Israel has invited the United States to relocate some of its regional bases from countries such as Qatar to Israel. But that raises a question: Why are the U.S. regional headquarters in a country that actively sponsors terrorism?

It’s a relatively recent development. For decades, Saudi Arabia served as the U.S.’s regional headquarters. It was from there—not Qatar—that the U.S. assembled forces and ultimately launched the Gulf War to liberate Kuwait. After 9/11 and the Iraq War, the U.S. sought a country with fewer political constraints and a location that would recruit fewer jihadists by being farther from Islam’s two holiest sites. Qatar fit the bill: no political complications, billions of dollars in subsidies, and the ready-to-use Al Udeid Air Base.

Now, more than 20 years later, Israel is positioning itself as the U.S.’s new home away from home in the region. The Israeli security establishment sees an opportunity to “reshape the map” of U.S. military positioning in the Middle East, reports Israel’s Channel 12.

There are several advantages to this move. For one, Israel has the strongest air defense systems in the region. The New York Times reported Wednesday that missile attacks on Qatar have forced “many American troops to relocate to hotels and office spaces throughout the region,” with much of the land-based military “fighting the war while working remotely, with the exception of fighter pilots and crews operating and maintaining warplanes and conducting strikes.” Meanwhile, the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) haven’t missed a day of work.

Another advantage is the close alliance between the U.S. and Israel. They’ve been conducting joint operations, gone on foreign trips together, and built a relationship where coordination is seamless. Isn’t it time to move in together? After all, the U.S. and Israel share strategic goals in the region, and operating from Israel means the U.S. doesn’t risk hitting targets that would be rebuilt by the same country they launched from.

Add to the fact that Qatar has not always been a cooperative host. In April 2025, Qatar [along with Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates (UAE)] said that they would not allow American warplanes to use Persian Gulf bases or airspace to strike Iran. Earlier this year, a prominent Qatari royal called the U.S. “merely a tenant of a military base in Qatar” and warned, “Do not act as if you are doing us a favor.” While this may have been largely rhetorical, Qatari sentiments have grown more skeptical since missile strikes began, and it is not a sentiment the U.S. is likely to encounter in Israel.

But there are a few disadvantages as well, the most prominent being geographical. Israel is roughly 1,000 miles west of Qatar. Sure, that means fewer missiles can reach it, but it is more useful for the U.S. if they want to fly over Beirut—less so for strikes on Tehran.

Qatar also subsidizes the upkeep of its base to the tune of billions of dollars. Israel’s defense budget hit record highs this year, but an extra few billion is still significant for a country without endless oil wealth that has been paying for a highly active war for the past two years.

Regional allies are unlikely to be thrilled either. Some, like Turkey, would be opposed out of that early-2000s distaste for Israel, while others—Kuwait, the UAE, and Saudi Arabia—may object simply because it means American help is now farther away.

The U.S. and Israel are currently negotiating this proposal. U.S. Central Command is unlikely to fully relocate from Qatar, but there could very well be a new U.S. base established. As U.S. Secretary of State Alexander Haig famously said, Israel is “the largest American aircraft carrier in the world that cannot be sunk”—and the U.S. may finally be looking to put that to use.

Overnight, the Knesset successfully passed the largest state budget in Israel’s history. Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich called the NIS 850.6 billion ($271 billion) spending bill “a budget that takes care of everyone and fights the cost of living,” while opposition leader Yair Lapid called it “the greatest theft in the history of the state.” Whether Lapid is correct or not, this budget is historic.

For the first time in his nearly 20 years as prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu has successfully passed a budget in an election year—a milestone that secures the government against collapse through the end of its term. In his six previous terms, for one reason or another, he never reached this point. Even if the ultra-Orthodox were to bring down the coalition in the next legislative session, the earliest elections that could be held would be in September—just one month short of the government’s full term. This makes the current Knesset the longest-serving government Israel has had since 1969. That’s right: more than 50 years. Israeli politics has a long-standing tradition of chaos and self-destruction.

Yet history doesn’t come cheap. At the last moment, the coalition approved amendments allocating approximately NIS 800 million ($255 million) to Haredi programs and institutions. This was compensation for the ultra-Orthodox parties’ support, as they voted in favor of the budget despite the coalition not enacting the blanket exemptions from military conscription for yeshiva students that they had demanded.

According to Channel 13, the budget increased allocations to Haredi educational institutions by more than NIS 1 billion ($318 million). But the Haredim weren’t the biggest beneficiaries of the night—the defense budget received a NIS 28 billion ($9 billion) raise, bringing it to NIS 143 billion ($45.8 billion). That’s double the 2022 allocation.

Last night was also historic in that, for the first time, nearly the entire Knesset had to vote from protected spaces as Jerusalem came under fire. I’m not sure if Iran was planning on preventing the IDF from being funded, but firing missiles isn’t exactly the way to convince a country to cut its defense spending.

Also in Jerusalem yesterday, police prevented the Latin Patriarch of Jerusalem from praying at the Holy Sepulchre on Palm Sunday. Have Tucker Carlson’s fantasies finally become a reality? Has Israel finally started persecuting Christians?

Not quite.

I have a rule: Whenever a minister is involved, the situation falls into one of two categories—House of Cards or Saturday Night Live. This was SNL. Simply put, the police in the Old City didn’t fully understand the sensitivity of the issue and were following Home Front Command directives to prevent large gatherings. Before the situation could be clarified, the story went viral, and everyone started offering their takes—some claiming Israel was persecuting Christians, others, if Israeli, blaming the current government.

The whole issue was resolved within a day. This morning, police announced that limited numbers would be allowed into the Holy Sepulchre. For context, Home Front Command directives also currently prevent prayers on the Temple Mount or at the Western Wall, and neither has caused an international incident.

A well-known exchange, between David Ben-Gurion and U.S. Secretary of State John Foster Dulles in 1954, captures something most people still don’t understand.

Dulles reportedly challenged Ben-Gurion, asking how Israel could claim to represent one people after 2,000 years of exile, scattered across continents, cultures, and languages. It’s a fair question, if you think a nation is defined only by land.

Ben-Gurion’s response reframed everything. He suggested that Dulles go out and find ten American children and ask them simple questions about the Mayflower, who was the captain, how long was the journey, what did they eat. Most wouldn’t know.

Then he said, go find ten Jewish children, anywhere in the world, and ask them who took the Jews out of Egypt, how long it took to reach the Land of Israel, what they ate in the desert, and what happened when they reached the sea. And you will get answers.

Not because of trivia, because of memory. Because across continents, languages, and centuries, the Jewish people carried the same story, told the same way, around the same table, year after year.

A nation is not only geography. It is continuity. It is shared narrative. It is ritual lived in real time.

Empires rise and fall on power. The Jewish people endured on memory.

That is what nationhood looks like when it is built not only on land, but on memory.

Defying Fear, Embracing Zion

The air raid sirens wail, a stark reminder of the ever-present threat. Yet, even as rockets streak across the Israeli sky and the echoes of war reverberate, a powerful testament to the enduring spirit of Zionism unfolds: North American Jews are continuing to make Aliyah, immigrating to Israel in numbers that defy the anxieties of the moment. This isn’t simply a relocation; it’s a profound statement of faith, resilience, and an unshakeable belief in the future of the Jewish homeland.

While some might assume that the recent conflict would deter potential immigrants, the reality is far more nuanced. Yes, there is apprehension, a natural human response to danger. But for many North American Jews, the desire to be part of the Israeli story, to contribute to its growth and security, outweighs the perceived risks. The shared sense of purpose, the feeling of belonging to a nation fighting for its survival, has become a powerful magnet.

“We are seeing a continued interest in Aliyah, and in some cases, even an increase,” says Rabbi Yehoshua Fass, Executive Director of Nefesh B’Nefesh, an organization that facilitates Aliyah from North America. “People understand that Israel is not just a place, but a people, and they want to be a part of that people, especially during challenging times.”

The Pull of Shared Destiny

Several factors contribute to this unwavering commitment. Firstly, the deep-rooted connection to Jewish history and heritage remains a powerful motivator. For generations, Jews have yearned to return to their ancestral land, and the establishment of the State of Israel in 1948 fulfilled a centuries-old dream. This historical imperative continues to resonate strongly, inspiring many to make the move, regardless of the current security situation. According to a 2023 Pew Research Center study, 82% of American Jews feel at least some connection to Israel, with a significant percentage feeling very attached. This emotional bond transcends geopolitical considerations.

Secondly, the rise of antisemitism in North America and Europe is undeniably a contributing factor. A recent report by the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) revealed a staggering 388% increase in antisemitic incidents in the United States following the October 7th attacks. This alarming trend has left many Jews feeling vulnerable and exposed in their diaspora communities, prompting them to seek refuge and security in Israel, where they believe they will be safer and more accepted.

Furthermore, the strong sense of community and mutual support within Israel is a significant draw. New immigrants often speak of the warmth and acceptance they experience upon arrival, the feeling of being surrounded by people who understand their values and share their aspirations. This sense of belonging is particularly important during times of crisis, when the support of family, friends, and neighbors can make all the difference. Organizations like Nefesh B’Nefesh and the Jewish Agency for Israel provide comprehensive support to new immigrants, helping them navigate the complexities of settling in a new country and building a new life.

Beyond the Headlines: The Real Stories

The statistics tell one story, but the individual narratives paint an even more compelling picture. Consider the story of Sarah and David, a young couple from Toronto who had been planning their Aliyah for years. When the war broke out, their families urged them to reconsider, fearing for their safety. But Sarah and David were resolute. They felt a deep sense of responsibility to be in Israel during this difficult time, to stand in solidarity with their fellow Jews. They arrived in Tel Aviv just weeks after the attacks, determined to contribute to the war effort and build a life in their new homeland. Sarah, a trained nurse, volunteered at a local hospital, while David, an engineer, joined a team working on developing new defense technologies.

Then there’s the story of elderly Holocaust survivor, Ruth, who had always dreamed of making Aliyah but felt it was too late in her life. However, the recent surge in antisemitism and the events of October 7th rekindled her desire to return to the land of her ancestors. With the help of her grandchildren and Nefesh B’Nefesh, she finally made the move, finding solace and comfort in being surrounded by other Jews who understood her history and shared her hopes for the future. Ruth now lives in a retirement community in Jerusalem, where she spends her days sharing her story and connecting with younger generations.

These are just two examples of the many inspiring stories of North American Jews who are choosing to make Aliyah despite the challenges. Their courage, determination, and unwavering commitment to Israel are a testament to the enduring power of Zionism.

Economic Realities and Future Prospects

Beyond the emotional and spiritual factors, economic considerations also play a role in the decision to make Aliyah. While the cost of living in Israel can be high, particularly in major cities like Tel Aviv and Jerusalem, there are also significant economic opportunities, especially in the tech sector. Israel is a global hub for innovation and entrepreneurship, attracting talent from around the world. Many North American Jews, particularly those with skills and experience in high-tech industries, see Aliyah as a chance to advance their careers and build a better future for their families. A 2022 study by the Israel Innovation Authority found that approximately 25% of Israeli startups were founded by immigrants.

Furthermore, the Israeli government offers a range of financial incentives and support programs to encourage Aliyah. These include tax breaks, housing subsidies, and assistance with finding employment. These programs can make a significant difference in the financial viability of Aliyah, particularly for those who are starting from scratch. In 2023, the Ministry of Aliyah and Integration allocated over 1.5 billion shekels to support new immigrants, demonstrating the government’s commitment to facilitating Aliyah.

The long-term economic impact of Aliyah is also significant. New immigrants bring with them valuable skills, knowledge, and experience, which contribute to the growth and development of the Israeli economy. They also create jobs and stimulate demand for goods and services. A 2019 study by the Bank of Israel estimated that each new immigrant contributes an average of 200,000 shekels to the Israeli economy over their lifetime.

Challenges and Adaptations

Of course, Aliyah is not without its challenges. Adapting to a new culture, learning a new language, and navigating a different bureaucracy can be daunting. New immigrants often face difficulties finding suitable housing, securing employment, and integrating into Israeli society. The language barrier can be particularly challenging, especially for those who do not speak Hebrew fluently. However, with the help of support organizations and the willingness to embrace new experiences, these challenges can be overcome.

Moreover, the ongoing security situation in Israel presents unique challenges for new immigrants. The threat of rocket attacks, terrorist attacks, and regional conflicts can be unsettling, particularly for those who are not accustomed to living in a conflict zone. However, Israelis have developed a remarkable resilience in the face of adversity, and new immigrants quickly learn to adapt to the security realities of life in Israel. They also find comfort and support in the strong sense of community and mutual aid that exists within Israeli society.

“We are committed to providing new immigrants with the support they need to overcome these challenges and build successful lives in Israel,” says Rabbi Fass. “We believe that Aliyah is not just good for the individual, but also good for the State of Israel.”

A Future Forged in Unity

The decision to make Aliyah is a deeply personal one, driven by a complex mix of motivations. But for North American Jews, the current conflict has served to underscore the importance of solidarity and shared destiny. As rockets fall and tensions rise, they are choosing to stand with Israel, not just in spirit, but in person. Their presence reinforces the strength and resilience of the Jewish state, sending a clear message that despite the challenges, the dream of a secure and prosperous homeland for the Jewish people will endure. The current war has led to a 12% increase in Aliyah inquiries compared to the same period last year, demonstrating the growing desire to connect with Israel during times of crisis.

In the face of adversity, the unwavering commitment of North American Jews to Aliyah serves as a beacon of hope and a testament to the enduring power of the Zionist dream. It’s a story of courage, resilience, and an unshakeable belief in the future of Israel. As Israel navigates these turbulent times, the influx of new immigrants brings not only fresh perspectives and skills but also a renewed sense of purpose and determination. The act of making Aliyah during wartime is a powerful statement of solidarity, a declaration that the Jewish people will continue to build and thrive in their ancestral homeland, no matter the challenges they face. The future of Israel is being forged not only on the battlefield but also in the hearts and minds of those who choose to make it their home.