Israel, has in recent years ostensibly been “our friend”. Economic advantages outweighed outdated political dogmas. Recently, however, the old “anti-colonialist” bug has re-infected them, and they have rejoined the anti-Israel brigade at the UN. Judaism is still not a “recognised” faith in China, and whiffs of the old Jew hate can be detected. The irony is glaringly obvious of Communist China persecuting its Uyghur Muslim minority while at the same time supporting jihadist terror against Israel.

The day is rapidly approaching when a Hamas-like invasion of Taiwan will take place – all the signs are plainly in sight.

North Korea has never been a friend of Israel, and its malign influence can be easily discerned by its wholehearted support of Islamic terror. Chinese and North Korean weapons have found their way to terror groups and no doubt Iran is also benefitting from their expertise.

South Africa is another perfect example of how a failed regime diverts attention from its own mismanagement by blaming the Jewish State for each and every sin known to humanity. Its latest attempt at vilifying Israel involves getting the International Criminal Court to find Israel guilty of genocide in Gaza. Like the old blood libels and well-poisoning lies of not so long ago, the South African accusations have already found a willing audience among the ignorant and brainwashed masses.

There are many devout South African Christians who can see through the deceitful rhetoric and policies of their Government. As in many other countries, however, the growing influence of the jihadists will overwhelm them.

It is reported that in Nigeria, on Christmas Day, more than one hundred Christians were massacred by Islamist fanatics. The silence from world Church leaders and the general media has been notable.

The Irish Government has shown its true colours by enthusiastically joining the Israel-bashing brigade. I have just finished reading a book where an Irish Roman Catholic prelate describes something called the “Irish ‘flu.” His explanation for this affliction is that those infected “have had their brains go on holiday while their mouths keep moving.” I suppose this could account for the Irish inability to make a distinction between Islamic terror perpetrators and Israeli victims.

President Macron of France stated that “fighting terrorism does not mean flattening Gaza.” So far, he has not been able to explain how else to destroy the terror tunnels that exist under every house, school, clinic, hospital and Mosque. It is obviously much easier to offer unsolicited advice instead of dealing with France’s incubated tsunami of Jew hate. The French record of delivering up its Jewish citizens and refugees to Nazi terror is not exactly a paradigm of moral superiority.

Jewish communities in countries where anti-Israel and anti-Jewish mobs are now rampant are increasingly at risk.

Warning flags are there for a good reason. Failure to heed the message will cause too many Jews to be once again caught unprepared as the tide of hate overwhelms them.

John Kirby defends UNRWA after reports its facilities are being used by Hamas

“You can’t hold them accountable for the depredations of Hamas and the way Hamas uses civilian infrastructure, including hospitals, for command and control, for storage of weapons, for the holding of hostages,” he added.

When the reporter noted that the US gave UNRWA a billion dollars, Kirby replied, “They do good work in Gaza, and they are important to helping get the humanitarian assistance to the people of Gaza. And we’re grateful for that work that they’re doing, very much in harm’s way.”

He added, “I will let them speak to whatever concerns they have over Hamas’s activities and the degree to which that they feel obligated to speak out or not.”

John Kirby: UNRWA does important work

White House National Security Council spokesman defends the work of UN agency for “Palestinian refugees” after reports its facilities are being used by Hamas.

Elad Benari


  Jan 5, 2024, 6:11 AM (GMT+2)

White House National Security Council spokesman John Kirby on Thursday defended the work of UNRWA, the UN agency for “Palestinian refugees” after a reporter suggested the US should rethink its support for the UN agency in the wake of reportsthat its facilities are being used by Hamas terrorists.

“UNRWA does important work. In fact, they’re doing a lot of heavy lifting right now in terms of trying to get food, water, medicine to the people of Gaza, all up and down the Strip. They’re doing a lot of work, and they’re doing it in harm’s way — very much so in harm’s way,” said Kirby.

You can’t hold them accountable for the depredations of Hamas and the way Hamas uses civilian infrastructure, including hospitals, for command and control, for storage of weapons, for the holding of hostages,” he added.

When the reporter noted that the US gave UNRWA a billion dollars, Kirby replied, “They do good work in Gaza, and they are important to helping get the humanitarian assistance to the people of Gaza. And we’re grateful for that work that they’re doing, very much in harm’s way.”

He added, “I will let them speak to whatever concerns they have over Hamas’s activities and the degree to which that they feel obligated to speak out or not.”

Created in 1949, UNRWA supplies aid to more than three million of the five million registered “Palestinian refugees” in Jordan, Lebanon, Syria and territories assigned to the Palestinian Authority.

However, it is also notorious for its anti-Israel activities. During the 2014 counterterrorism Operation Protective Edge, Hamas rockets were discovered inside a school building run by UNRWA.

Likewise, a booby-trapped UNRWA clinic was detonated, killing three IDF soldiers. Aside from the massive amounts of explosives hidden in the walls of the clinic, it was revealed that it stood on top of dozens of terror tunnels, showing how UNRWA is closely embedded with Hamas.

More recently, it was discovered that a hostage kidnapped by Hamas to Gaza was held for 50 days in the attic of an UNRWA teacher.

 

Last year, the US increased its financial support for UNRWA, reaching a record $223 million, an increase of $16 million on the previous year.

Under the Trump administration, the US cut a full $300 million in funding to the agency in 2018. The Biden administration, however, changed the policy and announced it intends to resume aid to UNRWA, as well as other aid to the Palestinian Authority which was suspended by the Trump administration.

https://www.israelnationalnews.com/news/383105

Israel must send a clear message to the US

The Americans understand the importance of Israel’s victory over Hamas in Gaza, but their stated desire to avoid getting dragged into a regional war and have Israel end major combat operations even before completing the takeover of the entire strip encourages Iran and its proxies to continue gradually escalating their use of force, in the hope that the administration will stop Israel.

By Yossi Kuperwasser

A decisive victory in the complex campaign against Iran and its proxies requires a clear outcome in Gaza, as well as Israeli unity. The multi-front war – with Iran and its proxies, chiefly Hamas, backed by the Muslim Brotherhood (Qatar, Turkey, and their supporters worldwide) on the one hand, and Israel, the US, and parts of Western support on the other hand – has been going on for close to three months now. Each front has its own unique characteristics, derived from how the war began, the considerations of the actors involved, and their capabilities.

According to Defense Minister Yoav Gallant, Israel is fighting on seven fronts (Gaza, Lebanon, Syria, Judea and Samaria, Yemen, Iraq, and Iran), but in practice, the world stage forms another arena, and this is where Israel is fighting to maintain American backing as well as for the legitimacy of its actions and existence, and against antisemitism.

 

Ending the major combat operations before this goal is achieved just because we’ve reached a predetermined point in time (end of January?) will allow Hamas to claim that it forced Israel to effectively change its war goals in practice, and will encourage supporters of the terrorist organization who set themselves the goal of ensuring Hamas’ survival in Gaza, even if only in a small part of its territory. As long as Hamas controls the Gazan side of the Rafah crossing and is perceived by the population as a governing entity, it would be able to claim it had managed to survive, and by implication – won.

It is also important to drive home the message – in talks with the US – that defeating Hamas requires creating a reality in the strip that will not allow terrorists to rear their heads. Therefore, not only Hamas but also the weak and corrupt Palestinian Authority is unsuitable to take over responsibility for Gaza post-war: It remains committed to the armed conflict against Israel, encourages terror (through incitement and payment of salaries to imprisoned terrorists), and sees Hamas as a legitimate organization that should be part of the leadership.

 

This is not a war of choice; it has been forced upon Israel, and which began under extremely difficult opening conditions. And for that very reason, both Israel and the US must end it in victory. Achieving this requires several conditions. The first and most important is a clear defeat of Hamas in Gaza and the release of the captives. This means Israeli control at the end of high-intensity fighting over the entire area, including Rafah and the Philadelphi Route (excluding perhaps international management of displaced persons in secured areas designated to ensure the safety of the population during the mopping-up stage, which will likely last several months).

Gaining control over the entire area will also give Israel the necessary leverage to release the captives. As long as Hamas is not convinced that Israel is determined to eliminate its presence in Gaza, it has no interest in giving up its main asset, other than in return for an Israeli commitment to refrain from completing the takeover of the strip.

The second condition is reaching an understanding with the American administration that this is the US war almost to the same extent as it is Israel’s: Continuation of the current state of affairs on all fronts will damage its standing in the region and globally, and exacerbate threats to the security of American citizens and Washington’s interests. The Americans understand the importance of Israel’s victory over Hamas in Gaza, but their stated desire to avoid getting dragged into a regional war and have Israel end major combat operations even before completing the takeover of the entire strip encourages Iran and its proxies to continue gradually escalating their use of force, in the hope that the administration will stop Israel.

Defeating Hamas and convincing the US that this is also a war over the regional and global order – and translating this into a willingness to win – are key in the effort to exert diplomatic pressure on Iran, Hezbollah, the Houthis, and the pro-Iranian militias, and for effective military force against them if necessary.

This is the condition to create a new security reality along the northern border that will give residents a sense of security and allow them to return home; this is the condition to secure shipping through the Bab al-Mandeb strait; this is the condition to curb Iran’s nuclear program, which has again accelerated during the war; and this is the condition to promote efforts to establish a pragmatic regional center of gravity with normalization between Israel and Saudi Arabia at its core. Israel and the US need each other in these arenas, and Israel must dive home this interdependence and mutual benefit to ensure Washington’s commitment to achieving common goals.

Israel’s ability to meet the two conditions for victory will be greatly impacted by its ability to shake off the self-induced blindness that characterized its attitude towards its enemies’ intentions and display internal unity. This is not only the clear message communicated by the troops and the fallen, but also a strategic imperative. The greater and clearer the unity, the easier it will be for Israel to harness its capabilities and American support in order to achieve its war aims.

 

Operation Iron Swords (Updated to 1 p.m., January 2, 2024)

The combat arena: The IDF forces continued their integrated ground maneuver in the Gaza
Strip focusing on the Daraj-Tufah neighborhoods in Gaza City and Khan Yunis in the southern
Gaza Strip, while the fighting continued against terrorist centers in the northern and central
Gaza Strip. Senior Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad (PIJ) terrorists continue to claim that
they have the upper hand in the fighting with the IDF.

E_003_24 E_003_24

The Nahum Bedein Center for Near East Policy Research appears at the Israel Knesset 3pm to 5pm Israel time on Thursday, January 4th

The Nahum Bedein Center for Near East Policy Research appears at the Israel Knesset 3pm to 5pm Israel time on Thursday, January 4th,  invited by the Knesset Foreign Relations and Security committee to screen our movies which show how  UNRWA trainarmed UNRWA students  in guerrilla warfare– towards the  planned event on Oct. 7 2023-  under the guise of innocuous summer camps along the Gaza fence, filmed by our TV crews  based in Gaza.
These films precisely predicted the worst:   https://www.cfnepr.com/205640/Movies
 
Children depicted  herein act as  Arab cannon fodder in the current war.

From Israel: The Pernicious Lies of “Settler Violence”!!

A picture taken on August 5, 2022, shows Palestinian rockets fired from Gaza City in retaliation to earlier Israeli air strikes. - A senior militant from Islamic Jihad was killed in an Israeli air strike on the Gaza Strip today, prompting the militant group to warn Israel has "started a war".A child was among those killed in the strikes, the enclave's health ministry said, while Israel's military estimated 15 were dead. (Photo by MAHMUD HAMS / AFP)

January 3, 2024

There are so many instances of distortion in the media that present a false, negative picture of Israel that I could easily write a book on the subject.

But I want to focus here on the charges of “settler violence,” which are both fallacious and damaging.

~~~~~~~~~~

Many, if not most, of the charges of “settler violence” originated with agencies and organizations (either outside of Israel or receiving funds from sources outside of Israel) that are strongly predisposed against Israel:

One example among several is B’Tselem, registered as an Israeli NGO but funded to a significant degree by the EU, Sweden, New Israel Fund, Norway, the Ford Foundation and other (left-wing) non-Israeli sources. Representing itself as a “human rights organization,” it pursues a blatantly political agenda.

According to NGO Monitor, “B’Tselem is part of a network of NGOs that promote artificial and manufactured definitions of apartheid to extend the ongoing campaigns that seek to delegitimize and demonize Israel.” (Emphasis added)

B’Tselem

In 2020-2021, B’Tselem received funding from the EU for information on settler violence in Israel.

In 2021, B’Tselem wrote: “Settler violence against Palestinians is part of the strategy employed by Israel’s apartheid regime, which seeks to take over more and more West Bank land.”

https://www.btselem.org/settler_violence

This charge is ludicrous, as it is Palestinian Arabs who have been illegally usurping Israeli land in Area C.

For more on this see: https://www.regavim.org/category/battle-for-area-c/

~~~~~~~~~~

And then there is the UN, which is strongly predisposed against Israel. OHCHR – the UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights – released a report just over a year ago that included this:

“Armed and masked Israeli settlers are attacking Palestinians in their homes, attacking children on their way to school, destroying property and burning olive groves, and terrorising entire communities with complete impunity.”

https://www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2022/12/israel-un-experts-condemn-record-year-israeli-violence-occupied-west-bank

Incredible! Outrageous! A pastiche of lies.

OHCHR cites three “experts” who provided the information on “settler violence.” The very first one of those listed is “Francesca Albanese, Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights in the Palestinian Territory occupied since 1967.”

Albanese recently defended the Hamas massacre, distorting the facts in the process:

https://www.jns.org/not-an-international-crime-to-kill-soldiers-uns-francesca-albanese-says-of-oct-7/

Previously, she had spoken in defense of Palestinian Arab violence: “an occupation requires violence and generates violence. Palestinians have no other room for dissent than violence.”

UN rapporteur to Hamas gathering: ‘You have a right to resist Israel’

It makes a mockery of the entire report, that OHCHR relied upon the “expertise” of this biased woman with regard to charges of “settler violence.”

Lucas Koch AAP
Lucas Koch/AAP

~~~~~~~~~~

Charges made by these anti-Israel sources and others – notably Breaking the Silence, which receives foreign funding and worked with B’Tselem on its report on “settler violence” – have been picked up more broadly by mainstream media sources, many of which tilt against Israel as a matter of course. They have been shared in so many venues that they have become accepted as “fact.” But they are not fact.

Unfortunately, Joe Biden has chosen to take on this issue. Not only has he spoken about the problem of “settler violence,” the US government is acting in response to this alleged violence.

In early December, the Biden administration announced intention to implement visa bans on Israelis viewed as “extremist settlers” in the West Bank (that is, Judea & Samaria).

“State Department spokesperson Mathew Miller (pictured) said the U.S. is in the process of sanctioning people…

“Under the policy, any Israeli citizen deemed to be committing acts of violence or undermining peace and security in the West Bank, particularly against Palestinians, will be banned from entering the U.S.”

US announces visa bans for Israeli ‘extremist settlers’ in West Bank

State Department
State Department

This is a terribly wrong-headed policy, obviously political in its underpinning.

We might note, first, that this visa ban is directed against Jews selectively. A policy that was equitable would require that Palestinian Arabs living in Judea & Samaria would also be banned from entering the US if they committed acts of violence against Jews or undermined peace. But then again, if it were applied equitably, no one representing the PA, which pays terrorists and their families (surely an act that undermines peace), would be permitted into the US. And that would never do.

What is more, the identification of those to be banned is too general, too broad. What does it mean to “undermine peace” and precisely who will determine who these individuals allegedly doing so are?

Use of the term “deemed” is problematic. To “deem” is to believe or consider. No concrete proof will be required?

Those who in the end will be denied visas are small in number – Miller acknowledged as much in his announcement. They are not going to be denied entry into the US because they present a danger or are enemies of the US, but rather because of the political statements the US seeks to make.

~~~~~~~~~~

We come then to the question of precisely what political statements.

Politico
Politico

Biden is attempting to show progressives/leftists in the electorate that he can be tough on Israel. Why did he charge that Israel was doing ”indiscriminate” bombing in Gaza when he had to know better? It is of a piece, I believe, as he enters an election year.

Part of what he is doing is adopting a position of moral equivalency: Yea, yea, the Palestinian Arabs do some bad stuff, but look at what the Jews are doing. But don’t worry, he will deal with them.

And yet, there is something else going on that is even more significant.
Biden is pushing hard for that “two-state-solution.” This requires, in his fantasies, a Palestinian state in Gaza and the West Bank. And that means that Palestinian Arabs must control most – if not all – of Judea & Samaria. For that to happen, the Jews living in that area must be delegitimized. “Settlers” is a derisive term, in this context.

~~~~~~~~~~

David Weinberg, a senior fellow at The Institute for National Security & Zionist Strategy, has a slightly different take:

“Essentially, this is an effort to limit sympathy for Israel and to backhandedly excuse Hamas atrocities…

“To the Biden administration I say: Stop throwing ‘settler violence’ in Israel’s face as it fights for its very life against the genocidal Hamas. At best, this is a red herring issue. At worst, it is an ugly attempt to discredit the righteousness of Israel’s war effort.” (Emphasis added)

The myth of escalating settler violence

JNS 2
JNS

~~~~~~~~~~

Before we look at some of the data, I wish to make a point about the definition of “violence.” If every incident on the Israeli side, regardless of its severity, is calculated as being equivalent to every incident on the Arab side, a distortion of the reality will take place. There is a small number of hilltop youth in Judea & Samaria who have been prone to doing “price tag” attacks (although such attacks are fewer in number these days). Much of the time this involved vandalism. Not acceptable, not to be excused. But neither is it to be equated – incident to incident – with Arab attacks that maim or take life.

This entire issue of charging Jews with violence against Arabs is very deeply disturbing when – even before the massacre of October 7 – we were dealing with frequent terror attacks that killed innocent Jews. (More on this below.)

~~~~~~~~~~

Another problem in securing accurate data is the question of what is identified as a “settler attack.”

Ariel Kahana (pictured below), writing in Israel Hayom at the end of December, looks at some problematic instances:

According to the police, the agency that is officially tasked with collecting the data, there were instances in which rapid response teams in settlements were involved in incidents that were believed to be “settler violence.” On high alert following the Hamas attack, they tended to respond aggressively. The IDF erroneously identified these incidents as “settler violence,” but have now adjusted their data to conform with that of the police.

The police argue that the IDF method of counting incidents was inaccurate, and has damaged Israel’s international image.

According to the commander of the Israel Police Judea and Samaria District, Uzi Levy, following discussions with settler leaders, IDF Major General Fox had been misled by “extremist left-wing anarchists who have been deliberately creating friction so that the Arabs clash with settlers, and ultimately lay the blame on the settlers – but in many cases they are the ones causing the incidents.”

The police and the IDF have now adjusted data so that it is synchronized. The data indicates that during the second month of the Gaza war, there was a significant decline in what has been termed “nationalistic incidents” perpetrated by Israelis in the West Bank.

According to police data, this is the second consecutive month with a decline of about 50% in incidents compared to the equivalent period in 2022. This amounts to about 50 incidents on average per month, compared to a figure twice the size during the same months in 2022.

“Fox says in closed briefings that ‘99.9% of the half a million residents of the West Bank are normative law-abiding citizens, many of whom are currently being called into the Gaza war effort,’ and has also emphasized that the violent individuals are ’a handful of felons.’”

https://www.israelhayom.com/2023/12/26/idf-confirms-nationalistic-crime-perpetrated-by-settlers-drops-drastically/

PR
PR

~~~~~~~~~~

On Sunday, 23 MKs, all members of Israel’s Knesset and the Knesset Caucus to Combat Antisemitism and Delegitimization, wrote a letter to President Biden. The letter was initiated by the chairman of the lobby, MK Ariel Kallner (Likud), who calls the charges a “modern blood libel.”

Kellner laments a disproportionate focus on settlers that all but ignores the innate hatred toward Jews across Palestinian society: “This blood libel needs to be cut off at the root. The Jewish residents of Judea and Samaria have for years been subject to violent attacks by an Arab society that largely also supports the October 7 events.”

~~~~~~~~~~

I cite David Weinberg above and provide his comments from another article of his here. The issue is the threat to many Israeli communities, including those in Judea & Samaria, of attack by Palestinian Arabs (emphasis added):

“Most stark of all is the threat of Palestinian swarm attacks on settlement communities in Judea and Samaria and on cities straddling the Green Line in the center of the country like those in the Emek Hefer region. This is not an imaginary scenario. It is a clear and present danger…

“In the nine weeks since Hamas launched its cross-border attack from the Gaza Strip, there have been 1,388 Palestinian terrorist attacks in Judea and Samaria, including 569 stoning assaults, 287 attacks with explosives, 143 fire-bombings, and 70 drive-by shooting attacks. Three Israelis (a civilian, a soldier, and a Border Police officer) have been murdered in Judea and Samaria since October 7 and at least 52 Israelis sustained injuries.”

Read this in its entirety. It is blood-curdling. The suggestion from the world community that “the problem” is “settler violence” is enraging.

https://www.israelhayom.com/opinions/ready-the-rapid-response-squads-everywhere/

And consider this, from December 14:

“The Biden administration is blocking a shipment of more than 27,000 US-made rifles for the Israel Police out of fear they could make their way into the hands of ‘extremist Israeli settlers,’ US officials said.

“Three cases of firearms, including M-16 and M-4 rifles, have been waiting for the State Department’s required approval and notification to Congress for more than a month, according to The Wall Street Journal.

“The Biden administration told the Israeli government this month that it won’t transfer the rifles until they’ve received sufficient assurances from Israel that the guns will only be used by police, the officials said.”

US holds up rifle shipment to Israel over ‘settler violence’

These insufferable fools have it all wrong.

~~~~~~~~~~

Please, it is urgent that this information be shared broadly. Use it to refute the libel and alert people to the real dangers.

~~~~~~~~~~

The Beautiful People of Israel story of the day:

In a manner that is true of no other fighting force in the world, the IDF is concerned with reassuring the mothers of their soldiers. Those who are fighting in Gaza are not able to use their cell phones, and their mothers can go many days without word. Sometimes commanders message them to say that their sons are well.

Recently, someone I am close to, the mother of two young soldiers in Gaza, received a message from the commander of one of her sons. He is well, the commander told her. If she wanted to bake cookies for him and get them to a designated delivery point a distance away (outside of Gaza) by the following morning, they would be brought to her son.

She received the message at night and knew it was impossible, as she had no car, to get it to the delivery point by designated time in the morning. When she told this to the commander, he assured her she should not worry. He charged someone at the designated delivery point with buying some cookies for this woman’s son, which would be carried into Gaza with other cookies. Later in the day, she received a picture from the commander of her son enjoying the cookies.

Where else?

~~~~~~~~~~

Keep praying to Heaven for Israel, my friends. Pray for the strength and wisdom of our leaders, for the safety of our boys, and for the rescue of our hostages. Pray with a heart filled with hope.

~~~~~~~~~~

© Arlene Kushner. This material is produced by independent journalist Arlene Kushner. Permission is granted for it to be reproduced only with proper attribution.

Unfinished tasks

As the world switches over to the year 2024 in the civil calendar, those who are still sober will be aware that major pitfalls lie ahead.

Instead of old problems having been solved and dealt with, as 2023 is seen off, the challenges that have been either kicked down the road or swept under the carpet are guaranteed to confront humanity with a vengeance.

The primary casualty in the year ahead will be peace. 

In the absence of any will to deal with the old year’s primary sources of instability and mayhem in the world, the accumulated pressures will explode in our faces. That is the uncomfortable yet incontrovertible truth. Evil, left to fester and multiply will come back to menace all of us. The utter failure to root out and eradicate it and instead pretend that fancy rhetoric and moral cowardice may somehow solve the problem has repeatedly throughout history led to disasters and misery.

Jews have been described as the “canaries in the mine” because they usually are the first to suffer from the hate and incitement circulating in societies.

This can be clearly seen as we transition from the old to the new civil year. The long, littered trail of unresolved business is about to multiply and become more complex. It has the potential to engulf not only Jews in the Diaspora and Israel but also to contaminate all those living in endangered democracies.

Like diseases left untreated, the viruses now rampaging will mutate into incurable pandemics unless radical surgery and countermeasures are swiftly enforced.

The threats to peace, liberty and democracy remain the same.

In no particular order of malignancy they are clearly visible and growing more menacing as every day passes.

Iranian ambitions to acquire the means to threaten and destroy those they deem enemies have now progressed unhindered. Thanks to vacillating appeasement, craven hypocrisy and a collapse of all vestiges of morality, the Mullahs of Tehran stand on the cusp of acquiring nuclear weapons and the means to deliver them. Whether the failure by democratic nations to deter Iran involved circumventing trade sanctions, turning a blind eye to those who did so or unfreezing frozen funds the end result was the same.

The reaction of the international community has been one of total disinterest with each announcement of yet another missile development and revelation that enriching uranium had passed a previous red line. The Iranians, like the North Koreans, know that they can literally get away with murder without any fear of UN retribution. These two rogue regimes can threaten their neighbours with elimination yet remain upstanding members of an organization ostensibly established to preserve world peace and human rights.

Piracy has returned with a vengeance in the Red Sea and beyond. Everyone knows that those pulling the Houthi puppet strings are none other than the Iranian puppet masters. Piracy on the high seas can only be defeated by concerted action from maritime nations yet so far it has been a struggle to cobble together a coalition. The question, of course, is what will actually happen? Will the tin pot country of Yemen, with Iranian support, continue to get away with threatening shipping? Will this coalition actually tackle the threats or will it be more of a verbal volley and a slap on the wrist type response?

In 1967, Israel was assured by the USA that they and a coalition of nations would guarantee freedom of shipping in the Gulf of Aqaba. When it came to the crunch, however, this guarantee disappeared like a desert mirage and Israel was left to deal with the threat alone. Will 2024 see a rerun of this scenario as a loss of backbone results in the terror sponsors of Tehran being given a free pass?

The year now passing into oblivion witnessed the most scandalous exhibition of international duplicity ever perpetrated. The United Nations and its associated bodies demonstrated beyond a shadow of a doubt that they have become irredeemably irrelevant as far as Israel is concerned. Evidence uncovered in Gaza reveals that Hamas and UNRWA are partners in terror and educating the next generation to become terrorists. The UN Human Rights Council has been hijacked by human rights abusers and UNESCO has helped to delegitimize Jewish history.

The UN General Assembly annual resolution scorecard has just been released, and it shows a continuing and unbridled fetish with condemning Israel. It is impossible to deny the evidence as provided by UN Watch: North Korea – 1; Venezuela – 0; Myanmar – 1;  Lebanon – 0; Pakistan – 0; Hamas – 0; Turkey – 0; Russia – 2;

China – 0; Qatar – 0; Saudi Arabia – 0; Syria – 1; Iraq – 0; Iran – 1;

USA – 1; ISRAEL – 14.

The Security Council record for 2023 is no better.

The pattern for 2024 will be just as bad, if not worse. One has to ask how much longer Israel should subject itself to continuing flagellation by an organization so obviously corrupt and irrelevant.

The International Red Cross has proven once again that it has zero interest when it comes to JewsContinuing a pattern set during the Shoah years when it failed dismally, its recent refusal to demand access to hostages held by Hamas and even refusing to transfer medications to them is shameful.

Palestine Media Watch (PMW) has revealed that the PA has advised incarcerated terrorists and their families that in order to continue receiving stipends and pensions for 2024 they will need to submit the relevant forms via the International Red Cross.

All this brings us to the question of why Abbas and his PA/PLO/Fatah cronies should be rewarded with a State in the heartland of Israel.

There is nothing more certain that 2024 will witness a renewed frenzy to hand over Judea, Samaria and Jerusalem to terror plotters, supporters, facilitators and sympathizers.

The frenzied mobs of university ignoramuses, green lemmings, Marxist-imbued hallucinatory youth combined with locally radicalized Islamists have only started. Disrupting Christmas carols and tree lighting is just the start. They have declared war on Christian and Western societies. Inciting rhetoric and civil disruptions will inevitably be followed by physical violence.

The genie of Jew hate has already been let loose and the coming year will witness an intensification unseen since the Shoah years. Surveys taken in various countries show that, especially among 18 to 30-year-olds, the Shoah is being increasingly questioned and Jews are increasingly being seen as justifiable recipients of the masses’ wrath. One has to wonder how much eradicating history as a subject and the promotion of woke narratives has contributed towards this wholesale brainwashing.

The Israeli campaign against terror will need to intensify in 2024 and it will inevitably result in increased threats to Jewish life in countries where Judeophobia already bubbles just below the surface. Living in la la land is no longer a tenable option, especially when the warning signs are so clearly evident.

If all this sounds overly pessimistic, I plead guilty.

Short of an imminent arrival of the messianic age I am afraid that we will have to reconcile ourselves to another very difficult year ahead.

Denial of reality and escaping into a make-believe world where the lion is already lying down with the lamb is not a realistic option as far as Jews are concerned.

Let us hope at least for a healthy year and one in which the purveyors of evil are defeated.

Buckle up tight for a rough ride ahead.

Screams Without Words’: How Hamas Weaponized Sexual Violence on Oct. 7

At first, she was known simply as “the woman in the black dress.”

In a grainy video, you can see her, lying on her back, dress torn, legs spread, vagina exposed. Her face is burned beyond recognition and her right hand covers her eyes.

The video was shot in the early hours of Oct. 8 by a woman searching for a missing friend at the site of the rave in southern Israel where, the day before, Hamas terrorists massacred hundreds of young Israelis.

The video went viral, with thousands of people responding, desperate to know if the woman in the black dress was their missing friend, sister or daughter.

One family knew exactly who she was — Gal Abdush, mother of two from a working-class town in central Israel, who disappeared from the rave that night with her husband.

As the terrorists closed in on her, trapped on a highway in a line of cars of people trying to flee the party, she sent one final WhatsApp message to her family: “You don’t understand.”

Based largely on the video evidence — which was verified by The New York Times — Israeli police officials said they believed that Ms. Abdush was raped, and she has become a symbol of the horrors visited upon Israeli women and girls during the Oct. 7 attacks.

Israeli officials say that everywhere Hamas terrorists struck — the rave, the military bases along the Gaza border and the kibbutzim — they brutalized women.

A two-month investigation by The Times uncovered painful new details, establishing that the attacks against women were not isolated events but part of a broader pattern of gender-based violence on Oct. 7.

Relying on video footage, photographs, GPS data from mobile phones and interviews with more than 150 people, including witnesses, medical personnel, soldiers and rape counselors, The Times identified at least seven locations where Israeli women and girls appear to have been sexually assaulted or mutilated.

Four witnesses described in graphic detail seeing women raped and killed at two different places along Route 232, the same highway where Ms. Abdush’s half-naked body was found sprawled on the road at a third location.

And The Times interviewed several soldiers and volunteer medics who together described finding more than 30 bodies of women and girls in and around the rave site and in two kibbutzim in a similar state as Ms. Abdush’s — legs spread, clothes torn off, signs of abuse in their genital areas.

ImageCars — some destroyed by fire, others damaged — in a clearing among trees.
A camp area on Oct. 11 at the rave site in southern Israel.Credit…Sergey Ponomarev for The New York Times

Many of the accounts are difficult to bear, and the visual evidence is disturbing to see.

The Times viewed photographs of one woman’s corpse that emergency responders discovered in the rubble of a besieged kibbutz with dozens of nails driven into her thighs and groin.

The Times also viewed a video, provided by the Israeli military, showing two dead Israeli soldiers at a base near Gaza who appeared to have been shot directly in their vaginas.

Hamas has denied Israel’s accusations of sexual violence. Israeli activists have been outraged that the United Nations Secretary General, António Guterres, and the agency U.N. Women did not acknowledge the many accusations until weeks after the attacks.

Investigators with Israel’s top national police unit, Lahav 433, have been steadily gathering evidence but they have not put a number on how many women were raped, saying that most are dead — and buried — and that they will never know. No survivors have spoken publicly.

The Israeli police have acknowledged that, during the shock and confusion of Oct. 7, the deadliest day in Israeli history, they were not focused on collecting semen samples from women’s bodies, requesting autopsies or closely examining crime scenes. At that moment, the authorities said, they were intent on repelling Hamas and identifying the dead.

Image

Messages on a mobile phone screen.
Ms. Abdush’s sister showing one of the last messages Ms. Abdush sent on Oct. 7.

A combination of chaos, enormous grief and Jewish religious duties meant that many bodies were buried as quickly as possible. Most were never examined, and in some cases, like at the rave scene, where more than 360 people were slaughtered in a few hours, the bodies were hauled away by the truckload.

That has left the Israeli authorities at a loss to fully explain to families what happened to their loved ones in their final moments. Ms. Abdush’s relatives, for instance, never received a death certificate. They are still searching for answers.

In cases of widespread sexual violence during a war, it is not unusual to have limited forensic evidence, experts said.

“Armed conflict is so chaotic,” said Adil Haque, a Rutgers law professor and war crimes expert. “People are more focused on their safety than on building a criminal case down the road.”

Very often, he said, sex crime cases will be prosecuted years later on the basis of testimony from victims and witnesses.

“The eyewitness might not even know the name of the victim,” he added. “But if they can testify as, ‘I saw a woman being raped by this armed group,’ that can be enough.”

Sapir, a 24-year-old accountant, has become one of the Israeli police’s key witnesses. She does not want to be fully identified, saying she would be hounded for the rest of her life if her last name were revealed.

She attended the rave with several friends and provided investigators with graphic testimony. She also spoke to The Times. In a two-hour interview outside a cafe in southern Israel, she recounted seeing groups of heavily armed gunmen rape and kill at least five women.

She said that at 8 a.m. on Oct. 7, she was hiding under the low branches of a bushy tamarisk tree, just off Route 232, about four miles southwest of the party. She had been shot in the back. She felt faint. She covered herself in dry grass and lay as still as she could.

Image

Two people in high-visibility vests walk along a path toward severely damaged low buildings.
Volunteers with an emergency response team at the Kfar Aza kibbutz this month. The kibbutz was among the places attacked on Oct. 7.

About 15 meters from her hiding place, she said, she saw motorcycles, cars and trucks pulling up. She said that she saw “about 100 men,” most of them dressed in military fatigues and combat boots, a few in dark sweatsuits, getting in and out of the vehicles. She said the men congregated along the road and passed between them assault rifles, grenades, small missiles — and badly wounded women.

“It was like an assembly point,” she said.

The first victim she said she saw was a young woman with copper-color hair, blood running down her back, pants pushed down to her knees. One man pulled her by the hair and made her bend over. Another penetrated her, Sapir said, and every time she flinched, he plunged a knife into her back.

She said she then watched another woman “shredded into pieces.” While one terrorist raped her, she said, another pulled out a box cutter and sliced off her breast.

“One continues to rape her, and the other throws her breast to someone else, and they play with it, throw it, and it falls on the road,” Sapir said.

She said the men sliced her face and then the woman fell out of view. Around the same time, she said, she saw three other women raped and terrorists carrying the severed heads of three more women.

Sapir provided photographs of her hiding place and her wounds, and police officials have stood by her testimony and released a video of her, with her face blurred, recounting some of what she saw.

Yura Karol, a 22-year-old security consultant, said he was hiding in the same spot, and he can be seen in one of Sapir’s photos. He and Sapir were part of a group of friends who had met up at the party. In an interview, Mr. Karol said he barely lifted his head to look at the road but he also described seeing a woman raped and killed.

Since that day, Sapir said, she has struggled with a painful rash that spread across her torso, and she can barely sleep, waking up at night, heart pounding, covered in sweat.

“That day, I became an animal,” she said. “I was emotionally detached, sharp, just the adrenaline of survival. I looked at all this as if I was photographing them with my eyes, not forgetting any detail. I told myself: I should remember everything.”

That same morning, along Route 232 but in a different location about a mile southwest of the party area, Raz Cohen — a young Israeli who had also attended the rave and had worked recently in the Democratic Republic of Congo training Congolese soldiers — said that he was hiding in a dried-up streambed. It provided some cover from the assailants combing the area and shooting anyone they found, he said in an hour-and-a-half interview in a Tel Aviv restaurant.

Image

A head-and-shoulders photo of a man with a beard, wearing a black T-shirt, looking up to his left.
Raz Cohen, a security consultant, survived the Oct. 7 attacks by hiding in a dried-up streambed.

Maybe 40 yards in front of him, he recalled, a white van pulled up and its doors flew open.

He said he then saw five men, wearing civilian clothes, all carrying knives and one carrying a hammer, dragging a woman across the ground. She was young, naked and screaming.

“They all gather around her,” Mr. Cohen said. “She’s standing up. They start raping her. I saw the men standing in a half circle around her. One penetrates her. She screams. I still remember her voice, screams without words.”

“Then one of them raises a knife,” he said, “and they just slaughtered her.”

Shoam Gueta, one of Mr. Cohen’s friends and a fashion designer, said the two were hiding together in the streambed. He said he saw at least four men step out of the van and attack the woman, who ended up “between their legs.” He said that they were “talking, giggling and shouting,” and that one of them stabbed her with a knife repeatedly, “literally butchering her.”

Hours later, the first wave of volunteer emergency medical technicians arrived at the rave site. In interviews, four of them said that they discovered bodies of dead women with their legs spread and underwear missing — some with their hands tied by rope and zipties — in the party area, along the road, in the parking area and in the open fields around the rave site.

Jamal Waraki, a volunteer medic with the nonprofit ZAKA emergency response team, said he could not get out of his head a young woman in a rawhide vest found between the main stage and the bar.

“Her hands were tied behind her back,” he said. “She was bent over, half naked, her underwear rolled down below her knees.”

Yinon Rivlin, a member of the rave’s production team who lost two brothers in the attacks, said that after hiding from the killers, he emerged from a ditch and made his way to the parking area, east of the party, along Route 232, looking for survivors.

Near the highway, he said, he found the body of a young woman, on her stomach, no pants or underwear, legs spread apart. He said her vagina area appeared to have been sliced open, “as if someone tore her apart.”

Similar discoveries were made in two kibbutzim, Be’eri and Kfar Aza. Eight volunteer medics and two Israeli soldiers told The Times that in at least six different houses, they had come across a total of at least 24 bodies of women and girls naked or half naked, some mutilated, others tied up, and often alone.

A paramedic in an Israeli commando unit said that he had found the bodies of two teenage girls in a room in Be’eri.

One was lying on her side, he said, boxer shorts ripped, bruises by her groin. The other was sprawled on the floor face down, he said, pajama pants pulled to her knees, bottom exposed, semen smeared on her back.

Because his job was to look for survivors, he said, he kept moving and did not document the scene. Neighbors of the two girls killed — who were sisters, 13 and 16 — said their bodies had been found alone, separated from the rest of their family.

The Israeli military allowed the paramedic to speak with reporters on the condition that he not be identified because he serves in an elite unit.

Many of the dead were brought to the Shura military base, in central Israel, for identification. Here, too, witnesses said they saw signs of sexual violence.

Shari Mendes, an architect called up as a reserve soldier to help prepare the bodies of female soldiers for burial, said she had seen four with signs of sexual violence, including some with “a lot of blood in their pelvic areas.”

Image

A woman stands in a large metal container whose doors are open, showing wrapped bodies stacked on shelves, while a man with a gun stands looking in her direction.
Shari Mendes, an architect who was called up as a reserve soldier to help handle the bodies of female troops, in a container used to hold bodies before their removal to a morgue at the Shura military base in central Israel.

A dentist, Captain Maayan, who worked at the same identification center, said that she had seen at least 10 bodies of female soldiers from Gaza observation posts with signs of sexual violence.

Captain Maayan asked to be identified only by her rank and surname because of the sensitivity of the subject. She said she had seen several bodies with cuts in their vaginas and underwear soaked in blood and one whose fingernails had been pulled out.

The Israeli authorities have no shortage of video evidence from the Oct. 7 attacks. They have gathered hours of footage from Hamas body cameras, dashcams, security cameras and mobile phones showing Hamas terrorists killing civilians and many images of mutilated bodies.

But Moshe Fintzy, a deputy superintendent and senior spokesman of Israel’s national police, said, “We have zero autopsies, zero,” making an O with his right hand.

In the aftermath of the attack, police officials said, forensic examiners were dispatched to the Shura military base to help identify the hundreds of bodies — Israeli officials say around 1,200 people were killed that day.

The examiners worked quickly to give the agonized families of the missing a sense of closure and to determine, by a process of elimination, who was dead and who was being held hostage in Gaza.

According to Jewish tradition, funerals are held promptly. The result was that many bodies with signs of sexual abuse were put to rest without medical examinations, meaning that potential evidence now lies buried in the ground. International forensic experts said that it would be possible to recover some evidence from the corpses, but that it would be difficult.

Mr. Fintzy said Israeli security forces were still finding imagery that shows women were brutalized. Sitting at his desk at an imposing police building in Jerusalem, he swiped open his phone, tapped and produced the video of the two soldiers shot in the vagina, which he said was recorded by Hamas gunmen and recently recovered by Israeli soldiers.

A colleague sitting next to him, Mirit Ben Mayor, a police chief superintendent, said she believed that the brutality against women was a combination of two ferocious forces, “the hatred for Jews and the hatred for women.”

Some emergency medical workers now wish they had documented more of what they saw. In interviews, they said they had moved bodies, cut off zip ties and cleaned up scenes of carnage. Trying to be respectful to the dead, they inadvertently destroyed evidence.

Many volunteers working for ZAKA, the emergency response team, are religious Jews and operate under strict rules that command deep respect for the dead.

“I did not take pictures because we are not allowed to take pictures,” said Yossi Landau, a ZAKA volunteer. “In retrospect, I regret it.”

There are at least three women and one man who were sexually assaulted and survived, according to Gil Horev, a spokesman for Israel’s Ministry of Welfare and Social Affairs. “None of them has been willing to come physically for treatment,” he said. Two therapists said they were working with a woman who was gang raped at the rave and was in no condition to talk to investigators or reporters.

Image

A man with a beard and black jacket looks off to his left.
Yossi Landau, a volunteer with the nonprofit ZAKA emergency response team, said he had not taken pictures of the bodies because it was not allowed. “In retrospect, I regret it,” he added.

The trauma from sexual assault can be so heavy that sometimes survivors do not speak about it for years, several rape counselors said.

“Many people are looking for the golden evidence, of a woman who will testify about what happened to her. But don’t look for that, don’t put this pressure on this woman,” said Orit Sulitzeanu, executive director of the Association of Rape Crisis Centers in Israel. “The corpses tell the story.”

One of the last images of Ms. Abdush alive — captured by a security camera mounted on her front door — shows her leaving home with her husband, Nagi, at 2:30 a.m. on Oct. 7 for the rave.

He was wearing jeans and a black T-shirt. She was dressed in a short black dress, a black shawl tied around her waist and combat boots. As she struts out, she takes a swig from a glass (her brother-in-law remembers it was Red Bull and vodka) and laughs.

You’ve got to live life like it’s your last moments. That was her motto, her sisters said.

At daybreak, hundreds of terrorists closed in on the party from several directions, blocking the highways leading out. The couple jumped into their Audi, dashing off a string of messages as they moved.

“We’re on the border,” Ms. Abdush wrote to her family. “We’re leaving.”

“Explosions.”

Her husband made his own calls to his family, leaving a final audio message for his brother, Nissim, at 7:44 a.m. “Take care of the kids,” he said. “I love you.”

Gunshots rang out, and the message stopped.

That night, Eden Wessely, a car mechanic, drove to the rave site with three friends and found Ms. Abdush sprawled half naked on the road next to her burned car, about nine miles north of the site. She did not see the body of Mr. Abdush.

Image

A woman in a car, illuminated by an internal light.
Eden Wessely, a car mechanic, drove to the rave site looking for a missing friend but instead found Ms. Abdush sprawled half naked on the road next to her burned car.

She saw other burned cars and other bodies, and shot videos of several — hoping that they would help people to identify missing relatives. When she posted the video of the woman in the black dress on her Instagram story, she was deluged with messages.

“Hi, based on your description of the woman in the black dress, did she have blonde hair?” one message read.

“Eden, the woman you described with the black dress, do you remember the color of her eyes?” another said.

Some members of the Abdush family saw that video and another version of it filmed by one of Ms. Wessely’s friends. They immediately suspected that the body was Ms. Abdush, and based on the way her body was found, they feared that she might have been raped.

But they kept alive a flicker of hope that somehow, it wasn’t true.

The videos caught the eye of Israeli officials as well — very quickly after Oct. 7 they began gathering evidence of atrocities. They included footage of Ms. Abdush’s body in a presentation made to foreign governments and media organizations, using Ms. Abdush as a representation of violence committed against women that day.

Image

A fuzzy photograph of a woman’s body lying on the ground next to a white vehicle.
A screenshot from a video showing Ms. Abdush’s body.Credit…Eden Wessely

A week after her body was found, three government social workers appeared at the gate of the family’s home in Kiryat Ekron, a small town in central Israel. They broke the news that Ms. Abdush, 34, had been found dead.

But the only document the family received was a one-page form letter from Israel’s president, Isaac Herzog, expressing his condolences and sending a hug. The body of Mr. Abdush, 35, was identified two days after his wife’s. It was badly burned and investigators determined who he was based on a DNA sample and his wedding ring.

The couple had been together since they were teenagers. To the family, it seems only yesterday that Mr. Abdush was heading off to work to fix water heaters, a bag of tools slung over his shoulder, and Ms. Abdush was cooking up mashed potatoes and schnitzel for their two sons, Eliav, 10, and Refael, 7.

The boys are now orphans. They were sleeping over at an aunt’s the night their parents were killed. Ms. Abdush’s mother and father have applied for permanent custody, and everyone is chipping in to help.

Night after night, Ms. Abdush’s mother, Eti Bracha, lies in bed with the boys until they drift off. A few weeks ago, she said she tried to quietly leave their bedroom when the younger boy stopped her.

“Grandma,” he said, “I want to ask you a question.”

“Honey,” she said, “you can ask anything.”

“Grandma, how did mom die?”

Image

A woman with her eyes closed rests her head on the shoulder of a man wearing a skull cap, looking out of a window.
Ms. Abdush’s parents, Eti Bracha, 56, and her husband, Eli, 60.

Jeffrey Gettleman is an international correspondent and a winner of the Pulitzer Prize. He is the author of “Love, Africa,” a memoir. More about Jeffrey Gettleman

Jeffrey GettlemanAnat Schwartz and