Irreconcilable and Incompatible

Israel is currently faced with several challenges, domestic and foreign, which seem at first glance to be insurmountable.

Domestically, the ongoing saga of the Israeli hostages kidnapped by Hamas is boiling over. Concurrently the war against terror rumbles on without any respite. These two crises, combined with the added calls for elections and political accountability, fuel an already volatile atmosphere.

As though these problems were insufficient, we also face the implacable imbecility of a lame-duck US President, an aspiring Democratic candidate and a UN totally subverted by the axis of evil and appeasing fellow travellers.

Add to this toxic mix a media subverted by Orwellian untruths and you have a perfect recipe for chaos, surrender to terror forces and in the near future a world where once again hate rules supreme.

The bottom line both in Israel and the rest of the democratic world is whether we lie down without a fight and accept the inevitability of a new jihadist world order or whether we stand and resist.

The plight of the hostages presents an impossible dilemma.

The agony and desperation of the families whose loved ones are held in Gaza by Hamas and associated terror groups cannot be imagined. Their campaign on behalf of the kidnapped hostages is understandable. Unfortunately this has attracted controversy mainly because parts have been hijacked by groups with differing agendas.

Some demand a unilateral capitulation which includes a complete withdrawal from Gaza and the resurrection of Hamas and associated terror groups. In addition, it means the release from Israeli jails of a thousand or more murderers who, without a doubt, would resume their murderous rampages. This happened when the last so-called deal for one hostage was consummated. Hamas has already made it perfectly clear that it envisages future pogroms and massacres.

Additionally, Sinwar, the Hamas leader has surrounded himself with human hostage shields. Therefore we are faced with letting him escape with the few remaining live hostages. It is an untenable situation especially when one knows with certainty that surrender to terror demands inevitably leads to further such outrages. Those who advocate appeasing terror groups and their enablers seem to remain impervious to any sort of realization that it is the murderers rather than the victims who are guilty of crimes against humanity.

Of course, the media and two-faced political leaders have already decided that Israel is the guilty party and deliberately put the onus on it for refusing to kowtow to terrorists. Joe Biden who has just been on vacation for two weeks blames Netanyahu for “not doing enough” to rescue the hostages. One can only treat his comments with contempt, given his Administration’s abject failure in Afghanistan and also his abject failure to prevent illegals (including known terrorists and criminals) from infiltrating the USA.

Other groups who have latched on to the demonstrations are those calling for elections now and accountability on the part of those responsible for the security lapses on 7 October. These are valid demands but they should wait until the current war is successfully concluded. Undoubtedly there must be a reckoning for failed policies prior to 7 October and subsequent actions. Unfortunately, those whose aims are to engender chaos and disunity prefer to display it now much to the delight of all who relish the spectacle of Israel being pilloried for every imaginable sin.

The Israel Labor Union (Histadrut) declared a general strike whose sole aim seemed to be to wreck the Israeli economy instead of showing solidarity with the war against Hamas. Without a doubt, the terror leaders in Gaza, Lebanon, Qatar, Tehran and elsewhere are rejoicing at the sight of striking Israelis absolving them of any culpability.

Adding lethal fuel to the fires of social unrest are the irrational pontifications, admonitions and unctuous proclamations from all quarters of the democratic world. No sane Israeli expects any sort of solidarity from those nations which themselves are models of hypocritical rhetoric and habitual supporters of the ongoing anti Israel resolutions at the corrupt United Nations. However, the least that could be expected from the diminishing number of true democracies was some sort of understanding of the threats facing civilized societies today.

Pious declarations that “Israel has the right to defend itself” are hollow and insincere when in the next breath those uttering them demand an immediate halt to the campaign before the murderers have been eliminated.

One day after the brutal murder of six Israeli hostages the UK Government announced suspension of 30 arms sales licenses with more under review. Despite frantic denials that this did not constitute any sort of embargo the fact is that “perfidious Albion” has once again shown its true colours.

At the same time a report in the Washington Post revealed that Kamala Harris might be “open to imposing new conditions on future aid to Israel.” This “straw in the wind” of possible future action merely confirms what most in Israel already suspect. A Harris/Walz White House will be in thrall to the hard left and pandering to the jihadist lemmings. The Harris appointed director of Arab outreach is on record as claiming”the Zionists control US politics.”  As Biden demonstrates his incompetence and Harris displays her even worse detachment from reality there is no doubt unrestrained rejoicing in those places where future terror plans are being hatched.

As Hamas and friends issue a call for all Palestinians to mobilize against Israel the UN Secretary General finds it impossible to condemn Hamas by name. Eleven months after 7 October the UN Security Council will finally debate the plight of the kidnapped hostages. Don’t expect anything more meaningful than insincere expressions of hot air and condemnations of Israel’s war against terror.

Iran is trying to turn Judea and Samaria into another Gaza by smuggling weapons to its surrogates for use against Israeli civilians. That is why the IDF has been conducting security operations in the territory. Pre-emptive action is critical to ensuring that the heartland of Israel does not become another area from which lethal terror is directed at civilians. One would think that this elementary fact might resonate with all those who claim to have the Jewish State’s best interests at heart.

Unfortunately, once again, logic flies out the window.

The UN Secretary General who can’t bring himself to blame Hamas for terror against Israelis demands an instant cessation of Israel’s security operations.

The UK is “deeply concerned” that Israel is trying to defend its citizens.

The USA declares that “Israel must immediately rectify its conduct.”

Sundry other foreign ministries issue similar sentiments.

What other nation faced with 80 years of unrelenting hate and terror is admonished to not fight back? What sort of a message does this send to other threatened nations? It is this collective collapse of intestinal fortitude in the face of naked aggression which will at the end of the day spell doom for Europe and then other continents.

A perfect example of the deranged syndrome infecting certain sections of the Israeli left is provided by a news report last week.

Ehud Olmert, a former failed Prime Minister, who was incarcerated for a time, continues to demonstrate an unerring ability at manipulative meddling. It appears that he and the late unlamented Yasser Arafat’s nephew have been “negotiating” with the aim of delivering a peace proposal that is too good to turn down. This priceless piece of self-delusory ego tripping was apparently agreed upon and touted as the ultimate panacea that would lead to peace on earth and the heralding of good will to all humanity.

Its basic premise is a return by Israel to the 1949/1967 armistice lines with minor adjustments. Some 4% of territory will be ceded to Israel with a corresponding percentage of territory handed over to the “Palestinians.” Jerusalem will again be divided with the eastern part of the city part of a Palestinian capital. The UN Security Council would guarantee freedom of worship and a sort of international trusteeship would administer affairs.

This cockeyed concoction of a peace agreement can only be the product of sick minds and delusional appeasers working hand in hand. The tragedy is that it may very well be embraced by those currently demanding an Israeli surrender to terror, self-loathers and most certainly will be heralded by all those in the international community who are totally detached from any sort of reality.

It is not hard to understand why we face irreconcilable challenges.

Hamas murdered the hostages, not Benjamin Netanyahu

Even before the official announcement identifying the bodies of the returned hostages, the inflammatory rhetoric had already begun. Wild accusations started circulating, blaming Benjamin Netanyahu for nothing less than the direct murder of the six hostages.

In response to these absurd claims, the obvious truth emerges: Hamas is responsible for their deaths. Hamas is the terror group that kidnapped, held and murdered them.
But after stating the obvious, it’s also important to address the violent anger that has swept through social media and the streets. A morning that saw the return of six dead hostages and the murder of three police officers is unbearable. Beyond the sadness that gripped many, there was also a sharpened resolve that this war – in Gaza, the West Bank, Lebanon, and, in the future, Iran – is more justified than ever.
So, what explains the difference between those who walked around in sadness and those who were not only sad but also angry to the point of incitement? A sober reading of the reality. Those who have turned Netanyahu into the murderer of the six hostages deluded themselves over the past months into believing that a deal was genuinely on the table — that Sinwar was just about to relent and sign an agreement. That all it would take was for Israel to withdraw from the Philadelphi Corridor to get all the hostages back.
It’s hard to blame them. Irresponsible individuals in the media and government gave them the impression that this was possible, that Netanyahu was the only obstacle to a deal. But this is a complete lie – even according to the U.S. administration, which has had its disagreements with Netanyahu. Sinwar and those orchestrating this conflict, primarily Iran, aim to wear us down in a prolonged war, keeping hostages until the very last moment, partly to ensure that calls for incitement like those heard yesterday continue.
But at no point, from the first deal onward, were we ever close to signing an agreement for the hostages’ return. It was never on the table except in the fevered imaginations of a few who even the events of October 7 didn’t wake from their delusions.
The only thing that might have advanced the hostages’ return would be a surrender agreement, where the war ends, Israel withdraws from Gaza, military achievements are nullified, and Sinwar returns to leadership. Perhaps then we’d get some hostages back, but not all – because that’s not in Hamas’ interest. Hamas’ interest is always to keep some hostages. The purveyors of this lie then continue it today.
Histadrut labor union Chairman Arnon Bar-David declared a general strike, as if Israel was the one refusing to bring back our hostages, punishing us all. While our best soldiers risk their lives in Gaza and Lebanon to protect our security and keep the economy moving forward, Bar-David dismisses this sacrifice as if it were trivial. People are being evacuated from their homes, others are desperate for work, and yet he strikes. Thankfully, he didn’t call for unity.
It would be appropriate to say that those who contributed to this situation and yesterday’s incitement should do some soul-searching, but that’s expecting too much. Those who didn’t hesitate to mislead the hostages’ families with a deal that was never around the corner, those who didn’t shy away from using the mantra of “this is the last chance,” certainly won’t reflect on their role in this false hope of a deal that was never on the table. They can only blame themselves, but such soul-searching requires a high level of emotional intelligence. It’s easier to blame Netanyahu. Who else can they blame, Sinwar?

Hamas has taken the Israeli spirit hostage too

Through our tears and with hearts shattered six times over, here’s a sobering truth that cuts through the emotion: Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar doesn’t want a deal right now. He needs the hostages to ensure his survival and to keep extorting us. His strategy is to wear us down, to prolong our internal conflicts indefinitely, stretching them out for months and years to come. As long as possible. And we’re playing right into his hands.

The public, guided by the “Kaplan protesters” – meaning the masses protesting in Kaplan St. in Tel Aviv, and the understandably distraught families of hostages, unwittingly dances to the tune of Sinwar, the chief executioner. While no one can stand in those families’ shoes or criticize them, they’re unknowingly actors in a play Sinwar has written and continues to direct. Although Hamas is the murderer, the blame and protests are directed at Netanyahu and his ministers, as if they were the killers. This only gives Sinwar more reasons to dig in his heels. In this case, it’s not God hardening Pharaoh’s heart, but the public – awash in a flood of uniform media messages – failing to see that they’re hurting the hostages more than helping them.

Instead of tens or hundreds of thousands gathering at the Egyptian and Gaza borders, or thousands protesting outside Qatari embassies worldwide, crowds are massing at the wrong address. The hostages aren’t being held in the city of Caesarea or Tel Aviv’s Ayalon road. Believe it or not, despite his many critics and undeniable missteps, even Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu wants to bring the hostages home.

Israel agreed to President Joe Biden’s proposal and even its revisions. It might agree to further updates, but Sinwar isn’t interested. So Netanyahu and his government, whose negotiating positions can be debated, aren’t really relevant right now. That is unless someone’s willing to agree to Israel’s complete surrender and total withdrawal from Gaza “lock, stock, and barrel.” Even then, the international community won’t give Israel the green light to return to the Philadelphi Corridor. Even if the world turned upside down, and the weapons caches, Hamas terrorists, and rockets waiting in Sinai for Israel’s withdrawal made their way back into Gaza – which has become a modern-day Sodom.

The most clear-headed response to the execution of the six hostages by these new Nazis came from Washington. President Biden and Vice President Kamala Harris declared Hamas guilty and vowed they would pay. The question of how they’ll pay should be answered in Israel. We should set the price. The first step, which I proposed here two days after the Oct. 7 massacre, is to pass a law to bring Hamas and its collaborators to justice. We should conduct an expanded “Eichmann trial” against them – a trial that will expose, over time, the full scope of the atrocities Hamas has committed here in the last ten months and stretching back decades.

The second step is to make it crystal clear that Israel will permanently maintain a security buffer zone inside the Gaza Strip, along the border. The loss of this “holy ground” is the surest way to make the Hamas scums understand there’s a price for their murderous actions. Additional steps include further dividing the Strip into smaller, controlled areas and continuing to hunt down Hamas leaders in Gaza and worldwide. We should pursue them just as we did the murderers of the Munich Olympics athletes during Operation “Wrath of God” in former Israeli Prime Minister Golda Meir’s time – terrorists who also killed their hostages.

A deal, as much as we wish for it, exists only in our imagination right now. There’s no agreement on the table. We’re mainly negotiating with ourselves, caught in a spiral of self-flagellation. It’s not just the hostages who need to be freed, but the Israeli spirit itself, which Hamas continues to batter and manipulate within us.

UNRWA at war 2024 – English

The Israel-Hamas ‘War of Iron Swords’ was born in the UNRWA classroom, as decades of education to genocide revealed to the world on October 7, 2023. The Hamas takeover of UNRWA can no longer be denied.

Why did negotiations break down?

The hostages-ceasefire negotiations have broken down because of insufficient pressure from the Biden administration on Hamas’s patrons in Qatar. 
The failure of the negotiations should be attributed to Qatar’s lack of action against the Hamas leaders who are living in luxury in Doha. 
 
Qatar is not doing anything because it is not under any serious pressure from the Biden administration. 
 
Has the Biden administration considered using the threat of withdrawing the US Central Command from Qatar’s Al-Udeid Air Base from to pressure the Gulf state’s rulers into convincing their friends in Hamas to free all the hostages?

‘UNRWA at war’: New film shows UN agency teaching kids to kill in Judea and Samaria

evelations by Israel’s government about the United Nations Relief and Works Agency have shattered the group’s carefully cultivated image as a humanitarian organization, revealing it to be no less than an arm of Hamas in Gaza. However, little light has been thrown on UNRWA’s identical role in Judea and Samaria.

A new film, “UNRWA at War,” focuses on the educational side of UNRWA’s activities, in which children are taught not just to hate, but to kill. Just as it did in Gaza, UNRWA is inculcating children with the same genocidal creed in Judea and Samaria, only in this case for Fatah, the controlling party in the Palestinian Authority.

The roughly 20-minute film was released by the Jerusalem-based Center for Near East Policy Research on Sept. 1 and is available online.

The center’s director, David Bedein, told JNS that the movie shows what’s happening in Bethlehem. “That’s the next place they [the terrorists] are going to break out,” he said.

When could such an attack take place? “It could be as soon as tomorrow,” he said.

The film shows that terrorists, such as Dalal Mughrabi, a Fatah member who participated in the 1978 Coastal Road massacre in Israel, in which 38 Israeli civilians, including 13 children, were murdered, are routinely held up as heroes and role models in UNRWA schools. Images of Mughrabi and other terrorists adorn the schools’ walls.

In the film, Arab students in Judea and Samaria, products of UNRWA schools, speak of Mughrabi with reverence.

“She’s like my sister, like my mother. She’s part of our people,” says a boy from the Al-Amari refugee camp east of Ramallah. A girl of about six, also from Al-Amari, says, “Dhalal Mughrabi is a Palestinian martyr. She fought against the Jews. She blew them up.”

Bedein, who has been sounding the alarm regarding UNRWA for decades, describes the indoctrination the kids are receiving as “murder education.” UNRWA, he said, is a “machine” that produces genocidal children in a “cookie-cutter” manner.

Kutaiba Hatab, 15, from the Jalazone refugee camp. Credit: UNRWA at War.

Kutaiba Hatab, 15, attends the UNRWA Boys School in the Jalazone refugee camp north of Ramallah in Samaria. Asked in the film what he’s taught about the right of return, he says, “To fight, and to keep fighting, until Palestine is liberated!” He goes on to state that when he grows up, “I’ll be a jihadist and fight for Allah!”

“Do you hate Jews,” an interviewer asks Rada Abu-Hatab, 12, an UNRWA student in Jenin. “Yes, a lot,” she answers. “I want to fight and become a martyr and ascend to heaven with Allah!”

Mohammed Mahmud Khalil, an UNRWA student from Ein Arik, an Arab town near Ramallah, says, “What is the solution to Jerusalem? To kill the Jews. We’ll get rid of the Jews … With Allah’s help, I will become a holy warrior.”

All the children connected the Hamas invasion of Oct. 7 to the right of return, characterizing the gruesome attack as an effort to liberate the land from the Jews.

“Oct. 7 is related to the right of return because Hamas reconquered part of our land that was taken by the occupiers,” says Osama Belashe, an UNRWA student from Jalazone. “In school our teacher taught us we have to return. Even if Israel gives us compensation [to stay here] we have to return.”

For Bedein, the most important thing the film documents is that at UNRWA, children receive military training. In previous films, Bedein has shown that these training camps were set up near Israel Defense Forces bases.

He worries that Israel has been slow to adapt to the post-Oct. 7 reality. “They’re making the same mistake they made last October, not paying attention to the preparations for war in the UNRWA camps,” he said.

However, he sees signs of awakening, noting a recent Israel Army Radio report that the military intended to investigate military training at UNRWA camps.

And next week, Bedein is to present his findings to a Knesset committee. “People who did not take me seriously over a period of 36 years are now taking me seriously,” he said.

Incompetence, or willful blindness, on the part of the Israeli authorities is a recurring theme for Bedein.

He said the Foreign Ministry has a special division dedicated to overseeing UNRWA, yet its representatives were oblivious regarding the weapons held at UNRWA camps. He brought them to the Askar camp bordering Nablus (Shechem) to show them. “They had no idea about the guns,” he said.

Moreover, Israel never exercised what oversight it had, he said. “Israel has the power to veto anything in Palestinian education. What we learned from Oct. 7 is that they weren’t doing it,” he added.

“Back in the 1980s, I began this conversation with how humanitarian supplies were sold in the open market and with no supervision,” Bedein said. “And they [Israel] didn’t make any changes. There was no oversight. To say they’re not doing their job is an understatement,” he added.

David Bedein, director of the Center for Near East Policy Research. Photo by David Michael Cohen.

Although many have argued for doing away with UNRWA, according to Bedein that’s not a realistic solution. The organization is too embedded in the territories and in the United Nations, and the General Assembly would never accept it, he argued. However, he continued, it is possible to change UNRWA from within by pointing out the absurd situation and demanding change.

“The theme of UNRWA education is ‘peace starts here,’” he said. “How could it possibly be that a U.N. social work agency would be using their education system to prepare kids for war?”

Bedein has put together a five-point plan for changing UNRWA from within:

1. Cancellation of the new UNRWA curriculum based on jihad.

2. Disarmament of UNRWA schools and cessation of paramilitary training.

3. Dismissing UNRWA employees affiliated with Hamas, Islamic Jihad and Fatah.

4. Resettling fourth- and fifth-generation refugees from the 1948 war rather than keeping them in perpetual refugee status.

5. Demanding an audit of donor funds.

He has met five times with Antonio Guterres, the U.N. secretary general, whom he said is open to his proposals.

While UNRWA was always corrupt, it wasn’t always the way it is now, he said.

Even the children going through the schools, while they spoke of “their homes in Jaffa,” didn’t talk about going back and killing everyone in Jaffa as they do now, he said.

“The change took place after 1992 when the PLO was put in charge by [then-Foreign Minister] Shimon Peres,” he said. “UNRWA was handed over to the PLO.”

Going it alone

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu opens the weekly cabinet meeting at his Jerusalem office on February 10, 2019. - Nudged by rightwing political rivals after a deadly Palestinian attack on a young Israeli woman, Netanyahu who seeks re-election pledged today to freeze money transfers to the Palestinian Authority. (Photo by GALI TIBBON / POOL / AFP) (Photo credit should read GALI TIBBON/AFP/Getty Images)

Netanyahu has done many things throughout his many years in office. In my opinion, the scales are tipped against him in the balance of failures versus achievements, but now he plays a fateful, Churchillian role. He is facing terrible pressure from the hostile American government, which is also using at least some of the domestic subversion against him, and he is facing attempts at sedition, wild incitement, unbridled slander, and a public, which, although it is a minority, tries to burn the country in time of war as if there is no tomorrow and there are no enemies. He does all this in front of the majority of the hostile media, defeatist Chief of Staff and Minister of Defense who coordinate too much with the Americans and the corrupt justice system that does not lift a finger against the thieves of the state, the rebels, and the instigators, in a blatant display of hypocrisy and standing in favor of the rebels. This could be Netanyahu’s great and historic hour. His whole life so far, his whole career, all the mistakes he had to learn from—everything is now draining to a climax. A climax in insisting on eliminating Hamas, destroying Gaza, and proving that it does not pay to massacre the Jews in the State of Israel, and also a climax on the Iranian issue, which is now reaching the final stage of developing atomic bombs. If he stands up to the pressure and does what is assigned to him, which he knows very well, he will go down in history alongside Churchill, because not only the fate of Israel vis-à-vis Islam is now at stake, but also the fate of the Western world that has fought against that enemy. Israel defeating Hams may provide proof and a personal example that extreme Islam can be defeated, so Netanyahu’s role is twofold. We are in a critical period. We have the ability to turn it into a great period, our most beautiful hour. Today I am strengthening Netanyahu’s hand and keeping my fingers crossed for him.

Israel: Ceasefire Deal Will Prevent Hostages from Coming Home, Anti-Government Protests Only Embolden Hamas

Masked Hamas militants hold weapons during a protest against Israel's attacks on the Gaza Strip, in Gaza City, Monday, March 3, 2008. In the early hours of Monday, Palestinians counted nine separate Israeli airstrikes on weapons manufacturing and storage facilities, a Hamas headquarters and groups of gunmen, all over Gaza. Five Palestinians were killed in the strikes, all of them Hamas militants, Hamas said. (AP Photo/Khalil Hamra) *** Local Caption *** ??? ??????

Hamas leaders, who are closely observing the protests, are likely to harden their stance in the hope that the Israeli government will give in to the demonstrators’ demands, including an immediate and unconditional ceasefire in the Gaza Strip. Hamas has the Israeli public pressuring their government to allow Hamas to “live to fight another day”: to rearm, regroup and continue attacking Israelis – as Hamas official Ghazi Hamad vowed.

 

No More Credibility for You, Israel-Bashers

Photo by Aaron Kittredge on Pexels.com

“What we do believe is that they heard us,” Gaza protest organizer Hatem Abudayyeh tells a New York Times reporter.

Sure, “they” – Democratic leaders – “heard” self-appointed activists for the Palestinians during the four-day Democratic National Convention. They heard Abudayyeh’s peers urge that a pro-Arab speaker address the convention, that the government impose an arms embargo on Israel and that a cease-fire go into effect to end the conflict between Israel and Hamas.

On the third day of the convention, Democratic leaders refused any speaking slot for a pro-Arab representative despite months of negotiations, protest leaders said. Nor have there been any of the policy changes that they demanded.

“There have been no changes made, there have been no statements made that are in line with what we want to happen,” complained Ashley Taylor-Gouge, a member of the Minnesota Anti-War Committee, as quoted in the Times.

The pro-Arab network has spent the past 5½ years pressuring Democrats to undermine Israel, forcing them to walk a tightrope between Israel-bashers and the Jewish community. Not now. A week ago, I was ready to suggest that their influence could be waning. Not could be. It is waning. They have lost much of their credibility, and both protesters and high-level Democrats agree with that assessment, in so many words.

A relatively low turnout materialized for their demonstrations in Chicago last week. It was still a substantial amount of people, but far lighter than they expected.

“A small handful of people does not represent close to even a sliver of where the Democratic Party is right now,” declared Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer on Thursday, the last night of the convention, according to the Associated Press.

Protest organizer Taher Herzallah affirmed the national Democrats’ attitude, saying, “People are trying to employ different tactics because we recognize that after 10 months of being on the streets, we have to deploy different tactics to make sure we are being heard,” according to the Times.

They are being heard. None of us can avoid hearing it. Their problem is that much fewer Americans are buying it. Not “Free Palestine.” Not “globalize Intifada.”

First they exposed their mobster-like operation during last spring’s campus harassment of Jewish students, installation of illegal encampments, seizure of buildings and resistance to police. Not to mention blocking already congested bridges, highways and airport entrances. Many threatened to ignore both Biden and former President Donald J. Trump at the polls, which could tip elections in swing states to Trump.

Then on July 21, President Biden endorsed Vice President Kamala Harris as the Democratic nominee for president after dropping out of the race. Liberals, especially women, flooded a movement to elect Harris as president. Even those who sympathized with the Palestinians probably placed the Gaza war issue on the backburner. They have made it obvious that electing the first woman as president – one who will fight to enact liberal policies – is among their top priorities.

It would not surprise me if many Arab-American women vote for Harris rather than cast a protest vote for an independent candidate or not vote at all in standing up for the Palestinians. In Arab countries, subjugation of women is the rule and that system has been exported here to some extent. This election will be a golden opportunity to rebel – if they are allowed to vote.

Biden and Harris both tossed verbal bones to protesters during their speeches at the DNC.

“Those protesters out in the streets, they have a point,” said Biden. “A lot of innocent people are being killed on both sides.”

What point do they have? Yes, many “innocent people” are being killed. We learned that once tragic events unfolded since Oct. 7, the day when Hamas murdered 1,200 Israelis in southern Israel and took 240 others hostage. That was followed by Israel’s response that killed thousands of Gazans. What did Biden say that should satisfy the pro-Arab activists?

Harris’ words did little to appease them: “I will always stand up for Israel’s right to defend itself and I will always ensure Israel has the ability to defend itself…the people of Israel must never again face the horror that a terrorist organization called Hamas caused on October 7.”

She then referred to Gazan deaths as “devastating” and described the “scale of suffering” as “heartbreaking.” She also said she hopes that “the Palestinian people can realize their right to dignity, security, freedom and self-determination.” Is that what they want? Hamas seeks to destroy Israel and at least some Palestinians feel that way. The Palestinian leadership has rejected proposals for a two-state solution in the past.

As evidence that activists recognize that their cause has weakened, two organizers cited the need to release Israeli hostages during a television interview. That is unusual. For almost 11 months, advocates for Gazans have typically ignored the plight of hostages and other examples of Israeli suffering. That would be an attempt at respectability. Too late for most of us.

In another sign of desperation, activists are pouncing on African Americans for gathering behind Harris, who is part Black, while abandoning the Palestinian cause. “I’m so sick and tired of Americans playing your identity politics,” said a British Israel-basher on TikTok who claimed to be part Palestinian. “It’s f-ing insane, a Black woman in f-ing presidency is not going to save us, and no I’m not f-ing saying vote Trump in.”

The New York Post reports that another British Muslim attacked liberals for “weaponizing anti-blackness to defend the US empire all because they want a token ethnic president…She has very clearly stated that she won’t impose an arms embargo…It’s very clear where she stands.”

They are assuming that Black voters so identify with the Palestinians that their so-called struggle takes in all causes. “These are people who feel that they are entitled to the support of Black people no matter what, that they get to push us around and tell us who the hell we get to vote for if we support them,” TikTokker Tori Grier pushed back. “As if that means we’re just not supposed to give a damn about ourselves.”

Pushback is evolving in various ways, especially on college campuses. New York Gov. Kathy Hochul on Monday held a conference call with 200 college and university leaders to reinforce the need to devise and implement emergency plans as students return to campus this fall, according to a news release. She also noted that they can connect with necessary resources.

Many colleges nationwide are preparing for the possible onslaught of protests. Swarthmore hired outside investigators to build cases against students, The Philadelphia Inquirer reports. Rutgers has banned encampments.

In Manhattan, Sonia Ossorio joined other women’s rights to press Antonio Guterres, secretary general of the United Nations, “to demand a full investigation of systemic rape during the Oct. 7 attacks and for the perpetrators to be held accountable for war crimes.”

In a Newsweek opinion piece, Ossorio writes, “The protests in and of themselves are not the issue…denying, downplaying and justifying rape and murder is inconsistent with protesting on behalf of human rights. Protests should not justify extremism. They should not excuse rape, they should not mislabel a terrorist attack as “a historic win for the Palestinian resistance.”

Ossorio, the executive director of the National Organization for Women New York City and Women’s Justice NOW, adds, “This lack of accountability isn’t an issue unique to Oct. 7. Women’s equality and women’s right to live free of sexual terror deserves greater world attention.”

The DNC’s resistance to the protest tactics should be studied by university officials, writes former federal prosecutor Gregory J. Wallance in The Hill, a Capitol Hill publication. “A no-appeasement policy should be the guiding principle for how, going forward, universities deal with disruptive, sometimes antisemitic pro-Palestinian demonstrations,” Wallance writes.

A no-appeasement policy is awfully late in coming, but it has arrived. Pro-Arab activists are on notice.

The Hostage Murders and the New Threat

An American has been murdered in the tunnels under Rafah—and by at least one IDF account at some point in the past day or so. Hersh Goldberg-Polin’s parents, Rachel and Jon, have represented the best of us, the most civilized, the most controlled, the most noble of us Jews battling to maintain our emotional stability in the face of what has gone on in Israel and in America since October 7. They are Jewish heroes. And now their son Hersh is a Jewish martyr. The crime done to him is unspeakable. The crime done to them is no less unspeakable. His body was found with five other survivors of 10/7, all of whom had families and loved ones and babies on the way.

And I cannot help but ask. I cannot. Had the Biden administration’s will not been bent and twisted in the months following the attack by the fiendish propaganda campaign causing them to worry about the war’s effect on Joe’s chances in Michigan—due to a population that effectively supported the terrorist monsters and cared not a whit for the eight Americans, let alone the 240 other innocents dragged into Hell—would Hersh and these others have survived? Imagine an Israel that had not found itself restrained and under assault, not told to pause, not scolded in pissy little phone calls with petulant American establishmentarians, without arms and aid held up, without being lectured about the geostrategic value of going slow or not going at all.

Imagine an Israel that was not told by its best friend in the world that offensive action in Gaza had become self-defeating, was not told that Israel should care more about feeding people in Gaza than about eliminating the threat to its 9 million citizens and pummelling Hamas until that evil group of thugs cried uncle and begged for way to negotiate to return the hostages.

Imagine an America that did not lose its nerve under a president whose team knew perfectly well he was infirm and was working desperately to stave off his eventual collapse and departure from the race to save their own rotten and misbegotten jobs. Imagine an America that had said, “You have right and justice on your side, and your actions in the first two months of the war succeeded in getting 78 hostages home. You keep on doing what you’re doing until they’re all home.” Imagine an America that wasn’t secretly ashamed by its own inability to secure victory in war and didn’t therefore see Israel’s insistence that victory was the only way forward as a moral rebuke to our own divided soul.

Imagine what might have been. Do not be unburdened by that. Be burdened by that. Ask yourself if an Israel that had done in Rafah over the past six weeks—had trapped the Hamas leadership, had begun eliminating the Hamas leadership, had pinpointed its attacks to a degree that the death toll in Gaza for all except Hamas seniors fell precipitously—had done this in March rather than in August.

Hamas is the evil here. America is not responsible for the deaths of anyone in Gaza, and anyone who says otherwise is a moral idiot—just like those deranged people who seem determined to blame Bibi Netanyahu for not surrendering to Hamas, as though the hostage deals of the past, like the one that freed Hamas mastermind Yahya Sinwar in 2011, weren’t among the root causes of this horrible conflict.

But we Americans are morally liable for our role in our backseat-driving in this war, for screaming at the Israelis at the wheel, unnerving them as they were trying to keep their eye on the road ahead.

Hersh Goldberg-Polin was 23 years old. There are two babies there, somewhere, in those tunnels that Kamala Harris said Israel should not go into. At her convention, Rachel and Jon spoke. America wept. Then Kamala Harris gave her speech and said Israel had the right to defend herself BUT there was too much killing and we needed a ceasefire and a hostage deal and a two-state solution and for the oceans to turn to lemonade, which is about as likely in the foreseeable future as a two-state solution.

And Hamas saw her, and saw Biden, and was so terrified by what they saw, so fearful of America’s martial response to their evil, that they killed Hersh and the five others whose bodies were found—and who knows who else yet.

This is a dangerous moment. This monstrous act of villainy will not quiet the campuses as the anniversary of October 7 approaches. No, it will embolden the very monsters who have been psychologically torturing Jewish students—and assaulting them in some cases—over the past year. The stories we’ve read in the past two days about the report of Columbia University’s anti-Semitism task force chill the blood. “Hillel Go to Hell,” read a banner at a Baruch College demonstration this week, in case you were wondering if things were going to quiet down.

The threats were real then and they are going to be even more real now, as those who support the destruction of the Jewish state and the crushing of the spirit and the freedom of American Jews make their moves over the next month. Their intention is to take over the anniversary of the massacre and turn it into a tribute, as they plan to do at the University of Maryland.

We don’t need to read Joe Biden issuing statements of outrage about Hersh. We need to see that things are going to be done to protect America’s Jews from the evil that might be visited upon us as we tick down the days until it’s been a year since Jews were plunged into this existential battle designed to destabilize the Jewish state and drive American Jews underground.

Joe Biden was sitting on the beach this afternoon as the Israelis recovered the bodies. He is a spent force, a quartered roasted duck. So what are you going to do about it, Ms. Harris? What are you going to do?