Rabbi Leo Dee: Ordinary Palestinians silently thank Allah for the Jenin operation

When Lucy, Maia and Rina were suddenly and brutally taken from this world during Pesach, I cried in pain. Not against every Arab, not against every Muslim, but against every terrorist.

I have Palestinian friends and acquaintances. That is the norm when you live in Efrat. Indeed it is the norm when you live in any location in Judea and Samaria (unaffectionately known as the “West Bank”).

Our local supermarket is located in Area C and I select my tomatoes and cucumbers standing next to Palestinian men and women who live in Bethlehem and Hebron. Unsurprisingly, most of these people are just like you and me. Many of them work in construction in Jerusalem or Beit Shemesh and earn more than twice what a Palestinian Authority employee (even a doctor) would earn in their own territory. This is the majority.

And then there are terrorists. They are not like you and me. They were mostly brought up in UNRWA run “refugee” towns and trained in terrorist skills during summer camps and fed hatred through Palestinian Authority textbooks that glorify past murderers of innocent civilians. That UNRWA even considers them refugees after 75 years is a direct result of United Nations antisemitism. Nobody, today, considers the millions of descendants of those 700,000 Jews expelled from Arab countries in the 1940’s and 1950’s as refugees.

What most people are unaware of is how the “good” Palestinians hate the terrorists. They despise them. However, they live in fear, in a terror state, the Palestinian Authority (PA). And the PA is funded by world governments to rule over the ten cities in the region and much of the land in between. The citizens of those 10 cities would prefer to run themselves under the protection of the IDF, but the presence of the PLO (the heavily armed PA army) is ubiquitous and feared. They unanimously describe the murderers of my family as “inhuman” and “not believing in Allah” when they see me. But only in private. A public statement would likely lead to them, and their families, being shot at in the street. And such shootings occur every day. These “good” Palestinians are the silent victims of PA terror.

Jenin has become a centre for such terror and the IDF is wise and brave to enter and eliminate it. The “good” Palestinians silently thank Allah for the operation, but they have little hope as the international funding of this terror state, which has no human rights (according to Freedom House 2023 data) and grants no freedom of speech, religion or right to vote, goes on and on.

When will the world wake up and realise that funding failed terror states is a crime against humanity? It is a crime against the Israeli victims and survivors, such as my family, and so many more, and against my two million Palestinian neighbours who just want to buy their tomatoes and cucumbers and live with us in Shalom.

Rabbi Leo Dee lives in Efrat with his three children and is the author of Transforming the World – The Jewish Impact on Modernity

My neighbors in Jenin, what future are you hoping for?

Greeting residents of the Jenin refugee camp which has become a terrorist hub, those who are not involved in terrorism. Seeing what you have had to endure, is painful. You live mere minutes from the 1967 border with Israel. We do not take pleasure in your trials and tribulations and would prefer to have neighbors who are content in their jobs, education, economic growth and industry. We cannot rejoice when our neighbors have made the industry of death the foundation of their identity.

Take note, Jenin refugee camp residents. You who are not involved in terrorism. The unified command of the terror factions, established bases in three areas of your camp, two of them, UNRWA facilities and one a school. They knew what they were doing. They wanted the IDF to strike those sites, in order to win points in the sphere of public opinion and increase the perception that Palestinians are victims.

תיעוד ההרס בג'נין לאחר יצאת כוחות צה''ל
Women walk past homes destroyed in the Jenin refugee camp on Wednesday (צילום: AFP)
Do you want that too? UNRWA provides you with food and education. How would you benefit from your schools or other servicing facilities being destroyed? You would be the victims of such a scenario. Is it not advisable to think of a change of course? Once you consider your own benefits, you would see who your real enemies are and we would both benefit from that.

 

You have representatives speaking on your behalf around the world, who tell themselves, their audiences and even you, that justice is on your side. You are “fighting the foreign occupiers,” they say. But they are wrong. Have you ever considered taking real stock of your situation? Have you asked yourselves what it is that you are seeking? Opportunities to end the occupation were presented to you over and over again but your leaders have always rejected them. Those alleged advocates are part and parcel of your tragedy. Rather than leading you to safety, and a better life, they nurture the illusions of justice under the rule of evil, foolishness and lethal weapons.
Your fight, we know well, is not against the Israeli occupation of the West Bank. You would do well to realize that you have become pawns in the hands of the international jihad and Iran. They are pulling the strings. Have they helped you at all? Quite on the contrary. Where ever jihad has taken hold, death and destruction soon followed.

תיעוד ההרס בג'נין לאחר יצאת כוחות צה''ל
A Palestinian woman walks by homes destroyed in the IDF offensive in the Jenin refugee camp (Photo: AP)

This has nothing to do with Israel. Lebanon has suffered from it for decades and continues to be a failed state. Over 80% of Lebanese live below the poverty line because of Iran, not Israel. Tehran has hundreds of millions of dollars invested in the industry of death and the production of more and more missiles and to what end? To fulfill the dream of destroying Israel.

Lebanon has the Iran-backed Hezbollah terror group and Jenin has the Palestinian Islamic Jihad. Yemen has been subjected to the same. Iran intervened in the internal conflict, flooding the Houthi rebels with weapons, creating nearly a million new refugees, killing nearly 400,000 people and causing widespread hunger. Your Nakba is a walk in the park compared to what the people of Yemen have been subjected to. So don’t say Israel and the occupation are to blame for your wows. Your fate will be to mirror Yemen and that will not be a source of pleasure for us.

תיעוד ההרס בג'נין לאחר יצאת כוחות צה''ל
A woman walks by a burned-ut vehicle in Jenin on Wednesday (Photo: AFP)

It is only a matter of time, sometimes hours, sometimes a couple or three days after Israel launches a military offensive before international public opinion will turn in your favor. Despite the fact that Israel is fighting terrorists, not civilians, you are still seen as victims of the military. But that should not be a source of pleasure because it will not result in any improvement in your life. The UN Human Rights Council will vote on a resolution to condemn Israel, and if you are lucky, some left-wing anti-Semites will organize protests in your support. Even in Israel, protesters have come out to condemn the military operation.

We see your streets celebrating and sweets offered to all after Jews are murdered in terror strikes. There will always be the idiot among us who will justify your conduct and post a tired of abuse against the IDF. He will tell you that your resistance against Israel is inspiring or that the military overlooks the fact that civilians are targeted in their operations and that that is horrendous. And it is. But no weekly anti-occupation protest will change that.

במחנה בורג' אל-בראג'נה מחלקים ממתקים לאחר הפיגוע בעלי
You regard such demonstrations as a sign of Israeli weakness, but they are a sign of a vibrant democracy that can withstand criticism and even malicious propaganda. The day you allow expressions of support for peace and condemnation of terror, without the speakers being killed in no time, will be a happy day that may indicate that change is coming.

But even now, after everything that has happened and despite it all, most Israelis extend their hands to you in peace, if only you would choose prosperity over terrorism. You are right that peace has been evaded for decades but for your sake as much as ours, let us hope it is achieved.

Why We Are Afraid, A 1400 Year Secret, by Dr Bill Warner

Why We Are Afraid is a lecture by Dr. Bill Warner with an accompanying PowerPoint Presentation. Its synopsis includes 1400 year history and the growth of Islam. Political Islam has subjugated civilizations for 1,400 years.

 

UNRWA’s Terrorists, by Ted Bellman

FirstOneThrough

Once again Israel is being forced to combat terrorists who have committed and plan to commit murderous attacks on civilians. Once more, the locus for the attacks is coming from United Nations’ “refugee” camps. Once again, the majority of the terrorists are Arabs whom the UN has told have rights to move into grandparents’ homes in Israel.

UNRWA Wards By The Numbers

For the year ending December 2021, according to UNRWA, there were 6,539,844 Palestinian wards who accept services from the agency, of which 5,807,653 (89%) were “refugees” and another 732,191 (11%) were other people whom the UN thought deserved particular support. Of the 6.5m, 863,708 (13.2%) are above age 60, suggesting perhaps only 2.6% of the total, or 175,000 are actual refugees from 1948 who lost homes a few miles away in Israel, after they launched a war to destroy the Jewish state.

The total number of UNRWA Refugees jumped by about 2.5% by year end 2022 to 6.7 million, while the number of actual refugees continues to decline. The total for West Bank wards was around 1.12 million (16.7%) and in Gaza it was 1.76 million (26.3%), which means that around 43% of all UNRWA wards already live in the area of 1948 Palestine, just a few miles from where ancestors had lived.

The majority of UNRWA wards live in Jordan, about 2.55 million (38% of the total wards), and have Jordanian citizenship. Jordan had been part of the original Palestine Mandate in 1922, and then attacked Israel in 1948 and illegally annexed the eastern portion of Israel which became known as the “West Bank” in 1950. After expelling all Jews from the region, Jordan granted all non-Jews in the area citizenship in 1954. Jordan abandoned its claim on the “West Bank” in 1988, and began pulling its citizenship from Arabs in the region.

The balance of UNRWA wards live in Lebanon (557,300) and Syria (674,500).

UNRWA offices in Jerusalem (photo: First One Through)<
>
<
>
UNRWA Camps in the West Bank

Roughly 25% of UNRWA’s West Bank wards live in official UNRWA “camps”. There are 19 camps currently including:

UNRWA’s Jenin Terrorists

UNRWA’s camp in Jenin has long served as the launching point for terrorists as well as a safe haven for murderers.

2002 Massacre

On March 27, 2002, roughly 250 people sat down for a festive holiday seder meal for Passover in the Park Hotel in Netanya along the Mediterranean Sea. A 25-year old member of Hamas from the nearby West Bank city of Tulkarm walked into the hotel and blew himself up, killing 30 and injuring 140. Hamas praised the attack and said Israelis “have to expect those attacks from everywhere, from every Palestinian group.” The Palestinian Authority named a soccer tournament after the terrorist the next year.

In response to the attack, part of a wave of Palestinian terrorism that killed 135 Israeli civilians in that month, Israel launched Operation Defensive Shield a few days later. From April 1-11, the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) entered the Jenin Camp which was home base of many of the killers. Rather than bomb the area from the air which might have resulted in the injury of Arab civilians, the IDF deployed infantry into the narrow streets. Palestinian militants set boobytraps which killed and maimed over a dozens soldiers, so the IDF brought in armored bulldozers to clear them out. The militants surrendered on April 11 and the IDF cleared out of the area the following week, but not before losing 23 soldiers.

Center of Jenin Camp in April 2002, cleared of wanted militants, land mines and boobytraps<
>
<
>
June and July, 2023 IDF Incursions for Jenin Camp Terrorists

The Jenin Camp was long been a stronghold of the political-terrorist group Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad. In September 2021, a new group called the Jenin Brigades was formed and it was soon accompanied by the Lion’s Den. The terrorists groups committed in excess of 50 attacks against Israeli civilians and soldiers, many attacks staged under the umbrella of UNRWA.

On June 19, the IDF came to arrest two UNRWA ward terrorists. As the Jenin Brigades open fire on the IDF, the Israelis responded with live fire. Eight Palestinian gunmen were killed, most of them confirmed terrorists. UNRWA confirmed that the majority were wards under its care.

As the IDF left the camp, the terrorists detonated a roadside bomb under an Israeli armored vehicle, wounding eight soldiers. Israel deployed a gunship helicopter to help rescue the soldiers from the hornet’s nest.

After yet additional terrorist attacks on Israeli civilians, Israel launched another incursion into the camp on July 3rd. The 48 hour operation once again focused on a small section of the UNRWA camp, where the IDF removed Palestinian terrorists, weapons and weapon-making factories.

UNRWA Ward Terrorists

The high percentage of UNRWA wards who are terrorists goes to the heart of the conflict: it is not about “occupation” or lack of sovereignty, as these people are in Palestine and under Palestinian rule. These terrorists have been told by the United Nations that they are entitled to move into homes where grandparents used to live inside of Israel. They are frustrated by the failure to get their “right of return” which the global body has promised.



Entrance to UNRWA refugee camp as a keyhole with a key on top, demonstrating that the pathway to homes inside Israel is via UNRWA.<
>
<
>
The United Nations has incubated a destructive cult mentality which is leading to terrorism and death. It is well past time to shut UNRWA, and the first camps to be shuttered are those under Palestinian rule, the launching pads in Gaza and the West Bank.

Related articles:

The Growth of UNRWA’s “Other” Wards

Time to Dissolve Key Principles of the “Inalienable Rights of Palestinians”

Help Refugees: Shut the UNRWA, Fund the UNHCR

Stabbing the Palestinian “Right of Return”

“Politics Aside,” It’s All Politics for UNRWA

Related music video:

The 2002 Massacres of Netanya and Jenin (music by Gorecki)

Observation: Tel Aviv police chief Amichai Eshed clueless – thought alternative was breaking bones rather than ARRESTING Kaplan dictators

 5 July 2023

“I could have easily used disproportionate force and filled the ER at
Ichilov [Medical Center] at the end of every demonstration in Tel Aviv. We
could have cleared Ayalon [Highway] within minutes at the terrible cost of
cracking heads and breaking bones, at the cost of breaking the pact between
police and the citizenry…as a commander I taught generations of policemen
to recognize the limits of force, to safeguard our contract with the public…
Unfortunately, for the first time in my three decades of service, I was met
with the bizarre reality that calm and order are not the desired goal, but
rather the opposite is.”

Tel Aviv police chief Amichai Eshed announcing his resignation

Amichai Eshed asserts that the choice was between:

Option #1: Allowing Kaplan dictators to block roads – thus violating his
“contract with the public” to assure that REST OF THE PUBLIC the freedom of
movement which is recognized as a BASIC RIGHT in Article 13 of the
Universal Declaration of Human Rights: “Everyone has the right to freedom of
movement” .

or

Option #2: Cracking heads and breaking bones

Amichai Eshed is CLUELESS.

There was ALWAYS another option:  ENFORCING THE LAW.

And by ENFORCING THE LAW I mean ARRESTING EVERYONE BLOCKING THE ROAD
regardless of the time that it takes.

Let every Kaplan dictator burn hours or even days being processed before
being released.

Let every Kaplan dictator find themselves spending a lot of time within the
court system.

And let every Kaplan dictator who did enough to spend time in jail instead
of just face a fine spend time in jail.

Let us be clear what has happened after the police allowed the Kaplan
dictators invade Terminal 3 and effectively close off Ben Gurion Airport:

The Kaplan dictators have tasted blood and they like it.

I have spoken with Kaplan dictators today to see if there are any red lines.

So I asked if they can invade a hospital emergency room with their protest.

“Why not” was the response.

I asked one if it would be ok to hold a protest in front of a fire house so
that the fire trucks can’t get out.

“Sure”.

Good Israelis have now been brainwashed by the favorable media coverage to
accept the behavior of the Kaplan dictators.

And unfortunately, a lot of people are silent.

Naftali Bennett, for example, was busy patting himself on the back on
Twitter for his BBC interview today but never found the time to write even a
sentence against the actions of the Kaplan dictators.  It doesn’t matter if
he has some poll that shows he would lose some supporters in the next
elections if he opened his mouth against road blockers and airport invaders.
The true test of leadership is when you do the right thing simply because it’s
the right thing.

Bennett’s not alone.  There are all kinds of public leaders who remain
silent.  Including of course President Herzog.

And of course – Prime Minister Netanyahu has declined to take a strong
public stand for the police to finally do their job in dealing with the
Kaplan dictators.

We cannot afford for this leadership void to continue.

Will France do what it demands of Israel?

There’s a meme making the rounds, showing a tricolored map of France in blue, white and red, only it has a jagged black line running through the middle from north to south. 

Accompanying this image is the following message, referring to Sharia-supremacist rioting across the country in recent days: “This attack only underscores the need for France to immediately engage in negotiations with French Muslims that will result in the creation of two states for two peoples, living side by side in peace and security, with Paris as a shared capital.” 

The question occurs: How long will it be before enemies of France demand such an outcome? Improbable as it may seem, the answer likely is “Not long.” That’s especially so since President Emanuel Macron and his predecessors have been the most insistent in demanding that Israel follow precisely this suicidal advice.

This is Frank Gaffney.

Heads in the sand

According to a popular and widely accepted myth, it is believed that ostriches spend a large part of their day with their head in the sand.

In actual fact this is a fallacy.

The only forms of life which, in reality, often seem to bury their head in the sand are humans.

Continuing to vote for political parties which habitually take the side of Israel bashers is a classic case. Pretending that the victim is to blame and, therefore, somehow deserves everything directed at it is another symptom. Joining the lynch gangs in the vain hope that this will deflect attention and gain approval is an old failing tactic. History should have taught us that self-flagellation and attempted assimilation never work in the long run.

This past week has provided yet more examples of what happens when reality is distorted and deliberately manipulated.

These are just a few samples that are worth noting.

Advocates of a post-Shoah secure Jewish future in Europe make much of the fact that the return of Jews to Germany and the resurrection of decimated communities there and in other countries on the continent proves we have triumphed over evil. The largest Jewish communal centre since pre-Shoah times has been opened in Berlin. This has been heralded as a wonderful renaissance of Jewish life in a country where 90,000 Jews are affiliated with a communal organisation and 100,000 are unaffiliated. In the same breath, as communal leaders celebrate the dedication of the US$43.7 million edifice and wax lyrically about Jews returning to the fatherland, one can discern some discordant signs.

Efforts to ban Shechitah and Brit Milah in Europe continue and the increasing popularity of political parties with dubious past histories as far as Jews are concerned all point to trouble ahead.

The German antisemitism Commissioner has declared “that German schools must teach that Jews belong in our country”. Based on the recent past one can assume that this will be a wasted exercise in shutting the stable doors after the racist horses have bolted.

In a report to the Austrian Parliament, it was revealed that, based on data collected, one-third of Austrians think Jews are trying to take advantage of the Nazi era while forty-seven percent think that Jews have too much power in the country. More than one third of Austrians think Jews dominate the international business world.

Meanwhile, it is reported from the Netherlands that one in ten Dutch teachers encounter students who deny that the Shoah ever occurred.

One of the best examples of “head in the sand” syndrome is the statement by the President of the EU Union of Jewish students on whether Jews in Europe have any future. She remarked that “she is confident that European Jews will continue and become stronger than ever. As much as antisemitism is a threat, it is also part of the European Jewish identity for better or worse. It makes Jewish communities resilient and active.”

I have yet to discover anything more detached from the grim realities of rising Judeophobia. It is the same hallucinatory conclusions that communal leaders, lay and religious, spouted pre 1939. A report released earlier this year stated “antisemitism has been rising in Germany since the country’s reunification in the 1990s. In the modern day, antisemitism takes many forms, including hate speech, violent attacks, and anti-Jewish conspiracy theories.”

It may not be politically correct to say so but the stark reality is that there is no future for identifying Jews anywhere in Europe, west or east. Increasing restrictions on religious life and rising hate combined with rampant assimilation will inevitably decimate even those who may think they are welcome citizens.

Meanwhile, “down under” another variation of the “head in sand” affliction has manifested itself.

The City Council of Wellington, New Zealand’s Capital, with the support of its Mayor, moved to enter into a “sisterly” relationship with Ramallah. A further proposal to recognize “Palestine” and light up the town hall with its national colours on Nakba Day was for the time being at least put on hold. The Mayor declared her intention to host a meeting with the “Palestinian” Ambassador to Australia in order presumably to express solidarity and support.  This decision by Greens and leftist progressives earned the enthusiastic support of a local group which described Wellington and Ramallah as being “remarkably similar.”

True to form, someone identifying as an “alternative Jewish voice” welcomed the advent of Ramallah to Wellington. This is a classic case of the intended victim embracing her eventual fate.

As a Jewish Israeli, if I was ever to set foot in Ramallah, I would be lynched by the “peace-loving” gangs there. However, for woke progressives, facts like that are seemingly irrelevant.

The official slogan by of the Wellington City Council is “LET’S GET WELLINGTON MOVING” which reads more like an advertisement for laxatives. According to news reports, with potholes galore, failing water infrastructure and burst water pipes, gang violence and robberies commonplace, transport chaos, one would think that those elected to run the city might have more important challenges. Instead of obsessing about things which show their ignorance and cluelessness, they should be busy fixing all the major problems in their own backyard.

Meanwhile, back on ground zero here in Israel, the sight of Jews settling in their historical homeland causes international anguish and sleepless nights.

President Herzog has rung PA President for life, Abbas, and asked him to do something to prevent further terror attacks against Israeli civilians.

While this request may possibly gain a few brownie points from the White House, the State Department, the EU and the UN Secretary General its general effect will be zero. The media no doubt has already ignored or buried this news item.

I have lost count of the number of times that Israeli as well as Diaspora Jewish spokespersons have trodden this same failed path.

How on earth can any intelligent person believe that an individual who stands up in front of the UN General Assembly and spouts slanderous lies about Israel will actually do anything to rein in the terror gangs now running the PA and associated groups?  If you read the incitement pouring forth on a daily basis from Ramallah and Gaza you will immediately understand why appealing to the likes of Abbas and his partners in crime is a futile and self-defeating exercise. It merely reinforces in the warped minds of those concerned that Israel is desperate and weak.

The facilitators of terror and delegitimizers of Jewish sovereignty only understand one language and it certainly is not pleading telephone calls asking them to suddenly transform into paragons of tolerance.

If all those who currently are unable to see reality were to actually open their eyes and unblock their ears progress towards genuine peace might be made.

Unless and until that occurs it is imperative to expose the lies, double standards and hypocrisy as well as settling in greater numbers in our Promised Land.

Michael Kuttner is a Jewish New Zealander who for many years was actively involved with various communal organisations connected to Judaism and Israel. He now lives in Israel and is J-Wire’s correspondent in the region.

Netanyahu: Preserving A State Of Terror

Recent reports in the Jewish Chronicle have shed light on a disheartening development within Israeli politics.

Prime Minister Benyamin Netanyahu, during a briefing at the Israel Knesset Parliament Foreign Affairs and Security Committee, declared that the Palestinian Authority (PA), operating under the umbrella of the PLO, a designated terrorist organization, “must be preserved.” This statement raises serious concerns, considering the PA’s role in promoting terrorism, denouncing Israel’s legitimacy, and its complicity in armed attacks against Jewish civilians.

It is alarming to note that the PA school system has become a breeding ground for terrorism, perpetuating a cycle of violence. Furthermore, the PA consistently denounces the legitimacy of a Jewish state in various international forums, exhibiting a refusal to recognize Israel’s right to exist. The PA’s actions, including its involvement in armed attacks against Israeli citizens, are indicative of a state of war rather than a commitment to peace.

Even more concerning is the active participation of the Palestine Security Forces (PSF), trained by Israel to assist the IDF, in hundreds of armed attacks against Jewish individuals traveling on highways. The confirmation by senior Israel Cabinet Minister Avi Dichter, who formerly headed the Shabak General Security Services, underscores the gravity of the situation. It is disheartening to see the mainstream entity of the PA, Fatah, reporting directly to PA leader Machmud Abbas, involved in such acts of violence.

The most distressing aspect is the PA’s daily praise of murder attacks in real-time, glorifying the senseless loss of innocent lives. This includes the recent petrol station attack on four unarmed Jews in June. Yet, Prime Minister Netanyahu’s statement suggesting the preservation of the PA raises concerns that Israel may tolerate a permanent state of war within its own borders, given the PLO’s endorsement of violence against Jews on both sides of the pre-1967 armistice lines.

As a veteran journalist, I sought to test the reality of the situation. I asked Prime Minister Netanyahu’s office if they had demanded the repeal of the PA’s law that provides a lifetime salary for anyone who murders a Jew or for the family of someone killed while attempting to murder a Jew. While his spokesman claimed that such demands had been made, I requested documentation to support this assertion.

Unfortunately, despite extending the deadline for submission of this article, there was no response from the Prime Minister’s spokesman. The failure to provide documentation raises serious doubts about the government’s efforts to address the PA’s incentivized violence, where individuals are rewarded for acts of terror.

It is essential that Israel takes a firm stand against the PA’s incitement and incentivization of violence. Repealing the law that rewards murderers and their families must be a priority. Prime Minister Netanyahu’s silence on this matter is deeply troubling, as it sends a message that such actions may go unchallenged. The international community must also hold the PA accountable for its incitement, ensuring that steps are taken to promote peace and discourage violence.

Peace cannot be achieved while one side perpetuates a culture of total war and rewards acts of terror. It is imperative that Israel, as well as the international community, condemn the PA’s incitement and demand the repeal of laws that incentivize violence. Only by taking a strong stance against the PA’s dangerous actions can we hope to pave the way for genuine peace and security in the region.

Prime Minister Netanyahu must recognize the urgency of addressing the PA’s incitement and incentivized violence. It is imperative for the Israeli government to unequivocally demand the repeal of the law that rewards murderers and their families. Failure to do so not only perpetuate a cycle of violence but also undermines the prospects for a meaningful and lasting peace process.

The international community must also play a role in holding the Palestinian Authority accountable for its actions. It is crucial for world leaders and organizations to condemn the incitement and incentivization of violence, urging the PA to take concrete steps towards promoting peace, dialogue, and reconciliation.

It is deeply concerning that Prime Minister Netanyahu’s failure to address the PA’s dangerous actions raises doubts about Israel’s commitment to combatting terrorism and fostering peace. The incitement and incentivized violence perpetuated by the Palestinian Authority must not be overlooked or tolerated. It is essential for Israel, supported by the international community, to take decisive action in demanding the repeal of the PA’s laws that promote and reward acts of terror. Only through a united front against violence and incitement can we hope to create a future where Israelis and Palestinians can live in peace, security, and mutual respect.

Canada has committed more money to Palestinian refugee agency UNRWA, amid concerns about oversight

Canada has committed more money—up to $100 million over four years—to the United Nations agency responsible for the welfare of Palestinian refugees.

The announcement of new funding to the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA) came June 26 in a statement from Harjit Sajjan, minister of international development.

The latest allocation is meant to deliver “core programs that support basic education, health, social services and livelihood opportunities and protect the rights of Palestinian refugees,” the statement from Sajjan’s office said.

Canada, it added, is also providing $3 million to UNRWA’s Emergency Appeal for the West Bank and Gaza “to ensure the delivery of humanitarian assistance for basic services,” such as emergency food aid, health services and improved water and sanitation access.

The latest round of funds responds “to the rising needs and deteriorating conditions” faced by Palestinian refugees in the West Bank, Gaza, Syria, Lebanon and Jordan.

The new money is in addition to the $90 million Canada committed to UNRWA from 2019 until now.

The agency has been a magnet for controversy over the years because of its alleged ties to terrorist groups, use of hateful teaching materials in UNRWA-run schools, and reports of corruption in the agency’s administration.

Under former Conservative Prime Minister Stephen Harper, Canada’s contribution to UNRWA dropped to $19 million by 2009, but only to the emergency appeal for food and jobs, and nothing to the general fund, over concerns about the agency’s ties to Hamas.

That year, a study by the Center for Near East Policy Research in Israel found that Hamas, which Canada considers a terrorist group, was elected to run the UNRWA Workers Union and UNRWA teachers association.

The Trudeau Liberals reinstated full funding to UNRWA in 2016.

The following year, Canada and UNRWA signed a joint “Framework for Cooperation” outlining Ottawa’s expectations regarding UNRWA’s reform initiatives, regular monitoring and reporting, compliance with Canadian anti-terrorism requirements, and other oversight measures.

The document called on UNRWA to address “inappropriate” use of social media by its staff and to review curricula in schools the agency runs to ensure they are in line with “UN values and principles, including those that relate to neutrality.”

Sajjan pledged that Canada will “continue to exercise enhanced due diligence for all humanitarian and development assistance funding for Palestinians. This work includes ongoing oversight, regular site visits, a systematic screening process, and strong anti-terrorism provisions in funding agreements.”

In 2021, Canada said it would not suspend funding to UNRWA, pending an investigation into how anti-Israel, pro-violence teaching materials found their way into Palestinian schools.

That stemmed from a report by an Israeli non-profit group which found that teaching materials distributed by UNRWA to Palestinian children in Gaza and the West Bank between November 2020 and January 2021 contained incitement to violence; demonization of Israel, which was erased from maps; endorsements of jihad and martyrdom; the promulgation of “libels and conspiracies;” and failure to promote peacemaking.

Classroom materials referred to Israel solely as “the Enemy” or “the Israeli Occupation,” the Israeli study had found.

UNRWA said it pulled the offending material, saying it had been distributed in error.

Palestinian refugees face high rates of poverty, food insecurity and unemployment, Sajjan noted in his statement. In Syria, for example, 91 percent of Palestinian refugee households live in “absolute poverty.” In Lebanon, more than 89 percent of Palestinian refugees displaced from Syria are “in critical need of sustained humanitarian assistance,” the minister said.

The Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs (CJIA) said it supports “legitimate Canadian government efforts to assist Palestinians in providing measures such as food security and healthcare.”

However, CIJA remains concerned about “continued incidents of incitement by UNRWA staff, their ongoing support of terrorism, and their development and use of problematic educational materials,” David Cooper, CIJA’s vice-president of government relations, told The CJN.

“For these reasons, we agree with Canada’s enhanced due diligence and other oversight mechanisms to ensure aid is provided to the most vulnerable populations and is neither misappropriated by terror groups nor used to fund hatred,” Cooper added.

In a statement, the Toronto-based Abraham Global Peace Initiative (AGPI) expressed “profound disappointment” over the funding announcement. In light of recent terror attacks against Israelis, the group said it had called for a moratorium on any further funding to the Palestinian Authority and Gaza through UNRWA “until such time as the infamous pay-for-slay program run by the Palestinian Authority is cancelled. The program incentivizes Palestinians to carry out terror attacks against Israelis.”

Canadians for Justice and Peace in the Middle East, which supports the boycott movement against Israel, said it welcomes the renewal of Canada’s funding to Palestinian refugees but is disappointed that the latest pledge represents an annual cut of $5 million.